Lewis Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lewis bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Fort Lewis housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Honest Opinions

who's talking here?

cocowgirl777 1
Katena 2
Kristin 1
Maui Girl 2
MASC 4
Brenda E 3
peanutbutterjellytime 1
details 1
lemondrop 2
myopinion 3
AwesomeSauce 3
HookEmHorns 1
Masterchef 2
a4137440uu 12

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

a4137440uu --- 13 years ago -

I have a friend who is in a terrible marriage that is very much over. They are just mutually agreeing to live together for the time being.
One of the main reason for their split is because during a huge cheating mess in which her husband slept with everyone, my friend also started seeing someone else whom she "fell in love with" though she never physically cheated. This was almost three years ago while they were deployed together to Af.
The male she was having this relationship had at the time told her he was in the middle of a divorce, but after several months when they returned from deployment she found he was not actually divorcing his wife and they agreed to stop talking to allow him to work on his marriage.
Fast forward to now, there has been some contact(mainly just updates on each others life every 4-6 months) but nothing more until a few months ago when he called and informed her that he and his wife really were divorcing now, that he was still madly in love with her and could not continue living a lie with his wife, the only reason he had even tried so long with her is because of their children because he loves them so much and couldn't imagine not living in the same house with them but his wife recently told him that she is not willing to move with him anywhere if he PCSes and so he said what is the point then.
Oh and so now he wants to be with my friend..

All that said, my friend truly is in love with this man, however she feels that unless the man has paperwork in front of him clearly showing the divorce, she is not willing to even consider seeing him despite wanting to and him frequently begging.
The problem is that she doesn't know if she should give him an honest answer when he ask her about whether or not she will be with him if he does. I mean, if she says she doesn't know will he stay with his wife? IF that is the case, she honestly doesn't want him.
ALso, even if he does leave the wife on his own, she is worried that the guilt of having broken up his marriage, and taken a father away from his children will be more then she can live with. 

Maui Girl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

So what's the question? 

a4137440uu --- 13 years ago -

Should she even consider pursing this? Or just continue to ignore him despite her feelings for him? 

details --- 13 years ago -

This was almost three years ago while they were deployed together to Af.

Just to make sure I understand..."your friend" had a relationship with this dude three years ago and he was supposedly getting divorced? And now it's three years later and he's still married but supposedly getting divorced again?

Don't walk away. Run. 

Masterchef --- 13 years ago -

No she should not. She is still married and he is still married. They both stepped out on their marriages (regardless of what was going on) so it's just a recipe for disaster. If he can cheat with her, he can do it to her. Vice versa. Getting divorced should be because you want out of your marriage, not because you want to move onto someone new. Seems like he didn't even want the divorce anyway, he just doesn't wanna be alone when he moves. 

AwesomeSauce --- 13 years ago -

If he really wants to divorce his wife, her answer should not effect this decision. If he needs her answer before actually finalizing this divorce, he has other issues going on that he needs to take care of. So no. I don't think she should pursue this at all. He needs to take care of his business and she needs to take care of hers. They do not impact each other. 

a4137440uu --- 13 years ago -

Seems like he didn't even want the divorce anyway, he just doesn't wanna be alone when he moves

That's what I told her but she got all defensive. So I thought I would ask other people to see what they think. I get she has strong feelings for the guy and he claims he does for her, and I get why she has let him go all these years(it is what he requested) but he really is in love with her then how could he have spent so long with someone else? 

myopinion --- 13 years ago -

Show me the money! !!
In this case the divorce proceedings.
You know that epic scene in Jerry Maguire.

If he's for real show the documentation. Its a fair thing to ask to keep everyone honest. 

peanutbutterjellytime --- 13 years ago -

Sounds like a hot mess to me. And one to stay clear from. Replacing one person with another is not the way to fix oneself and the hurt and thats what sounds like is happening. They don't want to be with the person they are with but they don't want to be alone either....I think this situation is a recipe for a whole lot more hurt down the road. If it is ment to be they need to take care of themselves and get their lives straigh first. THEN if they want to they can work on their relationship together. Just my opinion. 

a4137440uu --- 13 years ago -

Oh no, she wants to be with him. The only reason she is in her marriage is a bad reason which is she has a health issue that requires a fair amount of attention and so she and her husband decided to stay married for the health insurance purposes since they didn't want to risk her getting worse because of their kids.
She has not pursued the other man despite wanting to be with him because she did not feel it would be fair or the right thing to do to his wife and family. 

a4137440uu --- 13 years ago -

Also, the original reason behind her split is her husbands infidelity. Which again, they stayed together for the health reasons. 

Brenda E --- 13 years ago -

Let's ERRR body get divorced....then start dating...see..easy peesy. Horse first, then cart... 

cocowgirl777 --- 13 years ago -

lol brenda...i had to read that errr like three times i thought you were being a retarded pirate or something...then i got it lol....wow... just wow...lol 

Brenda E --- 13 years ago -

ahahaha so funny! 

