Lewis Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lewis bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Fort Lewis housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Soldier who killed Afghan villagers from Joint Base Lewis-McChord

who's talking here?

JustcallmeSuz 1
Sabrina 4
ShamWow 4
zuzu 1
FL GIRL 1
Tange 3
Katena 4
Apple Pie 11
Sandra 11
Kathryn 1
Megan LeeAnne 4
Maui Girl 2
Justmeandthefamilia 5
Happy in Washington 5
SweetPea 5
NadaSuperstar 5
MissyhatesLewis 1
mamarex 2
Pepper Potts 11
Marbleyes 2
JLiz 1
BelleAdoresMommaFriend 13
MASC 3
lil momma 1
Brenda E 18
ella ella 10
Mommy2SNL 1
myopinion 16
Pandaroni 1
4MyFYI 6
meanie 3
Samba 3
Aubogon 1
OnARoll 3
Deasnuts 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

FL GIRL --- 14 years ago -

Soldier who killed Afghan villagers from Joint Base Lewis-McChord

by Associated Press
Posted on March 11, 2012 at 8:53 AM
Updated today at 3:11 PM

WASHINGTON - A U.S. official says the American who killed 16 Afghan villagers Sunday is a soldier from Washington who was assigned to a remote special operations site.
U.S. officials say the soldier acted alone, leaving his base in southern Afghanistan and opening fire on sleeping families in two villages.
The official says he is a conventional soldier from Joint Base Lewis-McChord, Washington. He was assigned to support a special operations unit of either Green Berets or Navy SEALs engaged in a village stability operation.
Such operations are among NATO's best hopes for transitioning out of Afghanistan. They pair special operations troops with local villagers chosen by village elders to become essentially a sanctioned, armed neighborhood watch.
The officials spoke on condition of anonymity because the investigation is still ongoing.
AFghtan President Hamid Karzai called it an "assassination" and furiously demanded an explanation from Washington. Nine children and three women were among the dead.
The killing spree deepened a crisis between U.S. forces and their Afghan hosts over Americans burning Muslim holy books on a base in Afghanistan last month. The Quran burnings sparked weeks of violent protests and attacks that left some 30 dead. Six U.S. service members have been killed by their Afghan colleagues since the burnings came to light, and the violence had just started to calm down.
"This is an assassination, an intentional killing of innocent civilians and cannot be forgiven," Karzai said in a statement. He said he has repeatedly demanded the U.S. stop killing Afghan civilians.
President Barack Obama called the attack "tragic and shocking" and offered his condolences to the families of those killed. In a statement released by the White House, he vowed "to get the facts as quickly as possible and to hold accountable anyone responsible."
The violence over the Quran burnings had already spurred calls in the U.S. for a faster exit strategy from the 10-year-old Afghan war. Obama even said recently that "now is the time for us to transition." But he also said he had no plan to change the current timetable that has Afghans taking control of security countrywide by the end of 2014.
In the wake of the Quran burnings, the top U.S. commander in Afghanistan, Gen. John Allen, visited troops at a base that was attacked last month and urged them not to give in to the impulse for revenge.
The tensions between the two countries had appeared to be easing as recently as Friday, when the two governments signed a memorandum of understanding about the transfer of Afghan detainees to Afghan control -- a key step toward an eventual strategic partnership to govern U.S. forces in the country.
Sunday's shooting could push that agreement further away.
"This is a fatal hammer blow on the U.S. military mission in Afghanistan. Whatever sliver of trust and credibility we might have had following the burnings of the Quran is now gone," said David Cortright, the director of policy studies at Notre Dame's Kroc Institute for International Peace Studies and an advocate for a quick withdrawal from Afghanistan.
"This may have been the act of a lone, deranged soldier. But the people of Afghanistan will see it for what it was, a wanton massacre of innocent civilians," Cortright said.
The attack began around 3 a.m. in two villages in Panjwai district, a rural suburb of Kandahar and a traditional Taliban stronghold where coalition forces have fought for control for years. The villages -- Balandi and Alkozai -- are about 500 yards (meters) from a U.S. base.
The gunman went into three houses and opened fire, said a resident of Alkozai, Abdul Baqi, citing accounts from his neighbors.
"When it was happening in the middle of the night, we were inside our houses. I heard gunshots and then silence and then gunshots again," Baqi said.
One villager said eleven of those killed were members of his family, many of them women and children.
Some villagers questioned whether a single soldier could have killed so many people.
Karzai's statement said he spoke by phone to one of the five people wounded in the attack, a 15-year-old named Rafiullah, who was shot in the leg. The statement said the teenager told Karzai that American soldiers entered his house in the middle of the night, woke up his family and began shooting them.
