Lewis Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lewis bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Fort Lewis housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Child support payments?

who's talking here?

Misty P. 3
kristi 2
Megan LeeAnne 1
Megz 1
JoJo 3
babycakes 4
ellaella 2
just PINK 2
someonesangel 5
HeatherLynn 15
Yogis Mommy 1
DirtyBetty 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

HeatherLynn --- 15 years ago -

Ok so my husband has Been paying his ex girlfriend $379/mo for his daughter who lives in Michigan for 4 years since she's been born. He was an e1 when he received the revision, now he's unemployed as well as going to school. His unemployment is $437 a week before taxes are taken out and he receives e5 bah because he's in school, $1317 a month. So he technically is making more now than when he was in the army. Today we received an income revision request that we have to send back to Michigan state. We are really worried that our payments will go up and we can barely afford the $379 that we pay a month already. His ex doesn't have a job so i know that reflects on how much our payments are as well... I'm not even sure if the bah counts as income for calculation of child support or not? If anyone could give me any advice at all that would be fantastic 

just PINK --- 15 years ago -

its it up to that state/county/city if they will include bah. i feel you pain. praying for you 

HeatherLynn --- 15 years ago -

I'm soooo stressed out :( both my husband and I are students right now and $379 is the max we can afford really at the moment. are u in a similar situation? 

ellaella --- 15 years ago -

Its up to the state, some states dont do it others dont look up the laws for the state, maybe even contact an attorney.

but honestly it is his kid and well they look at it as he has to pay to support it.

Doesnt matter what we think on whats fair I sure dont spend 400 w food on two of my kids each month but the system sucks !


good luck ! 

kristi --- 15 years ago -

I dont think MI counts Bah do not count me on that. but they will look at both incomes for unemployment n his E5 pay. n since your unemployment is the same as ur E5 just be prepared to pay twice the amount. I would look at it that way i would defentaly contact a lawyer here n in MI ten bucks he might have to go back to MI to appear in court. Also where did he file the child support papers at cause that is where they will have to go back in and do the revision at? 

kristi --- 15 years ago -

Dont count me on any of it I would rather u expect the worse n it turn out better for u than expected. Im from MI n they so suck when it comes to stff like this. 

HeatherLynn --- 15 years ago -

Ella, yes I know this is his responsibility, i'm not trying to argue with anyone about that because we ARE taking responsibility. We are just trying to see if anyone else has gone through a similar situation.

Kristi- Thanks! I'm really hoping the BAH isn't counted as income for the calculation of the child support :( We are pretty worried. We looked up a child support calculator for michigan, and with his ex not having any income besides what the child support gives her, it calculated almost $600/mo! Holy crap :( We are pretty worried 

Megz --- 15 years ago -

I know in Fl they take both parents income into account. If either or neither parent works then child support is based upon minimum wage because they believe that anyone can find a min wage job. then child support is calculated 49% for the non custodial and 51% for the custodial (bc they get to claim on taxes) 

babycakes --- 15 years ago -

In Texas if you dont have a job they look at what you where making at your last job, and they count BAH. The fact if she has a job or not most of the time does not matter because it is not about her it is about him, I am going to go out on a limb and say your payments are going up, not sure by how much but pretty sure they are. 

babycakes --- 15 years ago -

Oh and the way the courts look at it he is capable of working so he should be working so that he can afford to pay his child support. 

Misty P. --- 15 years ago -

Most states, washington being one, will still count the parent that is not working as making minimum wage unless they can prove they are unable to work. My husbands ex is supposed to be paying...she does not have a job because she does not want to work and pay it...but the state said that since she is able to work and voluntarily chooses not too, they still put her down as making minimum wage. 

HeatherLynn --- 15 years ago -

Yes, he is going to school, so therefore he does not have to look for a job. He has NEVER missed a child support payment, but with him being unemployed and him not receiving the unemployment benefits for too long, we really can't afford the payments to go up ALOT.

Misty- His ex has epilepsy, but she works for her mother under the table in her daycare...So, proving that she IS able to have a job. But, because her job is under the table, our payments go up because she doesn't have a job.

