Lewis Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lewis bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Fort Lewis housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: Spanking Kids?

who's talking here?

goddessanne 5
brittney 1
ShamWow 1
Sandra 1
Kathryn 1
Maui Girl 2
NadaSuperstar 1
MASC 1
Leesah 1
Shelley S 2
ella ella 3
details 1
Lucy 1
mammaD 1
myopinion 1
CSGray 2
33Whisky 1
AwesomeSauce 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

POLL: Spanking Kids?

yes Vote
 
 82.9% (34)
no Vote
 
 17.1% (7)
AwesomeSauce --- 14 years ago -

Undecided. Back home, CPS was called on people for looking at your kid wrong. Then I lived in the south and was traumatized by seeing spankings in public. I actually asked who to call, and my coworkers laughed in my face.

For my child- I don't know, honestly. I don't think it's ok to hurt them, but a swat on the bum usually made me straighten out. He's only 9 months so I have some time to decide.

Other kids- sometimes I really wish I could spank them! 

Lucy --- 14 years ago -

Spanking doesnt work for my son, I use timeouts or taking away things he likes and that seems to work best! I don't really like spanking guess it was because when I was growing up my mom had a boyfriend who used to spank his kids but ended up pretty much Beating them... 

Maui Girl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Ah yes. The heated spanking debate. Lol. Before I had my own kids, I was TOTALLY anti-spanking. My father was physically and verbally abusive. He said things that I only hope most people don't have to hear in their lifetime. I blocked most of the physical abuse, but the verbal has stuck.

As for spanking, I told myself the abuse cycle would stop with me. And it did. I do not abuse my children. HOWEVER, my stance on spanking has changed. I've come to learn there are certain disrespects I will NOT tolerate from my kids, and I let them know it. My disciplinary methods have gotten much more organized in the last few months, which I think has improved my relationship with my kids. They aren't total but cases in public, and if they test me, I have consequences lined up. One of the hardest things about discipline is being creative with your consequences. Lol. When worst comes to worst, I find a finger flick to the forehead to be rather effective. Lol. Straightens them right out. 

Maui Girl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

*nut cases, not "but cases". Lol 

brittney --- 14 years ago -

nut cases, not "but cases". Lol
lol it works either way atleast with mine.

i spank i see nothing wrong with it. i was raised in sc and va and it was common there but there is a line. 

Leesah --- 14 years ago -

Maui, I am almost the exact same way. My mom used to beat the crap out of me and when my son was born I vowed to never lay a finger on him. He mostly gets time outs or sent to his room, but I have given him a swat on his bum a few times. 

33Whisky --- 14 years ago -

I feel a swat on the the behind, a slap on the hand are appropriate as occasional punishments when the point made needs emphasized.

Other than that, I think it's difficult to discern as far as how often, or 1, 2, 3 swats?? But, all forms of punishment need to be cautiously used and in moderation. 

mammaD --- 14 years ago -

I personally think spanking is normal as long as its on the bum with your hand.time outs and taking things away is great as well but when it comes to the kids pushing my buttons (especially in public) then they get a swift butt spanking and stuck in their room the rest of their day except meals 

Shelley S --- 14 years ago -

You could count on one hand how many times I actually spanked my two kids, but man did I hate it simply because I was spanked by my step dad for everything from a bed not made right to a C in school. I am a yeller, and so many times that my dad would have spanked, I yelled, and I got the same results he did...

I think it's a family by family thing, I dont judge anyone with the spanking/no spanking beliefs because they aren't my family. 

MASC --- 14 years ago -

something i watched recently said 90% of parents admit to spanking their kids. so far that looks about right.

i think there is a line. spanking is not beating. spanking is a swat on the behind. my daughter gets them when she needs them. usually 1 but sometimes 2 depending on the severity of what she has done. she doesnt like time outs but if i give them she finds a way to play thru it so she doesnt learn.

i dont like yelling. i do it, but i dont like it. and i think sometimes what you say can hurt a child worse than if you had just given them a swat.

i also think it is different when a father does the spanking, especially if it is his daughter. maybe its because i just think men shouldnt hit women... so if a dad spanks his daughter she would see it as okay later on in life? i dunno. 