However, Karzai only spoke in his statement of a single U.S. soldier involved.
A U.S. official in Washington also said the American, an Army staff sergeant, was believed to have acted alone and that initial reports indicated he returned to the base after the shooting and turned himself in.
An AP photographer saw 15 bodies in the two villages caught up in the shooting. Some of the bodies had been burned, while others were covered with blankets. A young boy partially wrapped in a blanket was in the back of a minibus, dried blood crusted on his face and pooled in his ear. His loose-fitting brown pants were partly burned, revealing a leg charred by fire.
An AP photo showed the bloodstained corner of a house next to a large black area that was charred by fire. The charred area appeared to be remnants of blankets and possibly bodies that had been set on fire.
Villagers packed inside the minibus looked on with concern as a woman spoke to reporters. She pulled back a blanket to reveal the body of a smaller child wearing what appeared to be red pajamas. A third dead child lay in a pile of green blankets in the bed of a truck.
NATO officials apologized for the shootings but did not confirm that anyone was killed, referring instead to reports of deaths.
"This deeply appalling incident in no way represents the values of ISAF and coalition troops or the abiding respect we feel for the Afghan people," Allen said in a statement, using the abbreviation for NATO's International Security Assistance Force.
He pledged a "rapid and thorough investigation" and vowed to ensure that "anyone who is found to have committed wrongdoing is held fully accountable."
NATO spokesman Justin Brockhoff said a U.S. service member had been detained at a NATO base as the alleged shooter. The wounded people were evacuated to NATO medical facilities, he added.
International forces have fought for control of Panjwai for years as they've tried to subdue the Taliban in their rural strongholds. The Taliban movement started just to the north of Panjwai, and many of the militant group's senior leaders, including chief Mullah Omar, were born, raised, fought or preached in the area. Omar once ran an Islamic school in an area of Panjwai that has since been carved into a new district.
In addition to its symbolic significance, the district is an important base for the Taliban to target the city of Kandahar to the east. Panjwai was seen as key to securing Kandahar when U.S. forces flooded the province as part of Obama's strategy to surge in the south starting in 2009.
Twelve of the dead were from Balandi, said Samad Khan, a farmer who lost all 11 members of his family, including women and children. Khan was away from the village when the incident occurred and returned to find his family members shot and burned. One of his neighbors was also killed, he said.
"This is an anti-human and anti-Islamic act," said Khan. "Nobody is allowed in any religion in the world to kill children and women."
Khan and other villagers demanded that Karzai punish the American shooter.
"Otherwise we will make a decision," said Khan. "He should be handed over to us."
The four people killed in the village of Alkozai were all from one family, said a female relative who was shouting in anger. She did not give her name because of the conservative nature of local society.
"No Taliban were here. No gunbattle was going on," said the woman. "We don't know why this foreign soldier came and killed our innocent family members. Either he was drunk or he was enjoying killing civilians."
The Taliban called the shootings the latest sign that international forces are working against the Afghan people.
"The so-called American peace keepers have once again quenched their thirst with the blood of innocent Afghan civilians in Kandahar province," the Taliban said in a statement posted on a website used by the insurgent group.
Karzai said he was sending a high-level delegation to investigate.
U.S. forces have been implicated before in other violence in the same area.
Four soldiers from a Stryker brigade out of Lewis-McChord, Washington, have been sent to prison in connection with the 2010 killing of three unarmed men during patrols in Kandahar province's Maiwand district, which is just northwest of Panjwai. They were accused of forming a "kill team" that murdered Afghan civilians for sport -- slaughtering victims with grenades and powerful machine guns during patrols, then dropping weapons near their bodies to make them appear to have been combatants.
And in January, before the Quran burning incident, a video that purportedly showed U.S. Marines urinating on corpses of men they had killed sparked widespread outrage.
Obama has apologized for the Quran burnings and said they were a mistake. The Qurans and other Islamic books were taken from a detention facility and dumped in a burn pit last month because they were believed to contain extremist messages or inscriptions. A military official said at the time that it appeared detainees were exchanging messages by making notations in the texts. 

Sandra --- 14 years ago -

How shameful. 

