Lewis Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lewis bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Fort Lewis housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Death row inmates...

who's talking here?

JessiKa yells roll tide 1
Shelley 1
kimmieg00 1
Kathryn 6
CountryKitchen 3
FoleysWifey 6
Forever Wickless 2
Marissa12 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

FoleysWifey --- 15 years ago -

So I read an article awhile back about a guy being on death row for multiple murders. He petitioned the courts to let him donate organs to 'give back' I think its a good idea and people on death row should donate organs. As long as they are still good after they receive the death penalty. Does anyone else agree? 

JessiKa yells roll tide --- 15 years ago -

Yea, totally! As long as it's a fully functioning healthy organ, why not. Not like he will need it anyways. 

Forever Wickless --- 15 years ago -

I dont see why they shouldnt be allowed to donate. A good organ is a good organ period no matter where it came from as long as it was harvested legally. Im an organ donor b/c the way I see it, im dead what the heck do I need them for?? 

Kathryn --- 15 years ago -

I think inmates bodies should be donated to science, without the consent of the prisoner. 

kimmieg00 --- 15 years ago -

i agree but on the other hand i dont know if i would want a murders organs. it just seems i dont know icky? I know they wouldnt make you kill anyone but i would feel bad having that part in me 

Forever Wickless --- 15 years ago -

dont know if i would want a murders organs

I thought the rule was they dont tell you where it comes from unless u go digging for the info yourself. 

Kathryn --- 15 years ago -

I think being a death row organ, the person getting it should get a choice. A lot of people say the embody a part of the donater's life, I would not want a killer's or molestor's kidney, just sayin'! 

FoleysWifey --- 15 years ago -

I feel the same way, who knows how many lives they could save!

Someone else was freaked out about it, its not like those organs will make you evil. It's just a body part!

I think their skin should be used for people burned that need skin grafts, it might be creepy but if I needed it, I wouldn't object just bc they did something to receive the death penalty. 

FoleysWifey --- 15 years ago -

If I was dieing and the only organ was coming from a murderer or worse...d@mm straight i would take it...I don't believe it will make me a bad person at all. 

Kathryn --- 15 years ago -

Foley, I agree, I do not think they should get a choice. When they got themselves onto death row, they lost the right to decide their afterlife. 

Kathryn --- 15 years ago -

...I don't believe it will make me a bad person at all.


Totally wasn't saying that!!!! I think it should happen, just don't know how I would feel waking up with a bad guy's body part lol! 

FoleysWifey --- 15 years ago -

The guy that kept fighting it felt it would give him piece of mind that at least a tiny portion of his life would be used for good, he felt it was giving back for the horror he ensued. Which if the makes him happy, let them use the organs. Hes gonna be dead so might as well save some lives you know? 

FoleysWifey --- 15 years ago -

Idk if I would even think about that lol...I would just be happy to be alive and have another day with my loved ones. I totally get what your saying though. 

CountryKitchen --- 15 years ago -

This is a good topic! I am PRO Death Penalty the only problem with it is that we don't use it enough! YES I do think they should donate any usable organs. And I think we should execute quicker instead of letting people sit on death row for years costing the tax payers to feed and house them.

I am from AZ and the state just executed a man that killed two people back in the 80's for less than 100 bucks. freakin loser should have been put to death a long time ago. I know it sounds harsh but that is my outlook on it,. 

Kathryn --- 15 years ago -

Totally agree Country- BUT with DNA matches some people are being freed who have spent half their life behind bars. I think that if their is a DNA match then do it ASAP, take em' out back and get it done! 

Kathryn --- 15 years ago -

there* sorry 

Marissa12 --- 15 years ago -

Hmm...very interesting girls! There is a book called Change of Heart by Jodi Picoult. It deals with this very situation and is a great read!! 

FoleysWifey --- 15 years ago -

Agreed country! Have any of you heard how much it costs to keep a prisoner daily! It's a ridiculous amount! Some prisons they even get laptops and video chats, its more of a luxury...no stress, no job....even for the ones that get out, they get money! So commit a crime, go to prison and get a lol vacation, get paid to get out and get a job quicker than someone who has never done anything wrong in their life!

@marissa, ill look for it. I love to read! 

Shelley --- 15 years ago -

I say let them donate if they want. At least then there is at least ONE good thing they did in their life, as far as their afterlife, well that's between them and (fill in the blank here). 

CountryKitchen --- 15 years ago -

BUT with DNA matches some people are being freed who have spent half their life behind bars. I think that if their is a DNA match then do it ASAP, take em' out back and get it done!



Yes I know what you mean, I really love this topic because I study this sort of thing, The people who are being freed by DNA *Most are for crimes that were committed long ago before the DNA thing, and I agree people who are on DR that the state knows there is holes in there case they should let them sit (like they do most anyway) but for people who it was cut and dry guilty they should give them a few years to see if they come around and ask the Lord for forgiveness and then execute.

There is a guy who I babysat for as a teenager who set his 2 year old little girl on fire and watched her burn until she was dead because he didn't want his girlfriend to get her (they had broken up) They know he is guilty people seen him in the area and he confessed. And I swear no matter where in the world we are stationed when they come to call to take him to the execution chamber I will be outside that prison gate in Arizona cheering! I hate that he has been sitting around this long, and I am sure it will be another 10 years before they send him to meet his maker. 

CountryKitchen --- 15 years ago -

Agreed country! Have any of you heard how much it costs to keep a prisoner daily! It's a ridiculous amount! Some prisons they even get laptops and video chats, its more of a luxury...no stress, no job....even for the ones that get out, they get money! So commit a crime, go to prison and get a lol vacation, get paid to get out and get a job quicker than someone who has never done anything wrong in their life!



YES! Its very expensive, its also very expensive to execute but I say that's money better spent. And yes you are 100% right my Brother has spent a total of 18 years in the Arizona DOC and he is currently been incarcerated since 2006 and is due for parole at the end of 2014 so this has been his longest stretch of time so far, and he is the first to tell me, he LOVES the pancakes they serve in prison he said they are better than his old lady makes, and he also plays cards gets high pretty much whenever he wants, its really pathetic and just think the tax payers pay for all that.. I say prison should be PRISON and they should make it rough in there not a walk in the park. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lewis Underground