ShamWow --- 14 years ago -

There is a difference between spanking and abusing. Spanking was used in our house growing up until we were old enough to be handled differently. 

goddessanne --- 14 years ago -

When I use to work at the Clarkmoor CDC, we had to immediately report instances of spanking. I argued about the fact that there is nothing wrong with it in some cultures just as long as it is not obvious abuse. I was shut down and told report regardless of how little.

I personally hate the fact that I spank my child, but my husband was for it and I didn't want our parenting to be inconsistent. He brought up the point that as long as we can control ourselves and never spank out of anger. We both agree that the idea of spanking is what makes our child cry and not the actual physical part of it. This is true for our son because there were so many times I "cheated" and didn't actually spank him (just the motion...basically a slight tap on the hand) he cried just as loud as if he really did get spanked. 

myopinion --- 14 years ago -

The above post is a crock of you know what. No you did not. First everyone Google WAs state child abuse govern laws. Bam. Wow.
As you read you will find that a spank within guidelines is not punishable by law. Then those of you who have never worked at CDC google again . Their website. Search it. You will find nothing. 

ella ella --- 14 years ago -

^^^ agree, in WA spanking is NOT punishable by law.

CDC is just filled with nutshells they called CPS on me because my daughter had fallen on a trampoline springs, and left a pattern bruise on her.

They are a bunch of worthless people working in there along with their trainers, they dont know the laws people just pound crap in their heads by personal beliefs not what is actually the law. 

details --- 14 years ago -

Lol. When worst comes to worst, I find a finger flick to the forehead to be rather effective. Lol. Straightens them right out.

Agree lol!

I'm not opposed to spanking in general, but it doesn't work on my kids. My daughter laughs and keeps going. Time outs, loss of privileges, and writing lines (for my oldest) are what I use. Good behavior gets lots of praise and recognition around here too.

I'm probably going to hell for this, but in November and December I also mention that Santa is always watching at the first sign of a tantrum or other bad behavior. I know it's so wrong, but it works! 

Shelley S --- 14 years ago -

I'm probably going to hell for this, but in November and December I also mention that Santa is always watching at the first sign of a tantrum or other bad behavior. I know it's so wrong, but it works!

well if you are going to hell for that, I'll save you a seat cause my kids fell for it every time ;) 

CSGray --- 14 years ago -

It depends on the child. My oldest, you just told him he was being bad, and that was enough to send him into tears and running off to his room. My younger two don't get the idea that you're serious until they get a swat on the butt. 

goddessanne --- 14 years ago -

When I worked at CDC I've personally never had the experience of reporting somebody. Although, I do think the intent is not to punish the parents simply because of a simple spank. I think we had to report as a form of precaution... better safe than sorry I guess. In a different setting, as a school counselor, I've had to report several spanking incidences. In some instances I do not deem them abuse, but I report because it was protocol. If I didn't do it, I can get fired or worse miss a hidden abuse. 

goddessanne --- 14 years ago -

Now I understand why CDC has those guidelines. Really, it's to ensure they don't lose accreditation. Daycares and Preschools are not required to be accredited and CDCs on base are. They work hard to obtain them and for sure they don't want to lose them. With all the times I've reported (different environment), I've never a time were parents did get in trouble by the law. Again, it is a precaution to ensure no abuse is really going on. Sometimes, my cases were ruled out just by a simple phone interview with me. 

ella ella --- 14 years ago -

Really ? When I got reported I went through hell and back and spent 12 hours at Madigan, with CID, CPS, social workers and had my kids taken from me to stay with grandparents because it happened on a Friday and they wouldnt do anything over the weekend. So DONT say parents dont get in trouble, because they do !!! Whether it just flys by after the days of horror, and then it gets cleared my husband even got sent home from Korea !

And yes CID believed us the whole time and so did the MPS on post, but its the one jerk off with CPS we got who was to damn lazy to show up at a decent hour that made the horrible call, over NOTHING and I MEAN NOTHING the kid fell !

So dont say that until you in it, and im embarrassed by and never ever will bring my kids on post, and even working in childcare now I think twice and take the RIGHT steps before I put any parent through what my family went through. 

goddessanne --- 14 years ago -

So DONT say parents dont get in trouble, because they do

My statements were from my own experience. They are surely not exclusive. What I've said is that so far all the ones I've reported were dismissed. Of course, procedures differ in different places, but with my previous work place I had to write a CPS report, turn it in, AND I had to call it in. I usually spend about 30 mins. on the phone explaining everything and they ask me questions. From there they may dismiss the case or further take it to the next level. You also gotta keep in mind the perceptions of the different people taking in the incident reports. Some may deem something as nothing while others may deem the very same incident as something worth investigating further.