BelleAdoresMommaFriend --- 14 years ago -

Yeah, I read about that......
What is to be said..... 

ella ella --- 14 years ago -

my exact response, was can you blame this guy, his mental state im sure was not right, and how many times has he been over and the things he sees, its not that easy to get mental help trust me I KNOW ! hence why a lot of soldiers come home and go psycho and try to get help and they get blown off because that one person ruined it for all. Im not mad at this guy at all, im not saying its okay, im saying hes not only to blame 

BelleAdoresMommaFriend --- 14 years ago -

Haha ella, I am actually having this exact same argument with my family at the moment. I am arguing that though what he did is wrong, I am beyond sure that he must have been suffering severe PTSD. And unless you have been in his shoes and seen what I am sure he has seen, you really have no right to judge.
They(my family) all think we should hand the guy one to AF government to be tried. And I am fighting back how wrong it would be to turn our back on him now. He is the product of our own making based on the things we(the military) have asked him to see and do.
How could we now drop him. 

BelleAdoresMommaFriend --- 14 years ago -

I mean I am personally mad at the guy for being so selfish and further endangering the lives of his fellow soldiers over there to include my husband, but I also sympathies with the situation the guy must have been living in. 

Sandra --- 14 years ago -

He was assigned to support a special operations unit of either Green Berets or Navy SEALs engaged in a village stability operation.

This particular group of soldier is the most damaged by the war. I know by personal experience because my husband is part of a special unit and a lot is told to 'suck it up' and a lot of red flags are ignored because you are trained to do more therefore expected to tolerate more. I have seen it first hand. The mind is not a muscle, it hurts the same for all of us and just because he is a special forces soldier it doesn't necessarily mean mentally he can endure more. He just sees a lot more and worse. I don't want to be misinterpreted, what he did is shameful and he does need to be punished. Believe it or not my heart aches for the family members of these poor victims. I put myself in their shoes and if me and my family were sleeping and all of a sudden a person that is supposed to help me comes in my home and shoots everyone, I'd want justice. But this man is sick, so hopefully they allow the US to take care of punishing him because if they allow them to do it, it's gonna get ugly. And hopefully, the US does justice not declare him mentally incompetent and let him off the hook, that is not justice either. 

ella ella --- 14 years ago -

Belle, you said !

I am not saying what he did is right or wrong, yet I can not judge the guy at all. I dont know what he sees, but being a army wife, and getting to meet soldiers, that are husbands, fathers and see them return from such situations for the 1, 2, 3rd time even they never come back the same.

So im sure he had issues thats common sense, is it wrong well yes, but yet we say its okay to go to war, and kill the enemy, and the enemy to some may include the WHOLE country not just one group. 

ella ella --- 14 years ago -

This particular group of soldier is the most damaged by the war.



AGREE ! 

Sandra --- 14 years ago -

and the enemy to some may include the WHOLE country not just one group.

This is always a very lively discussion between my husband and I that I don't think we'll ever agree on. He says once you get there, you have to be suspicious of every single soul, even the babies. He has seen mothers hide stuff in their baby's clothes and diaper. I feel sorry for the innocent people who have no fault. What can they do? Move away? They are poor, they are stuck in a hostile war that came to their neighborhoods. Imagine if all of a sudden our neighboring countries decided to move in on us, what do we do if we're broke? But he insists that you never let your guard down and even if a kid is looking at you, you always assume he has a pistol in his toy or pocket. This is how soldiers come home. It's become a joke among our military friends when we go to a restaurant that they all fight for the damn seat that faces the front door. Then they laugh and say 'dont worry I got the door covered'. This is NOT funny. And I totally just veered off the subject, but anyhoo, that's how I feel! 

ella ella --- 14 years ago -

@Sandra, my husband says the same thing ! I dont think its a joke, when my husband came back he couldnt be in large crowds for the longest time, anyone who looked weird that would even approach our son who was an infant just to say how cute your baby is blah blah blah, hed freak the F OUT !

I have no respect whether your a child or a woman in that country, they are all brainwashed, and you cant trust them, not sayin all are this way but its their way of living. 

Sandra --- 14 years ago -

he couldnt be in large crowds for the longest time,

Mine too, and he can't stand feeling 'crowded in', even on the highway, if there is a car in front and on either side of us he gets upset and feels frustrated and immediately gets out of that situation. He hates large crowds and when people all speak at one time (which my family does all the time haha) or when too loud. He also once freaked out during a movie in a scene where there was a take from above that shows a man strapped to a bomb walk into a crowded place, I forgot the name of the movie. He freaked out, he said 'hes got a bomb!' and for a few seconds hyperventilated and I tried to calm him down, smack in the middle of the movie theater on post, it took him a few minutes to get a grip. This was a few years back, I think it's improved, but other things have not, he's got very little patience and I've come to make peace with that. I think our soldiers needs are sometimes overlooked. He has injuries that he was told to 'suck up' and now he's 40 and walks and feels like a 70 yr old. Every morning he gets up and has to sit by the side of the bed and slowly get up like an old man. It's so sad. He's in pain every day. All because he listened when told to suck it up, he's now paying. And because he can no longer jump, the army is no longer interested in him. But that's a whole nother story hehehe! 

ella ella --- 14 years ago -

Oh boy !!!!!!! See it effects everyone, yet you cant really just get up and get out when your contract ends, most jobs leave you no skills really to go in the real world, they suck you in with the benefits, each re enlisment for my husband has been during a deployment and so is the next one, how the hell can he get a job being deployed !

