Lewis Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lewis bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Fort Lewis housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Should health care pay for abortions?

who's talking here?

ShamWow 1
Tange 5
Katena 1
babycakes 2
mamarex 1
just PINK 1
Brenda E 1
Leesah 2
Shelley S 2
details 1
myopinion 5
AwesomeSauce 1
4MyFYI 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

4MyFYI --- 14 years ago -

We where talking about this in my Survey for Social problems class and it became very heated, so Ill ask you guys. Do you think that medical insurance should pay for abortions if they cover prenatal care already?[b][/b] 

myopinion --- 14 years ago -

That's a retarded statement. No offense to you. Your not the maker of this outlandish statement. I can not believe professors will tolerate this type of thinking.
If insurance pays for prenatal why not abortions? The 

AwesomeSauce --- 14 years ago -

Ahhhh tough topic. I don't think I could get an abortion personally, but respect a woman's right to choose. I think that allowing insurance to cover abortions also allows it to be abused. It's an elective procedure... If there is no reason, health-wise, to get one- I think it should be under the same restrictions as an elective procedure. 

Katena --- 14 years ago -

This is a tough one but it is elective and unless it was medically necessary. We have to jump threw hoops for so many other things why should an abortion be so easy to get. I have been in the shoes where I almost had one and decided against it. !8 years later he has grown into an awesome young man. I believe it is a woman right to choose 

myopinion --- 14 years ago -

I looked up the bill. It has a lot of support backing it. This will obviously change the course of mankind if it passes. I didn't read anything about partial birth abortion in the bill though. So I'm sure the guidelines will be cut and dry. 

4MyFYI --- 14 years ago -

MO no offense at all, I am prochoice. I think that there should be a cut off point for sure, like b4 10 weeks or something. I think that people can be very closed minded but if aperson can not manage to give the baby up for adoption then yes they should have the option to have an abortion. I feel medical coverage in whole has so many red tape to cutt through that it needs to change in more ways then just this 

4MyFYI --- 14 years ago -

But that being said I think that they should make adoption a little easier, regardless of the childs age. In a perfect world, they would be able to take the unborn fetus out of 1 person and place into another. I think at some point the medical world will come to this atleast I hope becasue of all the people out there tht are dealing with fertility issues 

details --- 14 years ago -

It's an elective procedure... If there is no reason, health-wise, to get one- I think it should be under the same restrictions as an elective procedure. 

This. 

myopinion --- 14 years ago -

We agree on one thing.
In a perfect world we would be able to transfer fetuses.
However labeling pro-life as narrow minded makes me laugh. Please in a society as barbaric as ours. Where drugs.... sex.....involve children. Where we have the HIGHEST murder rates. GOOGLE IT. Where our principal is if it feels good for you ....its your right to do it. Standing for something is Rare and gos against the stream. 

4MyFYI --- 14 years ago -

However labeling pro-life as narrow minded makes me laugh

Sorry I mis typed lol, no I dont think pro-life is narrow minded at all. I feel society is, guess i should have worded it better.

i feel it takes a big person to come to the mind set that they can not take care of a child the way it needs and how they choose to handle it is their choice. 

myopinion --- 14 years ago -

Regardless if society is narrow minded. We are society. If one can be elevated because they made a cognitive decision to terminate a life then in my opinion society is indeed narrow minded. Shouldn't the elevation start at the point of pre conception? IN A PERFECT WORLD? null 

Leesah --- 14 years ago -

No, and I think some States should stop covering it through Medicaid as well. Murder is murder. To me, the fetus is a human being, and the mother (of all people) has decided to end his or her life because she is inconvienced. It should NOT be used as a method of birth control. There is an exception in cases or rape, incest, if the mothers life is in danger, or if the baby wouldnt survive after a full term birth. 

Shelley S --- 14 years ago -

There is an exception in cases or rape, incest, if the mothers life is in danger, or if the baby wouldnt survive after a full term birth.

I think this should be the only time medical should be paid, otherwise, let the person pay for their own abortion if that's what they choose to do. I'm pro choice though. 

mamarex --- 14 years ago -

I'm all for pro-choice, but insurance shouldnt be required to cover abortions unless it's life-threatning or medically necessary. If you want to choose to abort your baby, then you can choose to pay for it. 

ShamWow --- 14 years ago -

I do not think insurance should cover any abortions unless it is a matter of the mothers life being at risk, or being a victim of rape/incest. I know a girl who was on welfare that used her medical 4 times for abortions because that was her form of birth control. I used to also see that all the time when I worked for a family practice doctor who supported abortions. I can't tell you how many women he sent over for an abortion and how many of them said they felt they made a mistake and it ruined their lives. So I can't say I support any insurance covering them except for the 2 things above. 

Brenda E --- 14 years ago -

I feel like it's unconstitutional to make private insurance provide abortion coverage, or otherwise really. It's no different than someone telling a store what it can and can't sell--it's PRIVATE... Aren't we supposed to have Obamacare now? how about they cover abortions? then they can come with the stipulation of an IUD!!!! free abortion? free IUD so they don't come back for another abortion. 

