GROSS, if you are going to get a grocery store cake Safeway is the way to go! I think Commissary cakes taste and look cheap, they really don't taste well! I just had my daughters party and we did a safeway cake and every single person there raved about it.
I have bough commissary cakes in the past for different reasons and they aren't horrible...but Costco cakes are BY far the best. I do however, really love love love Eye Candy Cakes. I don't like to or have anything like everyone else and she makes that happen with her cakes! She is on vacation right now, but will be back at the end of the month. You can look her up on Facebook too =D
i have not had a bad experience with the commissary cakes. In fact i am a piggy and have gotten the small sheet cake for 7 bucks or something like that from the bakery just to eat for dessert a couple of times. Once we ordered a cake from safeway in lakewood it was pretty dry and the frosting tasted like cotton candy not the usual taste of buttercream which wasnt bad. I was a bit disappointed because I have had von's cakes which are so yummy. so it might have just been the one in lakewood.
I have gotten commissary cakes for all kids birthdays since we have been here. I have never had a bad cake. I would suggest getting the whipped frosting though because the other is just very sweet.
Commissary cake will make your tounge go backwards.... sorry I had to say it, my daughter tells me certain kids of food will do that to her tounge, it is a little alarming, I hope it never happens.
I am a picky b!tch when it comes to cake, I would choose Safeway, but the commissary does have a big selection of themes and characters.
"Commissary cake will make your tounge go backwards.... sorry I had to say it, my daughter tells me certain kids of food will do that to her tounge, it is a little alarming, I hope it never happens."
Hm I have ordered commissary cakes in the past and have loved them, I do whipped icing, not sure if that makes a difference or not. I like Safeway cakes too though.
I got my husband's promotion party cake at Safeway at the Town Center in Lakewood, but got my daughters graduation cake a few years ago at the commissary...must have been good, not much left of either cake lol
I have had cakes from all of the places mentioned. I dont think the Commissary is bad, you just have to get the whipped frosting like was mentioned or else to me they are way to sweet. The two cakes I got from safeway were DRY!! Costco is always a good choice! Love their red velvet. I actually picked up to take to a friends house tonight!
I always get the $7 commissary cakes for my kids' birthdays, since we do a little family party. It is just enough.
I have never had a problem with the cakes, they were always really good, to my taste. My kids prefer them to my cakes. But I guess that's not saying much.
def go Safeway over Comissary as someone said above. My son's bday is today the half sheets are on sake right now for $17.99, the same price as their quarter sheets! I ordered Thomas the Train and pick up tomorrow! Can't wait! They have always done a great job and the cakes are delish! We have had Star Wars, Kung Fu Panda, Sponge Bob, and a Lego Cake! They were all very nice and tasted moist and delish!
The bday cake I got for my hubs bday was dry and gross from the commissary! We each have a piece and he usually finishes up the rest of the cake in 2-3 days! That one got thrown away after 5 days of sitting around!