I have seen soldiers come back and totally neglect (not intentionally) their families, whether it be drink their lives away, or become to devoted to their jobs. I have even have heard of them saying that their next deployments they think that its it for them, how sad is that.

I fear my husband next deployment and its to Afghan more then Iraq, it creeps me out just the thought of something happenng I cant imagine how he feels. 

JustcallmeSuz --- 14 years ago -

That explains all the news trucks outside Madigan gate. 

BelleAdoresMommaFriend --- 14 years ago -

See I love reading these responses. Out of my family, only myself and my husband have ever served and so they have no clue what it is like. It is completely true that when you are over there, you have to be suspicious of EVERY one. I personally spent months investigating a group that was hiding explosives on pregnant women who were then trying to blend into the crowd when ever a US convo would come along.
My family are all wanting to leave him there and saying he deserves whatever AF sentences him to but they don't understand the dynamics behind the military life.
It's like punishing a dog you have trained to attack and nothing but attack for one day turning and attacking the wrong person. 

ShamWow --- 14 years ago -

All I can say is hope his actions dont get any other soldiers killed. My best friends 18yo son just got deployed there and another friends son is on his way soon. This guy is going to be responsible for taking these lives plus the soldiers he gets injured or killed. I'd hate to be his wife and have to deal with the fallout that will follow. How horrible. 

ella ella --- 14 years ago -

It's like punishing a dog you have trained to attack and nothing but attack for one day turning and attacking the wrong person. 


perfectly said ! 

Sandra --- 14 years ago -

My best friends 18yo son just got deployed there and another friends son is on his way soon.

My son will be joining soon, I'm heartbroken =( Hopefully something drastic happens soon so we're the hell out of all those places, but I doubt it. 

NadaSuperstar --- 14 years ago -

I am not saying what this solider did is right. There is always more to a story than what is printed. My brother was a Marine in Kandahar ten years ago. There was an incident where there were women and children with bombs attached to them ( it was their calling according to Allah) came to their camp. It was shoot to kill or be blown up themselves. My brother is haunted by that to do this day. There is not enough basis to this story released yet. If the solider did have mental issues, he should be tried and treated as such. There are a lot of incidents that have happened there that are not reported in the news. Does it hit the news whenever Afghan men blow up a group of soliders? They are treated like heros and celebrated......You don't see it being released to the news. I feel like the US soliders are held under a microscope and any event involving the killing of a foreigner is treated as a crime....like they are not individuals thrust in a war zone with often inadequate mental health care. 

NadaSuperstar --- 14 years ago -

I guess the point I am trying to make is that there are innocent Afghans and there are others who are not so innocent. And sometimes soliders are ordered to do things and take a fall for it. 

Pepper Potts --- 14 years ago -

But he insists that you never let your guard down and even if a kid is looking at you, you always assume he has a pistol in his toy or pocket. This is how soldiers come home.

Def one of the toughest issues facing our soldiers over there. This whole story hits incredibly close to home given where my hubby is & what he's been up to. I am thankful he is just naturally one of those guys that takes in details & like you said, always positions himself in a place to see everything, whether in a restaurant facing the door or in Afghanistan handing out candy on patrol. It's tough to know that the villagers are often Taliban pawns, often threatened with horrid consequences for not bearing arms against our soldiers. Worse, that's their norm. They have never maintained peace, even amongst themselves. 

Mommy2SNL --- 14 years ago -

I agree and feel the same as many of you ladies. My husband is over there too so of course I worry about the repercussions of this soldier's actions, but I can't say I blame him nor do I fully support it. What is there to say about it.... 

myopinion --- 14 years ago -

Does this soldier understand the sh-t storm he possibly started for the other soldiers over there right now? CNN is reporting this morning the Taliban is calling for revenge. He was a father of Two and married. He slaughtered 11 people. Sources confirm most were women and children. They were sleeping. My heart gos out to his wife .... to his children who will have to grow up not with a war hero who paid the ultimate sacrifice. No.....something different. My heart gos out to the women and children in Afghanistan ....to their lives that were cut short after living them already in treacherous circumstances. The world is a complicated place one where the the good guy can apparently become the bad guy. 

ella ella --- 14 years ago -

myopinion, until your in his state of mind, can you really judge him, he has done 4 tours overseas im sure he isnt stable in any shape way or form. No one come backs the same person.