Tange --- 14 years ago -

Pro-choice here but I think I agree with the other ladies here in regards to whether insurance should cover it. There are also different alternatives than abortion if the main objective of having one isn't medically necessary. 

Tange --- 14 years ago -

You know whats funny, in Canada, abortion is covered 100% by OHIP that is the free medical that the country provides for everyone.

Do you know the reasons why they do that? It's to stop the perpetuation of children born to unwed mothers with no husband, eduction or decent employment. They would rather you work hard to get an education, seek an employment, establish a stable setting for a planned family all in the efforts to contribute to society as much as you can. Thus preventing the incline of people on welfare who are basically living on tax papers money.

Meanwhile in Canada it is RIDICULOUS how much money they give to families who are on welfare. Their paycheck increases by a ton fold for every child that is born. I guess if we (Canada) didn't provide free abortions we would probably see a devastating amount of people who would solely relay on the system which could crumble the finances distributed by the Canadian government. I remember reading somewhere that it also helps with keeping crime down. It's too much to explain really but the way they have things configured is incredible.

There is a lot more reason they give to why they cover abortions even though there is a rally of people who would profess against it. But in a way I see where they are coming from.

However Canada unlike the U.S is NOT a capitalist country, surgeries there is off the cost, medication is the only thing you have to pay for and that's the only insurance you are required to purchase. The cost of living is more because the businesses have to pay more. That's right you read that correctly. The more you make in Canada the more you have to contribute to sustain the countries financial growth to providing equally for the people. 

Tange --- 14 years ago -

I don't know if anyone cared to know that about Canada but after living in the U.S for three years, I have really begun to notice the differences. In Canada they are more concerned about preventing death of women who decide to have a back alley botched abortion than abusing the system.

Medically, I've been told that every time you have an abortion it decreases your chances of future pregnancies by 25%. 

babycakes --- 14 years ago -

Maybe a portion and that is a huge maybe! If they can prove where they have been on birth control, like the shot or implant or something like that, to prove they where trying to prevent it in the first place then ok. Everyone has there right to choose what to do with their own body but I am with the person who said it is murder. So many people are on a waiting list to have a baby, these are good loving homes and yet they have to sit and wait for someone to not be selfish and give the baby up for adoption. And yes I feel by getting an abortion because you dont want it is very very selfish!!!! It takes lots of love to give you baby up, and a split knee jerk choice to abort it (in some cases). Abortion will always eb around just like everything else but adoption is a way better option. 

babycakes --- 14 years ago -

As for the people on medicade getting abortions, they should be forced to take the depo shot b4 they can get their next check! I know hard times come and go and there is nothing wrong with needing help but they should also be made to prevent more mouths to feed aswell as take a drug test that they must pass! 

Tange --- 14 years ago -

I think that people can be very closed minded but if aperson can not manage to give the baby up for adoption then yes they should have the option to have an abortion.


eeeh... I hope I'm reading this correctly but are you saying that abortion should be provided just because they can't "emotionally" manage to give the baby up for adoption?

If that's the case, that is incredibly selfish, considering that that choice only pertains to the convenience of the mother's emotional obligation but not the betterment of the child who otherwise would be a healthy, blossoming life raised by parents who they themselves cannot conceive if they (the baby) were adopted. 

Shelley S --- 14 years ago -

I know hard times come and go and there is nothing wrong with needing help but they should also be made to prevent more mouths to feed aswell as take a drug test that they must pass!

I couldn't agree more! 

Tange --- 14 years ago -

If the mother wants to have an abortion that she herself could have easily prevented and not for medical but for "convenience" on her part that yeah b itch pay for it no one else should. 

myopinion --- 14 years ago -

Poor money into prevention. But come on really what does any of this matter when TV shows like I'm 16 and with child .....are some of the highest grossing. 

Leesah --- 14 years ago -

You know, this thread made me think of an article I read not too long ago... It was published in a medical ethics journal stating infanticide should be legal. The premise of the entire thing was that a newborn is pretty much the same being as a fetus. Neither has a moral status of an actual person, and it is irrelavent that they are potential persons. Because abortions are legal, infanticide should be as well. Even though I completely disagree that infanticide should be legal, I do agree with one thing they said. If there was no moral difference between abortion and killing newborns, then abortion too should be illegal. They actually called them after birth abortions to make their point. 

just PINK --- 14 years ago -

if they pay for abortions then they should pay for cosmetic surgery. yes i can name less then a handfull when it should be covered......
-if you were raped
- you are high risk for miscarriage due to terminal/longterm illnes
- you are high risk to die during child birth or during pregnacy
-pregnacy in tubes(thats like 50% change right?)
thats all i can think of. so no. but i guess that is also because i do not believe in Abortions. No one has the right to play God, yes i know people kill people all the time. they dont have the right to play God either 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lewis Underground