Lewis Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lewis bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Fort Lewis housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

To Tell or Not to Tell

who's talking here?

Frankie 2
Megan LeeAnne 1
Manda 1
a1125604uu 1
babycakes 2
MomofTwins1 1
BelleAdoresMommaFriend 8
Shelley S 2
ella ella 5
Pandaroni 1
CHHL 1
Pepper 1
Kristie528 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

BelleAdoresMommaFriend --- 14 years ago -

So what does everyone think?

My husband's grandmother is in very bad condition in the hospital and the doctors don;t know how long she will make it.

Should I send a Red Cross message?
My points of argument against it are this:
Will it make a difference? Will he get to come home to see her?
I ask this because if not I think it will just make him worry like crazy and take his mind off his job and possibly risk his own life and the people around him by his distraction.
Or will not telling make him mad for not knowing if something does happen and she doesn't make it?

So what would you do? Tell him knowing he probably won't be allowed to come back rot see her or wait and risk the him being upset with you for not telling him sooner? 

Shelley S --- 14 years ago -

You know him better than we do of course, but knowing my own husband and as close as he was to his grandmother, I would tell him. 

MomofTwins1 --- 14 years ago -

I agree with Shelley, but I know several people that lost loved ones who were not told about it & never given the chance to say goodbye. It has really made it so much worse on them. :-(

If it were my husband, I would do my best to tell him so even if he's unable to be here to see her, maybe he'll at least have the chance to speak with her & say his goodbyes just in case. 

babycakes --- 14 years ago -

You tell him, it is up to the unit if he is allowed to come home but you should nvever take the chance of not telling him and him holding it against you for ever. 

ella ella --- 14 years ago -

Its not up to red cross to send him home or not, its up to the unit, and what mission is going on.


If you get a chance to talk to him before hand not sure on your guys communcation ask him.

But my husband would want to know hes very close to his grandma and would come home in a heartbeat. 

BelleAdoresMommaFriend --- 14 years ago -

I was told already by FRG that he will not be allowed to come home until she has actually died and maybe not even then. As for communication, he rarely gets to call so the red cross message would be the best way to get the info to him. And I know its up to the unit not red cross if he comes home, I was in for 10 years myself and my unit would not let me home from deployment for a grandparents death and it made me a mess to work with. 

Shelley S --- 14 years ago -

As for communication, he rarely gets to call so the red cross message would be the best way to get the info to him

Yeah they are usually very quick to get the info to them, even overseas, and if doesn't get a lot of chances to call you, it would be a shame to have to wait and it may be too late. Sorry you have to send him that message and praying for him as he has to hear it :( 

ella ella --- 14 years ago -

I was told already by FRG that he will not be allowed to come home until she has actually died and maybe not even then



Ya they really cant make that call..

we just had our red cross briefing before deployment, which aint my first..

and they stated send the red cross message, but if the soldier wants (if unit allows) he can come now, before death and take that chance or wait it out and go to funeral.

They usually let that up to the soldier, so they dont get 3 days leave get there person hasnt died, and they have to return.

So is up to the unit FRG cant make that call or decision. They have nothing to do with it. 

Kristie528 --- 14 years ago -

I think he needs to know. 

BelleAdoresMommaFriend --- 14 years ago -

I am also aware that FRG does not make the call on if the soldier comes home. I was the FRG leader for my husbands last unit for two years, one of which they were deployed for. They however are aware of what the units standards tend to be for situations such as this and can tell you what normally happens when these things happen.
In case of my husbands current unit, soldiers are not be granted emergency leave unless it is for immediate family, i.e. wife, child, parent. 

Frankie --- 14 years ago -

I would tell him. I for one would be super upset if my spouse knew that a family member was sick and could possibly pass away but they kept it from me.

He should be able to come home, if the unit allows it. My husbands Dad was in an accident when he was deployed and they were going to let him come home but he chose not to bc it wasn't life threatening. 

ella ella --- 14 years ago -

grandparents are on that list now... as well as fiances etc.. =D Just fyi...


Things have changed alot since my husband last deployed and im sure since you were a FRG leader.. and so on..
but our brief stated differently and this coming directly from Red Cross.

but if you know it all dont ask for advice. 

BelleAdoresMommaFriend --- 14 years ago -

I have already sent the Red Cross message. I agree that it is better to let him know and give him the chance to call her if he can then have him not know and not call.

but if you know it all dont ask for advice

I wasn't asking about the rules and regulation, I was asking personal opinions on whether or not to inform my husband of his grandmothers illness knowing that his unit will likely not let him come home to see her based off what has already been happening with situations such as this during THIS deployment in which grandparents are not making the cut as immediate family members. 

Frankie --- 14 years ago -

, I was asking personal opinions on whether or not to inform my husband of his grandmothers illness knowing that his unit will likely not let him come home to see her based off what has already been happening with situations such as this during THIS deployment in which grandparents are not making the cut as immediate family members.

So you wouldn't tell him just because they "might" not let him come home? Whether or not they let him shouldn't be the deciding factor. To do the right thing should be and the right thing is to let him know that his grandmother is ill. This shouldn't even be a thought in your mind. It would be very unkind and thoughtless to not do so. 

CHHL --- 14 years ago -

I was asking personal opinions on whether or not to inform my husband of his grandmothers illness knowing that his unit will likely not let him come home to see her based off what has already been happening with situations such as this during THIS deployment in which grandparents are not making the cut as immediate family members.