In the type of field I am in, many times I've had to put my personal beliefs aside and follow through with protocol. I even find myself apologizing even though I was doing my job duties. (I always make it clear to my students, that there are things I must do because it is required of me.) Like what I said before, some reporting is required by our job. Just like in the military, sometimes my husband does not approve of what is required of him, but he has to go by his higher up because it is either protocol or he can get in serious trouble if he defies it.

As an education worker, I just keep telling myself...wow, all this trouble to ensure a child is safe... what a nuisance!...but yes all this to ensure a child is safe.

As a parent, of course, I would hate what you went through. I would be pissed and just feel so many emotions. I personally would be scared, embarrassed, defeated as a parent, possibly betrayed by people I trust my child to, distrust in the system, etc. I've had parents yell at me before, but in my case I am just doing my job. I just get over it by saying, the child is safe, the child is okay, better safe than sorry... 

goddessanne --- 14 years ago -

Ella, I think you said you were reported because your child fell? Your situation is different.
I just wanted to point out that I am sharing my experience with witnessing spanking and reporting to CPS while with CDC and reporting a spanking incident through information gathered from a student as a school counselor. I may have confused you because they are two different jobs in different environments.

Here are other experiences I want to share:

I remember when I worked at the CDC, I had a coworker (who worked in a different room) whose child was in my classroom. This one day, she dropped her off and the first thing she asked me to do is to write an incident report about her child because she has a bruise on her back from the slides during the weekend. I was a newbie then and I was caught by surprise, I thought I surely would have not reported her because I saw nothing and there was nothing about the demeanor of the child that suggested abuse. I realize now it was her way of ensuring she would not get questioned. Again, she was a CDC worker so she knew that that a small incident could be twisted into something bigger. I surely do not expect all parents to do this... no way. I am simply pointing out, situations differ.

In some of the phone interviews I've had with a CPS, despite the fact that I was the one that reported the parent(s), I actually advocated for them. I always made it a point to provide my professional and personal thoughts in the matter. They don't always take my personal thoughts in consideration, but some CPS workers do. Truth be told, they have A LOT of cases to deal with as it is so whenever they can dismiss something immediately they would. (Again, this is not always the case.) 

Sandra --- 14 years ago -

I spank on an as needed basis. My oldest 2 needed a little more than the youngest one, with him a simple threat is enough most of the time. Raising my voice is step 2 and usually that's all that is needed. I would NEVER spank anyone else's kids nor would I ever allow anyone to spank my kids. I don't care if my kid cursed you out, they are not piƱatas for just anyone to lay a finger on them. Tell the parent, let them handle it as they seem fit. 

Kathryn --- 14 years ago -

My husband and I agreed when we had our first that we would only spank if our children do something that could put themselves or someone else in danger or hurt someone. My daughter will be five next month and we've never come close to having to spank! I think at this point we wouldn't spank since we have other systems of punishment. I'm not 100% against spanking, it's just not for us. 

NadaSuperstar --- 14 years ago -

Spanking is a personal parenting choice and I would not judge a parent who had to spank their child if the child was running into the road, swearing, being disrespectful, etc. If there appeared to be signs of abuse like negligence (letting child play in road, no supervision at all), the child had visible bruises, was scared of movement around them or had other signs of abuse, then yes that would be different. 

CSGray --- 14 years ago -

I have a long and not pleasant CPS story that I won't go into, but I will say that the CPS people I delt with, were more then kind and friendly. Especially once they heard the whole story and found out how I had been treated during the whole thing by the MPs, CID, and MPI.

I have been reported to CPS a total of five times. All five times they found the reports un-founded, and false. It's gotten to the point that reports made on me are back firing. Not only do I get checked out, but the person making the report gets checked in on as well. 

ella ella --- 14 years ago -

^^^ sad that sucks when people have nothing better to do with their time. Except make false accusations.

The issue is even unfounded it is still in the system for 7 years, it cant be located based on working for childcare, or fingerprint, but if CPS ever gets called again it can be used againest you, im on one year down and 6 more to go. Very annoying. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lewis Underground