Lewis Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lewis bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Fort Lewis housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Commissary Vs Off-post groceries

who's talking here?

Lewismomma3 1
Eliz 1
AlohaLohi 1
Skay 1
Kathryn 1
Kristin 2
Neci 1
Hooah Wifey 1
SimplySarah 1
armywife1026 1
FoleysWifey 4
ellaella 1
BaByMaKeS4 3
fam0f3 2
MoreThanJustAnArmyWife 3
MonstersMomma 2
Brenda E 3
ImissAz 4
Marleysmomma 1
Yogis Mommy 2
Displaced New Englander 3
a3109748uu 5
ARMYDUDE 1
NotACityGirl 2
Leesah 3
wengdongdong 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

a3109748uu --- 15 years ago -

I am curious, what do you guys like more for grocery shopping? The commissary doesn't have taxes, but the deals seem to be better at Wal-Mart/Sams Club. 

ImissAz --- 15 years ago -

We only shop off post! Save so much for us! We shop at winco => 

Hooah Wifey --- 15 years ago -

I went to walmart day before yesterday n the prices were almost the same than last night trip to the commissary where for 10 bags of groceries I paid $250 n that was w like $15 in coupons :O I knew it was pricier here but WOW from 5.98 for toilet paper at Ft Sill to almost $9 for the same here is like way too much. I might start doing couponing very seriously :/ Btw where's winco? 

a3109748uu --- 15 years ago -

Another question: Does JBLM have COLA? It sounds like the cost of living is pretty dang high there... 

ImissAz --- 15 years ago -

Yeah this place is pretty pricey, but we never spend more then 100 every 2wks in food 

FoleysWifey --- 15 years ago -

No we don't have cola. I shop at winco also and only spend $60 every 2 weeks. It's just me n hubby though, I buy baby food at Walmart. There isn't tax on food so if you buy stuff that there is tax on its only like $5.00 max for tax so I don't see it as a big deal. 

Kathryn --- 15 years ago -

Last I checked we got like $25 a month in COLA something like that. You see COLA when you move overseas. It is funny that the cost of living is a lot more here than in my home state of Texas yet the BAH rates for Texas(my area) are WAY HIGHER than here and rent is so much more out here! 

a3109748uu --- 15 years ago -

Yes, the BAH seems unfair for that area. It seems very hard to find a house to rent that is comparable in size to what is available on base. 

Leesah --- 15 years ago -

I know what you mean Kathryn. We are from the DFW and our BAH was higher with a lower cost of living... Stupid Washington. How did you manage to get COLA, we dont get it. 

Leesah --- 15 years ago -

You guys have really low grocery bills, I need to spend less, haha. I think $100 a week is a good week for us at winco/walmart. I hate the commissary. 

fam0f3 --- 15 years ago -

We primarily only shop at the commissary. In my personal experience I spent more at walmart out here than the commissary. I would pay 90/4 days of groceries at walmart and 200/2 weeks groceries at the commissary. Our neighbor only uses winco and says they took 150 off their grocery bill, family of 6. IDK how they did that because winco doesn't seem like much of a difference to me. Suppose it's all in how and what you buy though. Costco is a big one for us too, I'm always in there for something :) 

ImissAz --- 15 years ago -

We love winco & costco without going to Costco our bill is no higher then $100 and that's a basket full of goodies lol! But when we go to both it goes to $150-$160 but no more then that ever. We tried on post and for what we got at winco we paid over $300 so we stick to off post shopping! 

Skay --- 15 years ago -

I'm not a fan of the commissary but it is cheaper than most stores off post.. i'm sure you can find this and that cheaper off but overall I spend less at the commissary 

Marleysmomma --- 15 years ago -

I shop at the commissary. We spend 175 and feed 5 people 2 weeks. We have 2 teen boys too, and they eat a lot! I wasn't impressed with winco and Walmart is very close on prices, but most of their prices are for their brand, not the name brand I buy on post, so with coupons, and we bag ourselves to save on tip, and we live on post, so we save on gas, we for our our family it's the best choice. 

armywife1026 --- 15 years ago -

we love winco!
&there's one in lakewood. 

ImissAz --- 15 years ago -

We go to the one that just opened in tac, we use to drive to the one in Lacey! And we wasn't to impressed with the one in puy! :) lovvvve winco 

MonstersMomma --- 15 years ago -

we usually go to safeway or albertsons depending on the sales when we need groceries... i hate the comm. here.. since wa doesnt tax food i dont see the point in paying an extra 5%surcharge at the comm.
depending on the month 200$ worth of groceries usually lasts us all month. (fam of 3) 

Lewismomma3 --- 15 years ago -

I find that most of the things we buy are cheaper at the commissary. If I stuck to mostly to the "Great Value" store brand products at Walmart and only bought brand names with coupons, I could probably keep the bill closer to the price at the commissary but it would take more work and more planning to do so and we'd be very limited in what we could buy without spending more. The other grocery store near us is Safeway and that would be MUCH more expensive no matter what. I only go there for quick trips for things like bread or stuff from their bakery (the commissary bakery is sad. lol!)

