Lewis Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lewis bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Fort Lewis housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Andrea Yates, remember her?

who's talking here?

IMMoving 1
LovinMyLTBlocks 1
Katena 1
Apple Pie 2
Sandra 8
KristenP 1
Kathryn 8
proudjagwife 2
NadaSuperstar 2
armywife1026 1
babycakes 2
ellaella 2
Country Girl 2
what the 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Kathryn --- 15 years ago -

I was 16 years old when this happened, in my hometown, I will never forget.

Andrea Yates

I can not even fathom releasing her! UGH!! 

Katena --- 15 years ago -

wow is all I can say. i was pregnant wiith my 3rd son at the time. I was like was beautiful children snubbed away too soon. Now she sliving her life and wearing makeup she should stay put away forever. I understood mental illness but why does she deserve to live and the children are gone. I still beleive the father knew she was not totally right. 

Country Girl --- 15 years ago -

I used to work in the prison she was in and saw her frequently:( After seeing all the facts, I still cant wrap my head around it. The postpartum depression after each child that escalated or yet the state ignoring her pleas for help or the fact she drown each child one by one. Still hurts my stomach. 

babycakes --- 15 years ago -

IMO I feel she should go from there, since she is nolonger mentally ill, to a prison and serve a life sentence for all of her kids. I understand post partum, but She is still young enough tohave other children and who is to say she wont do the same to them. It sicken me to think she had to chase her oldest down becaue he had seen her drown the baby in the tub :( 

babycakes --- 15 years ago -

I agree that the dad had to of known but in his defense who would ever thinkthat there spouse would kill you kids 

Country Girl --- 15 years ago -

I agree that the dad had to of known
Yes, he had to, and the fact he made her homeschool them all in such a disturbing way. He just chose to ignore her pain. It does not excuse her behavior but certainly includes him. 

Kathryn --- 15 years ago -

Russell Yates, her ex husband, divorced her shortly after this story faded from the headlines and got remarried about 5 years ago and has at least one child now. 

Kathryn --- 15 years ago -

For anyone wanting a recap... Andrea Yates-wikipedia 

Sandra --- 15 years ago -

I believe the husband should have served some time for child neglect for leaving the kids with a woman so mentally ill. I do feel she has served enough, she didn't try to run or justify, she is remorseful. As soon as she realized what she had done she sought help. As a condition for her release though I think she should have her tubes tied, unfortunately the gov't has no say in that so it's not possible. Lets pray she has no more kids or she makes a conscious decision to get fixed so that this doesn't happen again. 

NadaSuperstar --- 15 years ago -

wow Kat was that traumatizing to live in the town where that happened?

That chick needs to be on death row...not on parole review. 

Kathryn --- 15 years ago -

I agree Russell Yates should have gotten into trouble. He completely ignored the Dr's advice and left her ome alone in the morning for an hour before her monther got there to stay with her during the day. But this lady knew she only had one hour to kill her kids, and she did just that. Even though she is remorseful, she, IMO, has not served enough time locked away somewhere. I believe she needs to be locked up somewhere for the rest of her life, maybe transfered to a low security prison. She is going to require extensive therapy for the rest of her life and I do not think she will ever become a normal functioning member of society. We have to remember "insane" or not she murdered FIVE innocent children, she needs to be punished rightfully. 

Kathryn --- 15 years ago -

wow Kat was that traumatizing to live in the town where that happened?


It is still talked about all the time, and I am sure now that this came out people are up in arms. We are a rock solid community back home. I remember getting my hair done and the verdict came back at her trial as guilty and we all started crying, it is still hard to believe that happened in our backyard.

Just for the record Clara Harris is also from my hometown... something must be in the water. 

NadaSuperstar --- 15 years ago -

OMFG...wow. There is something in the water...good thing you left town :-)

I just can't fathom killing a child..some people just have no ethics at all. She might be sorry now...but you have to wonder is for killing her kids or just sorry for herself being locked up? 

LovinMyLTBlocks --- 15 years ago -

Yes I so remember that. Poor babies. 

Sandra --- 15 years ago -

I think her condition is like schizophrenia, it can be controlled but not cured. I wouldn't use the same justice on a sane evil person as i would on a mentally ill individual. Yes, she deserves to be punished but not in the same way that Casey Anthony should be for example. Andrea Yates heard voices, imagined things, you can't use the same justice on an individual like that. She should NOT get pregnant, as part of her release she should get mental meds and depo at a doctor's office so that there is no getting pregnant for her. 