I know a lot of people with epilepsy, and they have jobs :( Thanks for letting me vent everyone lol 

HeatherLynn --- 15 years ago -

I'm not sure if we are able to prove that she does have income through her mom's daycare, because of the fact that it is under the table?? hmm 

Misty P. --- 15 years ago -

you can tell the agency and they should investigate it...we thought his ex was getting paid that way...they told us if we could provide where we thought she was working...they would crack down on the employer 

Misty P. --- 15 years ago -

If she wants to prove she cant work she has to be receiving some kinda state aid because of it...thats what they told us 

HeatherLynn --- 15 years ago -

hmmm =\ I think I understand what you're saying lol, well she earns money at her mother's daycare that she runs out of her house.....so i'm not sure how we would go about doing that.... ugh this sucks!! lol

We wouldn't have ANY problem paying the amount we had to, if she had a JOB too, ya know? It should go both ways. We shouldn't have to pay more because she doesn't have a job, and chooses not to have one. Her husband stole from his job, got fired so now I don't think they have any income except for the child support we give them.....

Also, my husband doesn't have any custody, so I think if our payments DO go up, we will fight for joint custody, and fly her out here... at least for the summer. She's 4 so she's getting to the age where she may be able to fly alone? I'm not exactly sure what we're going to do, she lives in Michigan lol 

someonesangel --- 15 years ago -

Girl, I feel your pain! First off, the courts will look at anything that looks like someone is trying to "deceive" the court as pretty serious. Get as much "proof" as you can about her working under the table. I mean, she is not paying taxes on that, which is illegal. Have your lawyer bring up something proving how she survives with no income!!

My husband was unemployed when he got out five years ago, was paying 1,000 dollars! He actually came back in to be able to pay all that money. He proved that his ex was lying about taking his daughter to childcare. The judge was so mad that he almost threw her in jail for the night for lying under oath, and he made her pay all that money back. He even lower the payments by 600 bucks. I am pretty sure BAH is not included. Is his daughter under tricare? If yes, that also counts toward providing for his daughter which equals "x" amount of money. Heck, throw dental in their. I'm all for child support and supporting your child, but when the ex doesn't work or tries to collect more money because they are greedy, that's where I get mad. I think they should have to account for all expenses, and split it down the middle. 

HeatherLynn --- 15 years ago -

THANK YOU SOMEONESANGEL!!! I agree with you 100%%%% LOL I feel the exact same way!
Actually my husband isn't in the military anymore, he's been out since June 2011. I'm sure we can prove that she has income, although if it's working with her mother i'm sure it may be a little difficult =\

I looked on the michigan site for child support, and I think that BAH is included in "income" ugh :( It says we will pay around $500-$600 when I did the calculator for child support...We definitely can't afford it!! I have no idea what to do, so stressed :(

PLUS his ex is pregnant AGAIN ! With her new husband (he's a dirt bag by the way lol) 

someonesangel --- 15 years ago -

Hmmm.. do you have kids? You could play the angle that you have bills and obligations that with the increase it will be hard to provide for the children living under your roof. Print out all your bills, tally them up, and show how tight things are.
South Carolina doesn't include the BAH. If she has food stamps, government housing, etc that will be included in her "income" and what about the new husband? If he works, that should be included in their household income. 

HeatherLynn --- 15 years ago -

No, I don't have any kids...but because of all of this it may be cheaper to HAVE ONE! LMAO

I really hope Michigan doesn't include BAH, but I can't seem to find that info out anywhere on the net :(
My husband and I are both in school, so we are already struggling trying to get through school with good grades, while she doesn't even have a damn job, so how the hell is she contributing to society ya know?
I've heard that it's only the 2 parents involved that they count for income? So her husband and I wouldn't be included in the income.?

Hopefully that makes sense lol 

someonesangel --- 15 years ago -

Hm, so many technicalities. In that case, I should become a millionaire, have my husband stay home with the kids, so our child support payments are next to nothing! lol. In all seriousness, every judge is going to be different. All I can suggest is to be honest, and get as much data and proof as you can. If she works under the table, that is income, whether she has pay checks or not. The judge will take that into account. It sucks that BAH is included, but try to look at it as this is your way of providing for the child, even if you know she is using that money for herself. We pay almost 35% of our TAKE HOME pay to child support now. My best advice is not to hold any of the mother's greediness against the child. Good luck! 

DirtyBetty --- 15 years ago -

Her not claiming any income might work in your favor. If I worked and paid daycare my ex would owe me more in child support.

If you look at this:

http://courts.michigan.gov/scao/services/focb/mcsf.htm

It does say BAH can be counted towards calculating support in MI. That's from 2008 but I couldn't find anything more current.