I tend to stick to 1 big shopping trip per pay period at the commissary using coupons. I can fill up a cart, include lots of in-season fruits and vegetables and spend less that $200 with coupons. I doubt I could buy enough food to last about 2 weeks for a family of 5 for under $200 anywhere else. 

Neci --- 15 years ago -

We shop at Walmart. There's no tax on food off post. If we buy something that isn't food or soda, the taxes on it are usually less than or about the same as the 'surcharge' we get charged on post. We've gotten WAY more from Walmart for the same price or less than at the commi. The thing about Walmart is there are the off brands, i.e. Great Value, that are a lot cheaper. We got 4 boxes of flavored mashed potatoes (with 2 packets, which is 2 separate meals for us, in each box) 4 for $4. If you don't mind looking a little more, the deals are easy to find. 

Brenda E --- 15 years ago -

lol I spend like 800 a month on groceries, but my husband refuses to eat anything out of a box pretty much..in 11 years, I can say i have never fed the man a single box of Hamburger helper, never made sloppy joes, no chicken nuggets for the kids, no pizza rolls, no frozen meals at all etc..everything we buy is veggies, fruits, meats, grains,dairy etc and it's mostly organic...the kids get some boxed treats like fruit snacks and crackers and juice boxes but all organic and then my son being on a gluten free/dairy free diet adds about 150-ish to the groceries... I did coupon about 53 $$ of food at the commissary last time, but that was all single items,not like 10 boxes of mac and cheese, or 8 toothpastes etc. It was all things already on my list that I looked up coupons for..

on payday I spent 300 in the commissary, 125 at the case lot sale, and I just spent 90 at costco yesterday..costco was almost all fruit and veggies, except for some hummus and cheese...the case lot we bought a whole salmon, 25, a giant roast 20, etc...

The surcharge at the commissary is the same as tax pretty much which sucks, but for the things I buy the commissary is cheaper about 70% of the time..the other 30% isn't worth chasing around .50 cents for from store to store with three kids, after gas and time(which is money!) I figure I am about the same and only made one stop...there is ton of things I would rather do than drive all over town to save 25 bucks even... 

Brenda E --- 15 years ago -

We are a family of five..and I swear my husband eats for three men! we spend way less when he is tdy and then I head straight for the corndogs for a break!lol!! we eat a lot of pb&j and cereal for dinner when he is gone!! lol 

BaByMaKeS4 --- 15 years ago -

wow i need the secret for you ladies spending only 100 every 2 weeks!!! normally we shop monthly and spend over 600 for 3 people!!! ridiculous i know!! we are trying going every 2 weeks and getting only what we need not what we want... we went last week and spent 210 with 10 dollars in coupons at the commionsary... i normally dont shop there i go to WinCo or Grocery Outlet then Walmart.. i stay away from Safeway and Alberstons. there way more expensive, QFC isnt bad when they have specials.. 

BaByMaKeS4 --- 15 years ago -

oh and for bulk items we use costco but i have coupons and only buy we what need there... 

fam0f3 --- 15 years ago -

depending on the month 200$ worth of groceries usually lasts us all month.


So then what are you buying, if you don't mind me asking. I suck at cooking so I do a lot of like hamburger helper and homemade pizza or stuff like that. I find that making actual meals are much more expensive. I usually have random stuff left over after our 2 weeks, but I still will go out and buy another 200 in groceries the next week. 

BaByMaKeS4 --- 15 years ago -

meats alone when we purchase coast 100 dollars or more!! 

Yogis Mommy --- 15 years ago -

meat is way more expensive at winco ---- i know cause ive cross referenced receipts.....between food, necessities like tp, cleaner, deodorant, laundry soap, etc...and diapers....our bill is 200.....at the commissary.....so take away all the extra necessities and count only food....the commissary isnt that bad...just don't shop on payday...they raise prices.... 

ellaella --- 15 years ago -

OFF POST ! ALL THE WAY !

WINCO !

poor quality at the commissarry ! the meat is nasty !


YUCK ! 

Yogis Mommy --- 15 years ago -

We buy enough meats for 14 meals every time we go....we get boneless chicken thighs (which feeds our entire family) and its only like 3.52 a package....steaks we get the large pack (5 something) and split them up into meals....and ground beef--- our meat bill for 3, is about 50 a pay check..... 

FoleysWifey --- 15 years ago -

We spend $6 on chicken and $10 on turkey every 2 weeks. Then once every 2-3 months we buy things like the boxed noodles or mashed potatoes which we haven't had to buy in 2 months. We don't buy chips, snacks of any kind, or soda. 

MoreThanJustAnArmyWife --- 15 years ago -

Dang I need to know some secrets too! lol i've been trying to coupon, usually saves us anywhere from $10-$25 every time we go to the commissary. For just my husband and I we usually spend about $300 every month for groceries.... Idk if that's super good or not, but we are both pretty cheap and try to buy things that are on sale, we also get some meat, and fruit!

I'm not a very good cook, so we do eat mostly boxed meals. I swear I need to take a cooking class! lol 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lewis Underground