I read an article yesterday in a magazine (don't remeber what magazine...was at an appt) that said Children with ADHD can be just as difficult, and sometimes more difficult than children with Autism.....what are you guys' opinions on that?
Just to clarify, I'm not trying to start a fight....just wondering what everyone thought, because I know we have parents of both ADHD kids and Autistic kids on here....just wondering everyones experiences and thoughts...
I don't think the point of the article was to say ADHD was more Difficult than Autism....it was saying that kid by kid, some parents can have more difficulty.. It depends of the severity of the CHILD, not the diagnosis..that's like saying, well, at least they don't have cancer, or something stupid....like that. My child has autism and he is better than MOST kids--period. Being his mother is a joy. And most of the neighbor kid annoy the hell out of me... I also have many friends who have autistic children, older, and still in diapers, and completely non verbal in the fourth or fifth grade......so it's not like I would pick one or the other but...the adhd would look a little less upsetting in that perspective....again, it's sort of a stupid thing to compare. It doesn't make any sense....ALL severe disabilities are stressful, and sad, and frustrating...and they all have very different levels. It's the severity that makes it hard---Like I said, my autistic child is, well behaved, smart, fun and loving...and our old neighbor who was a five year old psychopath drove me up the wall.......
it's sort of a stupid thing to compare. It doesn't make any sense
Exactly. It's not really a fair statement to say one is more difficult to handle then the other. It all depends on the individual circumstances. There are mild and extreme cases of both autism and ADHD. No matter what it is, when your child has a disability that's going to effect them for life it's difficult to deal with.
I don't think the point of the article was to say ADHD was more Difficult than Autism....it was saying that kid by kid, some parents can have more difficulty.. It depends of the severity of the CHILD, not the diagnosis..that's like saying, well, at least they don't have cancer, or something stupid....like that. My child has autism and he is better than MOST kids--period. Being his mother is a joy. And most of the neighbor kid annoy the hell out of me... I also have many friends who have autistic children, older, and still in diapers, and completely non verbal in the fourth or fifth grade......so it's not like I would pick one or the other but...the adhd would look a little less upsetting in that perspective....again, it's sort of a stupid thing to compare. It doesn't make any sense....ALL severe disabilities are stressful, and sad, and frustrating...and they all have very different levels. It's the severity that makes it hard---Like I said, my autistic child is, well behaved, smart, fun and loving...and our old neighbor who was a five year old psychopath drove me up the wall.......
it's sort of a stupid thing to compare. It doesn't make any sense
Exactly. It's not really a fair statement to say one is more difficult to handle then the other. It all depends on the individual circumstances. There are mild and extreme cases of both autism and ADHD. No matter what it is, when your child has a disability that's going to effect them for life it's difficult to deal with.
I agree, which is why I asked what you all thought about it....I think that's what they were meaning to say when they said "can be" in the article but failed to clarify (it was mainly an article about ADHD, so that was just a random sentence in the entire article...)...but I was just wondering everyone's experiences because I know they vary from person to person...it seems like my sons ADHD gets worse and worse all the time, and he's medicated...
I have a child who is autistic and I believe he has ADHD as well. We have a doctor appointment Friday. I think it depends on the child. I had two boys who had just ADHD they were different as day and night. Regardless of what is wrong parenting is hard and children with special needs is even harder. My son is autistic well behaved for the most part. He is in a mainstream classroom. But he would rather be left alone. He hates therapy. I had a doctor tell me he would never talk, be potty train or in a regular classroom. I am proud to say he has passed all this. I am also proud to say he loves to read. If you met him you would not even know; he just will not talk to you.
That's like mine, except he is developmentally delayed. As for the article OnA put, it's something that I had suspected all along. Unfortunately I don't have a degree to say it though. There is a pretty big difference in children w/ Aspberger's and children w/ other kinds of autism IMO
All of my boys were premature with my autistic son not necessarily a premmie but 36wks 6 days. So in my opinion not necessarily since my other boys have no issues.
Have you told your sons doctor he is getting worse? They can adjust his medication. My son has adhd. It is very difficult with him. I opted to keep him off medication to give him time to see if it will get better on his own. He is only 5 and will be starting 1st grade this year. I kept him off medication for the summer because I can handle it. Should his 1st grade teacher mention something to me then I will consider medication. His kindergarten teacher is the one that brought it up which is when I went to the doctors. Its worse at school than it is at home so I also think he is just bored with the work. He is very smart and makes great grades when I sit with him and make him finish his work. He just can't sit still long enough to finish it. His teacher even put him in the "star" reading group instead of the regular group. All that was was more difficult reading since hhe was breezing through the reading.
also, it's unorthodox, but let your older kids crawl through playground tubes. the act of crawling decreases adhd. a lot of times when babies go from carseat to bouncer to swing to bed they miss the exploratory stage of development. crawling is therapeutic.
Like others have said, special needs difficulties really just depend on the child. I think some of it also has to do with how the child is raised. My daughter had 2 in her class at school with down syndrome, one of the girls in her ballet class and one of the ballet teachers had a brother with it as well. All 4 of the boys are around the same age but all are different in their abilities and personalities. She also had 2 in her school class with ADHD. They were also on different levels.
No experience with autism but my daughter has a cousin her age with asperger's. He was able to memorize things very well at an early age. Other than that, when they play together you would not know one of them is 'special needs.' We don't get to see him often but my understanding is that he's supposed to have problems socializing. I haven't noticed this.
As far as I know (and what the Dr. has said), my daughter is not special needs. She is one hell of a handful though!
Non-stimulant, proved to be the best fit for his ADHD.
Mine too, but I have decided not to medicate him, something I've been questioning lately. He has ADD, he's not to hyperactive. My oldest couldn't have gone unmedicated! He eventually started weaning himself in high school, and is now a happy airman who's been w/o meds for 3 years!
I saw this on FB yesterday and just about exploded. One of my respite kids is quite wild and makes an assortment of loud and strange sounds, most of them very loud, and although she is not verbal, she can be very loving and affectionate which makes her more human than the person who wrote that letter.
makes her more human than the person who wrote that letter. exactly what i was thinking! what if she got in a car accident or had a stroke? according to her logic she should not put up with "not normal human behavior".
but of course my mind goes the other direction.... don't 100% rule out that the parent could have been writing it to herself to set up a neighbor she didn't care for using the news...
I read this and felt sorry for her. I am a mother of a child on the spectrum and understand. My son has some days where all he does is rock and makes sounds even though he is verbal. I am just amazed at him some days and wonder what are they thinking twirling and just making their sounds its like music to my ears. Just be blessed they are able to express themselves regardless of how they can communicate with us.