Please don't take what I'm about to say next the wrong way...fight for custody of your stepchild because you love them and genuinely want them to spend more time with you. Or if you think she's in a situation where her Mom is not fit to care for her. Not because you want to avoid paying her Mom more support then you have to. What's the reason they don't share custody already? If the support payments are really creating a financial hardship there are ways to ask for a reduction in payments. Especially if he has other children he is supporting. I'm not saying you don't want your stepchild in your home but when you say you'll fight for custody if your payments go up that's what it comes across like.

My ex lives on east coast and we are here in WA. My kids fly to visit him about once a year (his choice). We fly back and forth with them. It costs a bundle but it's worth it because they get to spend time with him. 5 is the youngest I've ever heard of a minor flying without a parent. At that age you will probably have to pay the airline extra money for a flight attendant to accompany the child and you'll most likely have to book a non-stop flight. Living in different states it's going to be hard to share custody, and by hard I mean harder on the child, and maybe more expensive then you think. If she comes to live with you for any length of time you'll have to provide her with a room, clothing, food, your utilities will go up, pretty much all of your living expenses will increase. Kids aren't cheap. 

HeatherLynn --- 15 years ago -

Thanks for the advice :) I really appreciate it, seriously!!

Oh no, we are talking about filing for joint custody, that way we DO get to see her more. I wish all of this was a lot easier, and she lived closer. But because we are both in school, there's no way to pick up and move to Michigan (where my hubby is from). We don't have any other children, just her. And we both love her VERRRRY much!

Yeah, definitely kids aren't cheap. Which is why we want to wait to have children because we wan't to be able to provide them with everything they need!

Thanks for finding that Betty, the only one I found was from like 2004 lol, It sucks that BAH will be included :( But, I think we are going to investigate and find out if she still is working under the table with her mom, in that case she will have to provide the income to the state. There's no way she's only living on the child support, which is $379 at the moment! 

Megan LeeAnne --- 15 years ago -

I haven't read all of this but if you have kids they will take that in effect, also, with her not working it actually works in your favor, when my ex first had child support set up before they recieved my info they had it set where he paid lower, when they got my work info it raised due to me having to pay for child care to provide a stable home. Good luck. 

HeatherLynn --- 15 years ago -

Weird, we don't have any other children that we provide for. Are you saying that because she doesn't have income, that our payments will be lower? I've heard that because she doesn't have income, that our payments will be higher, because we will have to provide more for her? 

DirtyBetty --- 15 years ago -

Oh thank God you were not offended, lol! I really didn't want it to come across like that. I am glad you want to spend more time with her. I love that my husband loves my kids like his own. It amazes every time I look at them together. I honestly don't know if I could love another woman's child the way he loves my kids. I love all kids but that would just be hard for me. I have huge respect for women who can open their hearts like that. 

HeatherLynn --- 15 years ago -

Oh no girl, I posted this knowing that I would get the truth. :) I needed it honestly lol. Yeah, It was hard at first knowing that he had a child, but after I met her, I fell in love with her!! She's so cute, and only 4 so i'm so happy I get to be apart of her life :) I can't wait to have children, but I definitely want to wait until we both have good jobs, and can financially afford to have them lol .

I really hope our payments don't go up too much!! I thought about going to talk to an attorney, but I know they won't help much unless you pay them a TON of money :( lol ugh 

DirtyBetty --- 15 years ago -

Are you saying that because she doesn't have income, that our payments will be lower? I've heard that because she doesn't have income, that our payments will be higher, because we will have to provide more for her?

Maybe. If she can prove that she pays for childcare then your payment could increase. Mine would be higher if I paid daycare. I only know this because the divorce lawyer I originally had a consult with told me I should find a job and put my kids in daycare so my ex would owe me more. Eventually I filed the papers on my own (cheaper in WA) and when I did the support worksheets I calculated childcare just to see if it did make a difference, and it did. If I paid for daycare his payments would be higher.

A lot of lawyers will talk to you for free about child support and custody issues. Even if it's just over the phone or a very brief session. Some of the best divorce advice I ever got came from a divorce attorney in NC and I literally spent about 15 minutes in his office, including the time in the waiting room. But it was free, and good advice! 

HeatherLynn --- 15 years ago -

Wow, yeah I've had to speak with an attorney before over landlord issues lol but the attorney sucked, and basically didn't give an advice unless we paid like $300/hr :( So that sucked....hmmm well i'm sure she doesn't pay for child care since she doesn't work..So thank god for that! lol but we are going to try to investigate how much $$ she makes for working with her mother. Hopefully they will be able to investigate that too! 

HeatherLynn --- 15 years ago -

There's no way she's only living on $379/mo! 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lewis Underground