Lewis Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lewis bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Fort Lewis housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

POLL: Spank your kids?

who's talking here?

IMissNCSooooMuch 1
~Tanya~ 1
HisGoddess 1
Krista 1
Shelley 1
Frankie 1
SSGWife 2
MelissaM 1
mobo54 1
Yep i finally popped Aug 13th 1
Katena 1
mommato3 1
Apple Pie 1
Zolees Momma 1
Sandra 1
Shutterbug 1
Carmella 2
scottswife 1
Maui Girl 1
Neci 1
BrendaE 1
The mommy 1
NadaSuperstar 1
Miggs wifey 1
I AM ME 1
Aviator Wife 2
Mrs know it all 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

POLL: Spank your kids?

what are your thoughts?

yes I have Vote
 
 94.4% (68)
no I havent, but I believe I could if needed Vote
 
 5.6% (4)
and destroy them forever, no way Vote
 
 0.0% (0)
Mrs know it all --- 15 years ago -

what are your thoughts? 

SSGWife --- 15 years ago -

Saying NO doesnt work
Corner doesn't work
Taking away toys, treats, ect.. doesn't work



Depends on which kid it is..
Spanking 1 out of my 5 doesn't work
The other 4 it works but I don't beat them... 

Mrs know it all --- 15 years ago -

Were you all spanked as a child? 

Neci --- 15 years ago -

Well, I can't say I've spanked my kids, because mine is still in the womb. HOWEVER, we grew up getting spankings and I've spanked my sister's kids. I think a good firm wack on the rear end when they refuse to listen is perfectly fine. Don't beat them, but just because you say No 50 times doesn't mean they will stop. They need to know you mean business. My brother and his first son play kinda rough so when he gets a wack on the butt he laughs, but popping his hands and telling him No works.

You just have to figure out what works and what doesn't. 

Apple Pie --- 15 years ago -

I don't have kids but if I had them I would, if it was necessary. 

Aviator Wife --- 15 years ago -

It depends on what happened. I don't spank, but one time my little girl ran across the street and daddy gave her a big one on the behind right there and then and told her why she got spanked. She learned her lesson that day. 

mommato3 --- 15 years ago -

My 5 year old doesn't respond to anything but once slap on the bottom and she is a angel.

Now my boys on listens right away while his twin needs a smack on the bottom. 

Sandra --- 15 years ago -

All kids are different though, my oldest two got a fair share, my youngest gets spanked maybe once a year, usually a swat on the bootie and that gets the point. Taking away favorites works miracles. The biggest I did was take away the DS(put in box w/charger) for a whole month it was a blessing in disguise, my son rarely shows interest in it anymore! 

Aviator Wife --- 15 years ago -

Oh and I was spanked as a kid by my dad. He even had a spanking tool. My sister and I would hide it and that would make him more mad. I turned out OK. ;) 

MelissaM --- 15 years ago -

I was never spanked and I will never spank my kids. We do time out and we talk with out little ones from a young age :-)

I personally think there are much better ways to discipline children without resorting to hitting or spanking. I've never seen a spank work affectively. But to each their own ya know 

Maui Girl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

My dad beat us as kids. But that's another story. I wrote a whole research paper on spanking and its negative effects when I started college, and then I had kids. I was extremely patient with my first child, but when I had my second, patience kind of just left the building. My fuse is much shorter now, so when I say things once, I expect my kids to follow through. It's definitely in their nature not to because let's face it: They're 2 and 4. There's a lot I don't spank for, and we do utilize time outs and talk-it-outs. But I will not tolerate smart mouths (4 year old) or blatant defiance and rolling of the eyes (2 yr old). There are a lot of obvious consequences we've been utilizing for things that we used to spank for. Things like when they splash water all over the bathroom floor when taking a bath and making them clean it up. Spilled the dog water all over the floor? Make them clean it up and then remove the water bowl from the equation. Yeah....we're working on improving our parenting skills, but I still say some kids, sometimes, do deserve a smack on the rear. 

SSGWife --- 15 years ago -

Yeap I was spanked as a kid.

Belt
Spoon
Switch
N more than that 

Krista --- 15 years ago -

When I was growing up I got spanked occasionally. I had to mess up pretty good or repeatedly to get spanked, but I think it worked. I either didn't do it again, or I made damn sure I didn't get caught again. I do spank my kid, but not very often because when I was with my mom as a child she went overboard with a lot of spankings and what not. 

~Tanya~ --- 15 years ago -

I rarely got spanked as a kid, but when I did, I stopped whatever it was I was doing wrong. Not from fear, but because I knew Mom meant business.

I spanked my oldest. Maybe too much to be effective. (you know what they say about your 1st being the practice to do everything "wrong") He's too old for spankings IMO now, so I just take things away and ground him. My middle one gets a spank maybe once every three months. Maybe. Just making us upset ruins her entire day.
My youngest, I get creative with because if I spanked her, even for "much needed spankings" that girl would be beat because she's ALWAYS doing something wrong somewhere. So for her I get creative and that's effective. So... each kid of mine is different and different disciplines work for them. 

Katena --- 15 years ago -

I do spank my kids and I also was beaten as a child. I have used a wooded spoon and belt. My boys usually straighten right up when I mentioned it and eveyone has a wooden spoon. I agree with Amamda taking away certain things,saying no and time out does not work. To each its own I do not beat my kids. For my older children taking away things does work but the younger 3 dont quite understand yet. 

