Lewis Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lewis bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Fort Lewis housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

A question on the seasons.

who's talking here?

Pepper Potts 3
myopinion 3
AwesomeSauce 1
4MyFYI 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

myopinion --- 14 years ago -

I read an article about seasonal depression. It stated a new challenge for the medical field to affirm this as more related to "PTSD" type symptoms. So say your not a depressive type ....and a relative dies in November. And you are emotionally affected. Thus every November you transfer to that state of mind again. Unless you become aware of this you rotate. So do you believe in seasonal depression? Or do you feel its a cycle of behavior brought on by grief? 

AwesomeSauce --- 14 years ago -

It's still seasonal in most cases I think- its a chemical change in your body, usually due to lack of sun. It was a big problem in Maine for the same reason it is here. Lots of clouds and rain, worse in the winter with shorter days, makes for some grumpy people. a relative dying in November would still be a problem, but would just add to an existing problem. 

Pepper Potts --- 14 years ago -

I like stuff like this. I'd guess both exist independently of one another. Separate disorders that can play out at the same time even. One, seasonal affective disorder (SAD) & the other, like you said, PTSD triggered by an emotional event. The fact that both can be chocked up to chemical imbalances is where things get confusing to me. At what point is it less science & more heart & vice versa? 

myopinion --- 14 years ago -

RIGHT? Both of you make sense and have proper data backing you up.
I'm interested in the theory of seasonal depression being stemmed from a catastrophic event. No other pre-exsisting mental disorders.
The question of the heart is so up my ally. I always consider science to be a tool JUST THAT A TOOL. Say this....you had a medical issue that almost took your life in January . Thus every year January comes and your whole body mind spirit changes. How is that a Pre existing issue? 

Pepper Potts --- 14 years ago -

I wonder about this too. My adoptive dad goes through a depression every July. Like clockwork. He had a traumatic life event in July. He has no pre-existing medical issues, but a switch flips in July & he is psychologically irritable...I don't know how else to say it. He regresses to a cynical/depressive mentality for like 2 months. 

myopinion --- 14 years ago -

Yes this is what I'm referring to. My mother had a patient who went nuts.
Google shooting in Nevada County CA. At state office. In 2000 20001?
Gosh even the year is hazy still. 

Pepper Potts --- 14 years ago -

Geez, that's comforting. I must be googling it wrong, I can't find it. Still, I seriously worry about my mom because dad turns into a dipwad for a couple of months. He has an intense personality to begin with & this throws him over the edge. My sister got married in September & this will be the first "depressive season" that he goes through without the reality check of having other people around (i.e., us kids.) Anyhow, we are visiting this summer because that's how it worked out with school & all, but I am secretly sighing with relief that my mom won't have to weather this alone just yet. 

4MyFYI --- 14 years ago -

do you feel its a cycle of behavior brought on by grief?

In the cases you have stated above I think it is this. Almost a PTSD situation. I have a friend who lost her child in November and you can not even talk about the month of November or thanksgiving ( it happened on thanksgiving) without her dazing out and becoming flush.

Somethings in life are just to hard or tramatic to get over and depending on the situation depends on the trigger that brings back all the emotions related to it. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lewis Underground