Kristin --- 13 years ago -

Why doesn't she focus on herself and her family and let him be-regardless of if he's going to stay married or not. If he is getting divorced then he really needs to take time to adjust with his kiddos without the distraction of a girlfriend. She was worried about his kids so she should be the better person and stay away for them. 

a4137440uu --- 13 years ago -

Well, she clarified and told me that the reason he is now leaving his wife is BECAUSE he loves her/wants to be with her if she'll have him. he had only stayed in the marriage for his children.
I guess that where her issue is. She does want to be in a relationship with him, but she feels wrong saying yes because she knows what it means for his family. 

Katena --- 13 years ago -

I think she needs to stay away from a relationship. She needs to take time for herself.I think she needs to take some breathing room. she needs to focus on herself. 

a4137440uu --- 13 years ago -

What does she need to focus on herself for? Her marriage is over and has been for several years. Both she and her husband openly knowledge that, he has dated many people over the years as she would have if she had found someone she was interested in. Her husband lives in the guest apartment in the basement, while she and the kids live in the main house. They have been that way for almost two years.
So I'm really not sure where the breathing room and time away from a relationship would be. She hasn't really been in one for a long time. 

myopinion --- 13 years ago -

Everyone involved needs to saddle up with a good therapist AND one provided for all the children as well. Bring all the issues out in the open. Seek council and take it slow. If I were her I would be telling him to go get some great therapy and to hit me up when he's settled. 

Maui Girl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

I say give the kids some breathing room, at the very least. How are they supposed to be expected to adjust to dad moving out and another man moving in right away? At least give the kids some time to get used to the separation before reintroducing another man into their lives. 

Katena --- 13 years ago -

@Maui I agree she may not need time but the kids may. This is a hard situation regardless. 

a4137440uu --- 13 years ago -

I don't think she would move in with the guy right away either way. 

lemondrop --- 13 years ago -

I basically agree with everyone.
She needs to wrap up her relationship, he needs to finish his. Then after, sure then talk about being together.
But the kids need time to adjust to being without the dad. All the advice people say to give the kids at LEAST one year without any boyfriends around. 

MASC --- 13 years ago -

honestly...

if she didnt want to hurt the wife and kids she would have walked away the minute she found out he was married and severed all ties.

put yourself in the wife's shoes. how would you feel if you found out your husband was telling people that youre getting divorced and carrying on relationships with other married women?

maybe the reason so many people are getting divorced these days is because they dont know what love is, or commitment and devotion. getting a tingle in your underpants isnt grounds for marriage. that feeling will pass and real life will follow. 

a4137440uu --- 13 years ago -

What you said Masc is essentially what happened.
The subject of each other's status didn't come up until they were each pretty far into having emotional feelings for each other because they worked very closely while deployed. There wasn't really the option to not spend time together or avoid contact.
It just became apparent to them eventually that they had mutual feelings, but as i mentioned before they never acted physically on them other then kissing and hand holding and still haven't.
My friend however did break contact when they returned and she learned of the wife and kids.
In the last three years, she has not contacted him and when he has contacted her she has wrapped up the conversation as quickly as possible, even hung up on him several times when he has starting saying that he still loves her and she has refused to see him when he ask.
Its not a thing they both do repeatedly. They are not both going out and having affairs, they simply met someone that they can't seem to forget. It's not about sex or having fun, it's purely a connection they can't shake. If he was just going out and cheating on his wife even once outside of my friend I would tell her to run but that's not it. She truly believes she has met her soulmate and three years of barely any contact has down little to change how either of them feel.
Her children don't need time. They have had it. Daddy has girlfriends over all the time, and mommy has yet to have anyone at all because the few dates she has had only made her miss this guy more. 

AwesomeSauce --- 13 years ago -

What is it you're looking for out of this conversation? You asked for opinions, yet seem to be a bit defensive? Were you hoping everyone would say to go for it? 

a4137440uu --- 13 years ago -

God no, I've been against it this whole time. I was trying to get a few other people to basically show her that it is not the best idea to trust the guy until she actually has proof of his divorce.
The defense is just out of respect for her. She has not been actively pursuing him and cutting him off whenever he does try to contact her until now and she only is open to him now as he is finally going through with ending the marriage. 

a4137440uu --- 13 years ago -

She just read the last comment from Masc about walking away the minute she found out he had the wife and kids and wanted mer to clarify she had. 

AwesomeSauce --- 13 years ago -

Well then I would say he has to finalize his divorce before any contact can happen. If he is waiting for her answer in order to make his decision, that's not right. It can't be her answer that changes everything. End one thing before beginning another. 

MASC --- 13 years ago -

so now i am wondering why he was not wearing his wedding band, since they didnt know about each others marriages. maybe he was actively seeking a relationship while away from his wife.

they never acted physically on them other then kissing and hand holding and still haven't.

i consider this physically acting on their feelings. to me, cheating is anything that you wouldnt want your spouse to know about if it happened, things you feel you have to hide. anything that you should be doing with your s/o, things that led you to be *together* (ie flirting, touching, kissing), is cheating. yes, i also believe in 'emotionally cheating,' hence the flirting being seen as cheating. feelings of guilt usually mean youre doing something wrong.

of course, there are some people that are so self-absorbed they feel no guilt at all.

im a little worried about your friends kids. their parents are still married and living in the same house, but daddy is bringing other women around. if i were a child this would confuse me. children learn from what they see, so will they view this as how relationships should be? 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lewis Underground