Shelley --- 15 years ago -

got spanked as a kid with a belt, but my kids have only been spanked with a hand, as they got older, grounding from electronics or friends was more effective 

I AM ME --- 15 years ago -

i spank both mine... but i make sure i tell them what they did wrong before i do it so they know WHY there getting a spankin.. and sometimes it depends i also do time out ( works sometimes ) 

BrendaE --- 15 years ago -

I spank but rarely but I will never hit my kids with an object..spoon, belt, etc.. I am not going to leave a mark on my child, that's crossing the line. I was beaten and choked and all sorts more,hit with anything within reach. I just won't ever go there. 

Shutterbug --- 15 years ago -

I've spanked, but we try to correct the problem in other ways first. First, we try talking, then time-outs, grounding, taking things away, etc... if it's something that really warrants a spanking, then we will give it, and let them know why we spanked them right then. 

Zolees Momma --- 15 years ago -

I am so glad this topic came up. Sometimes I feel like I'm going to be a bad parents b/c I've had this talk with friends that are completely against spanking, and I feel like they look at me negatively. But reading all of these comments makes me feel so much better.

As a kid, we were disciplined many different ways. Spankings, back hands, belts, wooden spoons, standing in the corner, grounded, had things taken away, soap in the mouth. My favorite though, when it was a fight between me and my brothers, my babysitter made us sit down across from each other and stare at each other til we weren't mad anymore. We weren't allowed to talk either. And within a few minutes we would be making faces at each other and laughing. Then we were allowed to play again.

I do think all kids respond differently to each discipline. And sometimes, spankings are the only thing that will work. I hope I don't ever have to do it, but I will if need be. 

NadaSuperstar --- 15 years ago -

My son has a natural hearing block when you ask him not to do something...time outs work sometimes...other times..he just needs a firm hand. 

The mommy --- 15 years ago -

I spank as a last resort.I spank but not hard enough to leave a red mark.


I drove past someones house the other day ans seen a woman beating the crap out of a kid...I was serously thinking about turning her @ss in. 

Carmella --- 15 years ago -

Agree gdm. 

Yep i finally popped Aug 13th --- 15 years ago -

i feel that should the occasion arise..a firm swat on the butt ins ok..but you should never leave any marks because if you do then you spanked a bit to hard...now my a$$ was grass if i messed up growing up...my dad made a hand carved paddle that even had a handle..i would never do that to my kids....but a bare handed swat..and even a pop on the hand when they are little..if you wait until they are like 5 to teach them you are in charge..good luck ever gaining their respect..also when my 2.5 year old swears or bites someone he gets a lite pop in the mouth..nothing to ever hurt him but just enough to scare him.... 

Carmella --- 15 years ago -

Prego/zach: my parents had a home made paddle to. It broke so they switched to kitchen spoons! 

Mrs know it all --- 15 years ago -

I dont remember much about being spanked as a kid. But I have open hand spanked my kids. They are too old now, taking toys, video games and play time with friends works now. But I am such a sucker, it.doesnt last long. 

IMissNCSooooMuch --- 15 years ago -

My mom beat my A$$ when I was little up until I moved out at 18(child abuse) not spankings. I do spank, however, only as a last resort, and only for last resort. I have very rarely had to spank. I never wanted them to grow up the way I did, yet I don;t want them runnin all over folks either, so it is ther as an option and they know my "Angry EyeS!"(hahaha Toy Story) SO they know they better straighten up and listen, or they will be corrected and punished. If that fails, a spank will follow along with time out in their room to reflect on what they did. Then I always talk to them individually to make sure they relaize why tey were spanked, what they should have done, what can be done next time to avoid it. SO far so good. 

Miggs wifey --- 15 years ago -

I have two kid's and my daughter is 2 when you tell her no she stops and listens. My 5 year old has adhd and nothing else works for him so when he gets outta control a spank on the rear and we mean business. I got yelled at in walmart by a lady for spanking his butt because he opened a candy bar after me telling him not to touch it. I looked at her and said if yo ucan do a better job go for it, she backed off.I think people are way to uptight about discipline and I am glad someone brought this up because it's a topic that never gets talked about! 

mobo54 --- 15 years ago -

I believe in spanking however, I do not have to do this very often. I will tell ya now, when you have a 12 year old who is pushing you within every inch of your being, you are gonna want to spank his a@@!! I have grounded this child for the past month and nothing is helping, so now he is going to counseling as a last resort. This crap all started as I have let him have more friends than usual. A year ago, I could honestly say that I have very well behaved, respectful children. Now, I feel like I have no control. The worst part is, my son comes home and tells me about these kids in school telling the counselor that their parents are beating them when they are not!!! Just to get out of their own home for a bit with no rules. I think times are really sad for parents these days. It is so hard to discipline your children anymore without a negative consequence. If you drive by someone's home and see a parent spanking a child, you should not assume the worst because you have no clue the circumstances. That child could have raised a hand to that parent or it could have been even worse. I kept an 8 year old child one time who threatened to kill my entire family because he didn't like rules. Needless to say, that was the last time I kept him. 

Frankie --- 15 years ago -

Was never spanked as a kid, and I don't like doing it now. I talk to them and do time outs after the 1st warning. My husband believes in spanking, but only does it as a last resort. I can't hit (spank) my kids for hitting another kid or being mean to them, bc I'm practically doing the same thing. They learn everything from us, we're figuring this out with our 3 yr old now. So we've learned to take a step back and really watch our actions around her so that she doesn't do the same and teach her brother later on. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lewis Underground