Kathryn --- 15 years ago -

I understand she was mentally ill at the time of the murders and it is not even comparable to Casey Anthony, and I am not suggesting she get the same punishment that Anthony is sure to get. I do not think she needs to free on her own, at all. 

Sandra --- 15 years ago -

I agree, maybe she needs a group home or a special program like they have for sexual offenders and such, not the SAME place, but a place for people like her 

what the --- 15 years ago -

I by no means am saying that what she did was excused in any way, but we as a society attack those who have suffered from postpardum and postpardum depression in such a way that there are so many mothers in this world that will not go to the doctor or tell anyone how they truly feel because of this. They may be embarrassed, or fearful that someone will take their baby, etc. The family(father and mother-in-law) were warned she was NOT to be left alone with the children. She had to be supervised during interaction with her children, babies especially. She was very ill. Her post pardum progressed into post pardum psychosis. After a while, her treatments and medications were helping her to improve. The family was warned again, do not take this as her being well. DO not leave her alone. After a while, she was helping to mother-in-law to clean, cook, feed the children. She actually started interacting with them after mths of therapy and meds. This is when the mother-in-law decided that she was no longer needed and the father agreed, only because he thought she was well again. A short period of time after, she murdered her kids. I don't blame anyone in this case, but coming from a psychology aspect, there were several red flags that were ignored time and time again. NO killing your kids is not okay, we know this, betaing or abusing as well. But we don't want to accept the fact that there truly are very sick people in the world that may need help. This definitely could have been prevented. 

Sandra --- 15 years ago -

Yes, because as soon as Rusty Yates was able to he divorced and remarried and remade his life w/ new children like the other family never existed. Where is his punishment? 

ellaella --- 15 years ago -

I was reading up on his blogs well he hasnt posted sence 2009 and the last post he had was sorry for not updating on here but im busy with my NEW FAMILY AND CHILD WHO IS 1 1.2 NOW.

Okay im sorry but his wording was RUDE !

and seems careless !!!!! 

Sandra --- 15 years ago -

Exactly, I feel he is more than 50% responsible because he WAS of sane mind and left his children with a very sick woman. He deserves at least twice her punishment. 

Kathryn --- 15 years ago -

he should have been charged as an accessory to murder. 

armywife1026 --- 15 years ago -

i agree with all of you!
as for rusty if he ever had a heart an has a heart he has to live with knowing he will never see his babys again..thats his punishment..(even though he should be in prison)but one day he'll get judged for what he did/ignored/&didn't do..&for her the samething.. 

ellaella --- 15 years ago -

Totally agree he just gets away with it like nothing ever happened having this new family. Like how can you live with yourself your FIVE KIDS are dead, over your mistake !!!


I get everyone wants to believe in their spouse and give them a chance because of how much they love them and so on and on... but realistically she wasn't meant to be with a lone even for an hour. !


Its a joke he knew she wasnt okay at all. She even stated she waited for him to leave.

Now what is she gonna do go out into the real world and she will see his new child and wife and kill them ?!!! 

Sandra --- 15 years ago -

Talk about the ultimate in revenge lol! 

proudjagwife --- 15 years ago -

Her husband got to have a whole new life and remarry. I am not sure if he ever had anymore children, but he knew she was unstable and had tried to commit suicide and instead of getting her help, they had even more children 

Apple Pie --- 15 years ago -

They're making room for Casey Anthony lol jk 

IMMoving --- 15 years ago -

They're making room for Casey Anthony lol jk

Oh wow...I love this. However, I hope they fry her! I don't want her chillin on the tax payers dime. 

proudjagwife --- 15 years ago -

I watched a bit of the Casey Anthony trial and the way she sits there, laughing, flirty with Baez one second and the fake crying the next drives me crazy! She is the reason they should bring back the firing squad, once she is found guilty take her out back and get it over with(was that too harsh lol) 

what the --- 15 years ago -

I say stone her to death like in the olden days! Really. The lies, and nonsense that comes from her mouth and her lawyers make me sick! Anyone that can represent someone who did something like this needs to be stoned as well! I don't know how her family can sit there in the court room and support her still even after all those lies. Just sad really. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lewis Underground