So to judge him isnt okay.
We really dont know what happened we only read and watch whats reported and no one will ever know his state of mind and his life story on why this happened.

Revenge yes he may have started but is this any different to the war were in that these countries have started by killing our people ?

Not saying its okay but its a two way road. To feel sorry for them something that is in their hands, and all the time money, we have devoted to these countries just to make peace I think people forget that. ! 

Justmeandthefamilia --- 14 years ago -

I was hearing about this on the news, and it is a possibility the soldier has PTSD, so may soldiers are suffering from PTSD, and not getting the help they need. It is shame it had came to him just going off and killing all those people. 

Brenda E --- 14 years ago -

I agree with my opinion...and I don't care how much trauma he has had...he blew away nine little kids in the middle of the night...if he is THAT sick or mentally unstable he should be locked away....if he had fragged a bunch of fellow soldiers, people wouldn't be sympathizing so much with him..


He had been through three tours in Iraq..who HASN'T at this point??? He could be a cook for all we know or a fobbit..(or he could have been on the ground and had three hard tours, but again who hasn't at this point? I know more who have then have not..it's been a decade of war..it's no excuse)

the article says he was "a CONVENTIONAL soldier ATTACHED to a Special Unit" that doesn't mean he was "special" in anyway or has endured anything more traumatic because of his assignment. All it means as far as we know is he was support for them, which could mean he was working their mail room for all we know.


PTSD will never be an excusable defense for murdering babies in their beds while they sleep...I think THAT is a disservice to the REST of the Soldiers suffering from PTSD who are unfairly being labeled as murderous ticking time bombs, because a few psychopaths kill overseas.

What he has done puts the lives of all the soldiers and civilians over there, more in danger than they already are. I feel terrible for his wife and children ~

But if you are capable of the murder of 16 PEOPLE in Cold Bold-while they lay with eyes closed...you are a danger to everyone around at home or anywhere and I would never release someone capable of that back to society..PTSD or other. What makes him ANY different that Nidal Hassan?! who is saying he was "mentally unstable" as well and really sites the same reasons, we are speculating in this case..revenge, stress, etc...I say make them cell mates 

Justmeandthefamilia --- 14 years ago -

Brenda, I wasn't trying to make an excuse for him, there is never any kind of excuse for doing what he did, all I am saying is there are so many soldiers out there suffering from PTSD and it is a big problem with in the military, it is not just the people this soldier killed, but also military families are getting hurt and killed because of PTSD, if a soldier does not get help he needs, and/or his Co is ignoring all signs this is the result of what is going to happen and until we address the issues at hand and get our soldiers the help they need then this is going to continue to happen. I know all this is speculation, but why else would he snap? He has other tours over seas. I agree they need to lock him up, but don't just lock him and throw away the key, he needs help, obviously there is something really wrong in his head. 

ella ella --- 14 years ago -

But your okay with war ? How is war any different going out and killing people whether they are terriosts or not ?

And them killing our troops ?

Isnt that cold blood murder also ?

oh wait it makes it okay because were at war and have *TARGETS*

And if your not a soldier you really dont know.. and wont know. No matter what your spouse tells you just saying.

To make such a opinion as above on a person youve never met is insane.

And yes PTSD is a real thing just like any mental issue that makes you have a breaking point, whether it be towards someone else, or yourself.

Yes it could have happened here. But also he is around his superiors every day.. EVERYDAY im sure. And someone should have noticed I highly doubt it just was out of NO WHERE he SNAPPED.

The army doesnt give a damn to provide enough resources and its hard enough to get them, if your stuck in the middle of no where.

Who cares, if he was a cook, or special ops. A deployment is a deployment doesnt matter your job. 

ella ella --- 14 years ago -

Brenda, I wasn't trying to make an excuse for him, there is never any kind of excuse for doing what he did, all I am saying is there are so many soldiers out there suffering from PTSD and it is a big problem with in the military, it is not just the people this soldier killed, but also military families are getting hurt and killed because of PTSD, if a soldier does not get help he needs, and/or his Co is ignoring all signs this is the result of what is going to happen and until we address the issues at hand and get our soldiers the help they need then this is going to continue to happen. 



Perfectly said. 

SweetPea --- 14 years ago -

This is so sad!!

All I could think about is, what if this was one of my family members sleeping out there and was killd for no reason..Would I blame it on the PTSD??? I dont know, but my heart does go out to those innocent lives and to that soldier. 

page 1 2 3 4 5 6
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lewis Underground