Lewis Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lewis bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Fort Lewis housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

OPSEC question...

who's talking here?

Megan LeeAnne 1
rachel613 1
Are we done yet 1
Shelley S 1
details 1
AwesomeSauce 1
Alyyy 1
ColoradoNative 1
Aubogon 1
Bens Mama 2
OnARoll 1
a3719110uu 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Bens Mama --- 13 years ago -

So a soldier from here posted on his "political fan page" (i guess thats what you call it) the he is returning home from Afghanistan tomorrow. This page is completely public and it has 544 people on it. He pissed off another page with 60,000 followers and got his information even further put out there. His profile picture is him in a stryker in all his gear. All I can say is thankfully the picture doesn't show his unit. So question is...is this something to be concerned about?? I would hate to sit back and do nothing and something potentially horrible happen. I reported the post...but it hasn't been removed. Thoughts? 

ColoradoNative --- 13 years ago -

As far as I know, any information pertaining to homecoming is an OPSEC violation, but I can't remember if it's okay if the soldier is already "in transit" (meaning out of country and on the way). I kind of doubt it, but I really can't remember... when it comes to stuff like that, I play it pretty safe and avoid it altogether. The closest I get is "Can't wait - husband will be home soon!" or just post something about it after he's already home - mostly for all of our friends and extended family that we don't call often. 

AwesomeSauce --- 13 years ago -

That is a violation. He should know better. I never said dates, just said "soon" or posted when he got home :) 

rachel613 --- 13 years ago -

Not to defend the guy but there are a couple companies that put out a number to call about inbound flights. It is posted online. Yes what he did is wrong however people can figure it if they knew the right info to look up. 

Are we done yet --- 13 years ago -

At ft riley they post home coming ceremonies on their web page before the soldiers have even left. The units fb page will post before they gave even left. I'm not one to post anythoing like that but I have always been told when its been posted by unit or on the bases we page then its ok for you to post. I disagree because like I said most the time that info in these pages are posted before they even leave country 

a3719110uu --- 13 years ago -

With OPSEC you are not allowed to say "Who , what, when, where, and why". When my husband was coming home from the last deployment, we weren't allowed to say he was coming home to anybody until they had landed in Germany. I didn't tell anyone when he was coming home, not even my kids.

People really need to be careful of what they put on Facebook. 

Bens Mama --- 13 years ago -

Thanks!!! :) I know that some units put out the information and all that...but that still doesn't mean it should be shouted to the world! I see what you are saying though! It just seems to me that the less people that know about it...the less chance that something bad would happen. I guess its a mute point now since they got home today...but I guess food for thought for later on! 

Alyyy --- 13 years ago -

Is it responsible for the news to post this, i can see this being protected by freedom of speech. But if something were to happen due to posting this are they held liable? i feel like that is WAAY to much information.

returning soldiers 

OnARoll --- 13 years ago -

idk. it's tomorrow, which means they are already en route 

details --- 13 years ago -

It just seems to me that the less people that know about it...the less chance that something bad would happen.

I 100% agree with this. But I also think that if someone really wanted to know about troop movement there would be way easier ways to find out before trolling Facebook. And technically just posting here about it sort of lets more people know, right?

The whole "my husband is coming home tomorrow" stuff on FB doesn't bother me. I was more annoyed when my husband was somewhere doing something supposedly top secret that he couldn't even tell me all the details about, and I read all about it in a newspaper article. They even gave out the freaking GPS coordinates of where we were constructing something. The article has since been scrubbed from the internet as best as I can tell, but you better believe I had that reporters name and if anything were to have happened I would've found that a**hole. The media puts stuff like that out there all the time. 

Megan LeeAnne --- 13 years ago -

The newspaper and news always announce when they are returning 1-2 days earlly. Even if you go to the gyms regularly you'll notice signs 3-4 days in advance that part is not open due to a homecoming. 

Aubogon --- 13 years ago -

So a soldier from here posted on his "political fan page" (i guess thats what you call it) the he is returning home from Afghanistan tomorrow. This page is completely public and it has 544 people on it. He pissed off another page with 60,000 followers and got his information even further put out there. His profile picture is him in a stryker in all his gear. All I can say is thankfully the picture doesn't show his unit. So question is...is this something to be concerned about?? I would hate to sit back and do nothing and something potentially horrible happen. I reported the post...but it hasn't been removed. Thoughts?


Chances are he is friends with other people in his unit. It's their job to deal with OPSEC violations not ours. You reported it that is all you can do 

Shelley S --- 13 years ago -

I've never liked that the news puts it out early, I would rather they waited until they were actually home. I too feel like if someone really wanted to know, it can be found out, but I agree with why take any chances as well. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lewis Underground