Tell him, he may be able to call even if he can't come home. Can it be a distraction, yes.

I would think it would be more of a distraction if she passes and his Aunt "Sally" tells him you knew about it and withheld the information from him.

Even if she can't speak or what have you, he can still try to say goodbye and know he did what he could. 

ella ella --- 14 years ago -

So you wouldn't tell him just because they "might" not let him come home? Whether or not they let him shouldn't be the deciding factor. To do the right thing should be and the right thing is to let him know that his grandmother is ill. This shouldn't even be a thought in your mind. It would be very unkind and thoughtless to not do so. 


agree, its his family and think like him, its not your choice, if his grandmother is ill tell him pass the message and move on.

This is something you dont question jsut because he cant come home, "or you think he cant"

you wont know till you try..

dont base it on your experince base it on your husband and his life, its his family. 

ella ella --- 14 years ago -

You cant possibly know everything that has happened in a deployment. People have different issues but to withhold information is wrong. 

BelleAdoresMommaFriend --- 14 years ago -

I am not in any way shape or form considering not telling my husband, "Just because he may not be able to come home." How thick do you think I am?

I know my husband as does his family and his mother and sister are the ones telling me they think we should wait on telling him because they know him like I do and know that something like his grandmothers illness could distract him to the point that he could be injured or killed himself because unfortunately that is what he is facing himself on a daily basis.
So no, under the circumstances I do not believe it is wrong of us to consider withholding the information. We are considering HIS best interest and the men around him who might also be affected if something happens due to his being distracted by this issue.
I am not saying it will affect him so strongly but would YOU want to risk losing your husband or other soldiers opposed to just withholding a piece of information that nothing can be done about?

THAT is how we are looking at the situation and the one and ONLY reason this topic even exist. I thought other wives would understand that is what I meant and was considering with something like this. From all points of view, considering his well being and other soldiers. His grandmother doesn't want us to tell him at all for fear that he will worry to much. 

BelleAdoresMommaFriend --- 14 years ago -

So you wouldn't tell him just because they "might" not let him come home? Whether or not they let him shouldn't be the deciding factor. To do the right thing should be and the right thing is to let him know that his grandmother is ill. This shouldn't even be a thought in your mind.

Read my above post! Has nothing to do with the "coming home" factor in the sense you are thinking. 

a1125604uu --- 14 years ago -

I wouldn't tell my husband the whole truth, cause like you and your husband's family are aware the information my distract from mission. I'm glad that you are considering his safety along with his co-workers.
I would mention that grandma is getting old and her health isn't what it used to be. A casual reminder of what happens in old age, or if she has been sick may help ease him into accepting her passing if it comes to that. (Sorry for those that think I'm morbid, but preparing for death isn't morbid. That is why we make wills and do power of attorneys).
I recommend waiting on the red cross message until closer to her passing (or right after). He'd have a better change of the command releasing him and it would give him time to grieve.
Good luck with your situation. Do what is best for him and your family. 

Megan LeeAnne --- 14 years ago -

I read the comment where you have already sent a message. Would you like this deleted since you don't need opinions anymore? 

BelleAdoresMommaFriend --- 14 years ago -

I don't think its necessary, but if you would like to. I think it is interesting reading other peoples interpretation of what I was asking. It helps me learn how to better word my topics in the future to avoid confusion on my meaning. 

Manda --- 14 years ago -

My step-son is sick and my husband knows it. He deployed three months ago and even he is unsure if he wants me to tell him if anything were to happen. I would tell my husband even if he didn't want to know. I would't want him to have a reason to take his grief out on me when he did find out later on. It all depends on your situation. 

BelleAdoresMommaFriend --- 14 years ago -

Manda, that is kinda how my husband is. Unless it was our daughter, I don't know if he would want to know. I surely wouldn't bother him if it was me and his mother would say the same thing as his Grandmother is now saying. 

Pepper --- 14 years ago -

I just had this dilemma with my soldier. It's my grandma, but he's like her son. She prays for him daily. Knew the exact details of a really close call he had over there without him saying anything. They have an uncanny connection. Her tumors have spread & I was debating whether to say anything. Didn't want to make him mourn her or distract him. Still, if the situation was reversed, I'd want to know, so I told him. He's doing what he can. Calling her a little more often. Planning a trip when he's stateside. 

Pandaroni --- 14 years ago -

I know my husband went though this while he was deployed the last time. His grandmother was on her death bed, waiting. No one really knew how long she would make it. She did pass away. He did not have the option to fly home due to where he was anyway, so he did not bother to ask really since 2 other soldiers had the same situation and were denied. :( I am sorry to hear she is so bad right now. I do think my husband would have been furious with me had I not notified him of her condition and the possibility of her passing. But I agree with the other ladies on their points as well. it depends on the person, you know him better, also on the fact that he may or may not get to say goodbye to her, either in person, or by phone, etc. But I think that may be an issue if he doe not get the chance, how would he feel? Good luck. It's a very hard situation to be in as a soldier, and also for the family members as well. 

babycakes --- 14 years ago -

I hope everything works out for th best for your husband, I found out my uncle had passed on facebook and it still hurts to this day. Atleast you didnt take that chance. Maybe with the message sent already his unit could be on notice now and he might get to come home when she passes. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lewis Underground