Lewis Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lewis bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Fort Lewis housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: pure breed or mixed dogs?

who's talking here?

wildflower2007 1
JustcallmeSuz 3
Apple Pie 1
Sandra 1
Maui Girl 1
staindingbymyman 1
Are we done yet 6
MASC 5
Brenda E 1
Shelley S 7
details 1
CSGray 4
33Whisky 7
Pandaroni 1
AwesomeSauce 1
Alyyy 2
Chris P Bacon 1
Kristie528 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

POLL: pure breed or mixed dogs?

I just was wondering if people would rather have a pure breeds or mixed breeds?

Mixed they are smarter Vote
 
 48.1% (13)
pure breed they are smarter Vote
 
 37.0% (10)
wouldn't want a dog Vote
 
 14.8% (4)
Are we done yet --- 14 years ago -

I just was wondering if people would rather have a pure breeds or mixed breeds? 

Chris P Bacon --- 14 years ago -

Pound puppies! Although I'm not certain rather or not they're smarter. LOL 

JustcallmeSuz --- 14 years ago -

I refuse to spend a ton of money on a dog! We inherited our choc lab/weimaraner from my parents and we rescued two great danes. 

JustcallmeSuz --- 14 years ago -

Also, I have found that rescue dogs (not that I have any experience buying purebread) are so appreciative of the love and care they get. Our dane, Gabby was abused so bad, she is so incredible loving. My nephews could lay on her and pull her ears and she would let them and loved it! 

Are we done yet --- 14 years ago -

I was just wondering because someone just told me that a majority of the dogs out there are mix breeds which i believe is true. And then she went into saying pure breeds are stupid and untrainable its like excuse my pure breed lab Which i got for free trained very well and is very smart and i have yet to find a pure breed that is stupid. Not saying mixed breeds are stupid i'm just saying people think pure breeds are more stupid then mixed. I wouldn't own anything but a pure breed but i also wouldnt go out and spend 300+ dollars to get a pure breed either. I would go rescue from an animal shelter if need be and i would watch it weekly to see if there were any pure breeds in there. We are stationed at riley we live off post and the town we live in told us recently you wouldnt believe how many animals are in the shelter right now and how many pure breeds people can come in and adopt if owner dont come forward much cheaper than they can get from a breeder. 

JustcallmeSuz --- 14 years ago -

My mix is incredibly smart. I love Great Danes they are my favorite breed dog by far. However, I would not put my nose in the air when it comes to a mix breed. Our Morgen (mix breed) is incredibly smart, much easier to train than any other dog we have had. To each their own. However, I would not make assumptions until you actually own a mix breed. 

Are we done yet --- 14 years ago -

I actually have my moms mixed breed she use to be hyper when i was younger but she is mellow now i guess thats what you get when you have a 14 yr old dog. I just still prefer having pure breeds. 

AwesomeSauce --- 14 years ago -

I've always preferred mutts and pound puppies. Some of the funniest, smartest, most infuriating yet enjoyable pets I've ever had :) 

details --- 14 years ago -

When we started talking about getting a dog hubby really wanted a boxer because he had one when he was a kid. I just wanted a puppy who could grow up with my kids from the start. Pure bred vs. mutt didn't really matter to either of us. We wound up with a pure boxer. We got her from a couple in Wenatchee whose female got molested by their friend's male boxer. They had one liter and then they got their female fixed.

I think a lot of people are against pure bred dogs because there are, unfortunately, a lot of "backyard breeders" who just breed to get pups to make money. They breed them more often then they should and sell the puppies without papers or proper vet care. Some of them charge hundreds of dollars and for some reason people are willing to pay. I have nothing against actual registered breeders who do what they do responsibly. And in cases like where our dog came from I do understand accidents can happen.

There are some very opinionated people out there when it comes to pure bred dogs. More then once I have had someone criticize me for "buying" my dog instead of adopting one from a shelter. I think what these people fail to realize is that my dog surely would've wound up in a shelter (or worse!) if I didn't buy her. The people lived in a tiny two bedroom house. There's no way they could've kept all eleven puppies from the liter. 

Pandaroni --- 14 years ago -

Neither are smarter than any other. They all need loved just the same. I have had mutts that are exceptionally smart, as well as pure breds. Loved them all. My favorite is German Shepherds. My parents bred them as well as Boston Terriers. The AKC Shepherd were mostly trained for law enforcement as well as S&R. Grew up with them so they are always my heart tuggers. 

Brenda E --- 14 years ago -

I don't think "pure breed is smarter" or "Mutt is smarter" is accurate...The MAIN point of buying a pure bred, is to A) be aware of all its genetics, and bloodlines- B) You can choose a dog with the traits/size/coat/mentality that you need. Example, you are a duck hunter..you might want a Lab with Champ hunting bloodlines vs a shatzoocackapoopit from the pound...

I Have had some Fab mutts...but if I needed a working dog, or a hunting dog, or an exact coat and size I would (and have) buy a pure bred dog.... 

Sandra --- 14 years ago -

Both of our dogs are rescue dogs. Our lab mix mutt we adopted 9 yrs. ago in a GA pound, and our abused Weimaraner came into our home 4 yrs ago. IMO, although both are rescue, our mutt is about ten times healthier than our pure bred dog. And unfortunately, she's probably smarter too. It is beyond me how people pay astronomical amounts for a puppy when there are so many at the humane society. I left in tears the last time I was there because all of these babies were just dying for a tiny touch, it's so hard to not take them all. 

Apple Pie --- 14 years ago -

My two dogs are mixed and they're awesome :) 

Kristie528 --- 14 years ago -

I have a pound puppy and a yorkie. 

33Whisky --- 14 years ago -

I've gotten wonderful mutts and wonderful purebred, I'm not biased in the least lol :) 

MASC --- 14 years ago -

i couldnt help but thinking of slytherin when i read your second post. :oP

also, to details... dont people realize youre technically buying them from the shelter too?

we were looking at cats in petsmart the other day and i noticed they had one of the breed i eventually want (its a rex for my husbands allergies) and they wanted 300 dollars more for it because it was a designer cat... even though it was given to them free, fixed and vaccinated when its owner died. even the ones that are just strays are 100 dollars!

i really dont have a preference for dogs as long as theyve got a good personality. we wont be getting any more for a while after ours are gone because i need a break from pets for a while. 

Maui Girl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Purebred dogs tend to have more health problems, DEPENDING on how many times they were in-bred. It's unfortunate, but it does happen often. I don't see anything wrong with either or. I also don't see the need to place such a high value on either type of animal. Mutts are just as valuable, if not more so, depending on the mixes included. If you REALLY wanted to get technical, every dog is "a mutt". Specific dog breeds didn't just pop up out of the earth. All the breeds out there are a product of cross-breeding at some point or another. It's just so far removed in time that they are now considered a "breed". 

33Whisky --- 14 years ago -

The shelters are really upsetting me lately. When my husband and I got a dog the humane society "offered" me a purebred shih tzu puppy that was "only" $600, that was surrendered by a couple that couldn't move with the dog.

It's wrong. It's thievery and wrong to do to people trying to do the right thing by rescuing. We ended up going to a breeder. 

MASC --- 14 years ago -

and they wonder why shelters are overcrowded! if they really want to help the animals they would lower the costs to what they used to be and get more pets moving through the system. 

33Whisky --- 14 years ago -

Agreed!

at tacoma humane, any dog under 25lbs is $350.
Charging more for more desirable dogs doesn't make people adopt the cheaper, larger dogs instead, it just drives us away and makes people like me, who have always rescued, go to a breeder for a healthy animal who's history I know, instead of one that costs more that I know less about and may have more health problems. 

Alyyy --- 14 years ago -

i adopted a purebred welsh corgi for $140 from the tacoma humane. And there were dogs that were $350 special needs, but it was listed in the front of the cage. And when you adopt a dog from there included is a health exam from a vet(they give you a list) where you must take the dog within 5 days of adoption date. There is also so many days, i believe 30, that you are able to return the animal if things aren't working out.

Also, i don't believe purebred dogs are smarter than mixed, it just depends on how well its been trained. My aunt has a purebred boxer her family was insistent on getting, he is EXTREMELY hard to train even with professional help, he turned out to be deaf and has a very little attention span to see them signing and even when he is paying attention he is goofy and stubborn and just ignores them, haha. 

Are we done yet --- 14 years ago -

That would be our problem because when we get a dog its to hunt. So we are wanting a specific blood line not a mixed breed. Altho mixed breeds can be hunters too just depends on whats in them. And i do agree even tho i havent experienced any health problems with my dog i have been told problems can occur more in pure breeds. Which for me i guess could happen anytime as my LAB is almost 5yrs old. 

Shelley S --- 14 years ago -

I wouldn't say pure breeds aren't smart, but both my pure breed poms I had I couldnt not for the life of me house break. On the other hand, in February we went to the humane society and found a mix pom/peek and he is incredibly loving and smart and has adapted very well and quickly to our family. He had some training before we could tell, like he walks behind us by a step, he doesn't have to be leashed (he wont run off) when talked to he sits and puts up his left paw. So while I have had both pure and mixed, I'm glad I went with the humane rescue this time. 

Shelley S --- 14 years ago -

Oh wow reading how much people have paid at shelters/humane society that's crazy! I paid $80 (plus a fee to my landlady to have the dog) and that included shots, him being fixed, and his city license that is required here in Lawton. All the dogs there have the same price and all the cats are the same price, they are listed right up front at the office. 

Are we done yet --- 14 years ago -

shelley, poms are very hard to house break. My husband grandma breeds them and i hate even going into her house because everytime you turn around there is pee on the floor. Doesnt matter how much she trains these dogs they wouldnt 

Shelley S --- 14 years ago -

That's why I gave up on pure poms, love them to death but I tried for years with both and they would still not fully train. Our rescue is part pom, but I guess the peek part was easier to train lol 

33Whisky --- 14 years ago -

Yeah, shelters are getting out of control. A friend of mine just got a dog there, for $200 that they lied to about a knee problem and ended up having to return her, they only let her exchange and now she has a dog with severe kennel cough.

I prefer rescuing and adore mutts, but after my last few experiences at the Humane society I can't trust them anymore.

I tried to get a dog from a rescue that would never return my emails, calls or voicemails and eventually had to give up, and the humane 'offered' me the $600 shih tzu pup, and then tried to talk me into a dog with blood in his urine, kennel cough and mysterious blisters on his tummy.

They are just too set on the money now and not with getting the animals into good homes. 

Shelley S --- 14 years ago -

How do they get away with asking such high prices? Ours was way cheap by comparison and seems we got a lot of stuff for the money we spent. 

Are we done yet --- 14 years ago -

How do they get away with asking such high prices?

I dont understand either. I have never been to a shelter took look or check out prices but from what i'm hearing her thats crazy. They want these animals to go to homes and not keep them in the over populated shelters. Plus if they get too many they have to start putting them down. 

CSGray --- 14 years ago -

I have both a pure bred, and a mix breed. Both are equally smart. But very different personalities.

The Mix breed was free.
The Pure bred was $500.

It's all on how you raise them and how you train them. and how you treat them.

I treat all my pets like they are my kids, literally. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lewis Underground