Lewis Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lewis bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Fort Lewis housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

If you buy bottled water you have to read this

who's talking here?

JessiKa yells roll tide 1
AshleyG 1
~Tanya~ 1
whitwhit 1
HisGoddess 1
Lewismomma3 2
FL GIRL 1
Tange 9
LuckyPiper 3
BrendaE 5

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Tange --- 15 years ago -

After watching the documentry TAPPED, it was quite a shock and an eye opening experience. What the bottled companies don't want you to know about what you are actually drinking.

Why is the government allowing bottled water companies to profit from us by purposing putting our health at risk.

I used to pay for crystal sprinps and mountain mist but admedaitely stopped my services with them after learning the truth.

If you have Netflix, TAPPED is right there avaliable for you to view. I think its time everyone learned the truth.



FACTS
Are You Paying 1,900 Times More for Unhealthy, Earth-Damaging Water?
If you drink bottled water, yes, you are!

Bottled water typically costs more than $1.50 per bottle, which is 1,900 times the price of tap water.

Yet, that very same bottled water that you’re paying a premium for is, in about 40 percent of cases, simply bottled tap water, which may or may not have received any additional treatment.

On top of that, most municipal tap water must actually adhere to more strict purity standards than the bottled water industry. Further, while the EPA requires large public water supplies to test for contaminants as often as several times a day, the FDA requires private bottlers to test for contaminants only once a week, once a year, or once every four years, depending on the contaminant.

An independent test performed by the Environmental Working Group revealed 38 low-level contaminants in bottled water, with each of the 10 tested brands containing an average of eight chemicals including disinfection byproducts (DBPs), caffeine, Tylenol, nitrate, industrial chemicals, arsenic, and bacteria were all detected.

So what you are paying for is often no different, or worse, than the water that comes out of your faucet.

When you factor in other elements, like the chemicals that can leach from the plastic bottle and its impact on the environment, bottled water becomes a losing proposition no matter how you look at it.

Drinking From Plastic Bottles is Not a Wise Health Move
When drinking bottled water you need to think not only about the water but also about the bottle itself. Plastic is not an inert substance as its manufacturers would like you to believe. It contains chemicals like BPA and phthalates, which mimic hormones in your body.

Even tiny concentrations can cause problems such as:

■Structural damage to your brain
■Hyperactivity, increased aggressiveness, and impaired learning
■Increased fat formation and risk of obesity
■Altered immune function
■Early puberty, stimulation of mammary gland development, disrupted reproductive cycles, and ovarian dysfunction
■Changes in gender-specific behavior, and abnormal sexual behavior
■Stimulation of prostate cancer cells
■Increased prostate size, and decreased sperm production
Anytime you drink from a plastic bottle you risk exposure, but if you leave your bottle of water in a hot car or reuse it, your exposure is magnified because heat and stress increase the amount of chemicals that leach out of the plastic. 

Tange --- 15 years ago -

The bigger bottles that hold up to five gallons are even worse. The plastic they put them in has not only BPA but benzene and sulene that relate to a whole bunch of health problems. 

LuckyPiper --- 15 years ago -

But keep in mind hte opposite side of the coin. I have watched this documentary. I save and reuse my bottles and recycle. Taking a radical stance on things like this seems entirely silly to me. I mean, it would be like me coming here and saying: "Hey Everyone! Please go watch Meet your Meat on YouTube, its there to see!" Because, well, it is...and it assumes a similar radical vantage point on the meat industry.

Or perhaps Super Size me? Are you gonna give up fast food?

Or Maxxed out? No more credit cards for you right?

By the way, those two are also available on Netflix instantly.

Just some extra info to think about :D 

Tange --- 15 years ago -

I didn't radically change my thinking by watching just one movie, I actually did a lot of research on this. And i completely see your point, most of us do stuff our faces with fast food or buy vegetables that have been bleached like carrots. But have you realized that these industries that try to tell you to buy their water because apparently its "healthier" than tapped water and its simply not true so most of us are wasting money because we are lead to believe that our tap water is unsafe mean while our municiple water is tested mutiple times on a daily basis while bottled water is not even FDA regulated.

Its just common sense at this point to make up your mind about what exactly are you paying for. I hope my reply doesn't offend you. 

FL GIRL --- 15 years ago -

I will continue to buy bottled water. 

LuckyPiper --- 15 years ago -

nope:) I'm not offended in the least, I like that people can hash out discussions here.

Also, I'm with FL Girl, I will continue to purchase bottled water. Not in mass quantities, but because it is so dangburn convenient from time to time when I haven't been home in 4-5 hours and have none left in whatever bottle i'm using that day. Be it my BPA free camelback bottle or a recycled dasani or figi bottle. 

Tange --- 15 years ago -

Tapped ISN'T the only source of information you can find on the topic. But you said you have seen the documentary and its more than 2 hours long, can you honestly tell me that it didn't spike your curiosity a little bit to find out if anything you were seeing on that television screen to be viable?

And yes bottled water totally has its convenience when you don't have easy access to water. But if you're at home and paying for big gallons of jugs to be delivered to your home. It makes you think, why am i paying for something that's not even better for me than just getting it for free from the tap no less! That's my point. 

LuckyPiper --- 15 years ago -

I never stated that the information contained within the documentary was false. I was just stating that given the current situation of the US population, myself in particular, getting rid of bottled water all together is not really an option for me, or I would venture to say, most people. Thats all. :) I'm a firm believer in filtering systems that attach to the faucet or filtering pitcherss if I'm going to play the lets be paranoid about our water game. Honestly though, I would just as soon fill up a bottle of some sort from the tap, and keep it on hand in the fridge for a nice cool drink when i need one. I typically keep at least one in the fridge, sometimes two, to be cool so I have water that is cold to drink.

The biggest part of the TAPPED documentary that struck a chord with me was the town by the bottle factory. I think when you see the information about how terrible the process is, that is does indeed force you to stop and think about what the entire process is doing to our towns and communities, to our health.

I see that your profile photo is of a child. Do you/ did you use bottled water (gallons or otherwise) for her bottles/formula? Or tap water? 

JessiKa yells roll tide --- 15 years ago -

I havent seen this documentary, doubt I will, but I think of it like this; Just about everything out in the world can kill us. If we let everything that the news or articles or scientist tell us and worry about it, we would live in a bubble, but not for long because we need food and water to survive. So unless you grow your own food, and get your water from a stream, which would still effect us because of the soil and ground from the earth (and bugs) we would all just vanish. I think we have gotten to technical with things and worry more about how to cure the real things that "kill" people like cancer. I still get my water from Crystal Springs, and I will. Just like my food in the grocery store comes in plastic, id rather drink my water from plastic. 

~Tanya~ --- 15 years ago -

It's all about taste for me. If my bottled water tastes better than filtered tap water, I'll drink bottled water. My bottles of water also do not cost over $1.00 a bottle since I buy a case of 24 for $3.99.
I also prefer the convenience of bottled water. Yes, I drink out of the tap (filtered, my pipes are old and my water tastes nasty). And yes, I fill the coffee pot, make iced tea, cook with, etc tap water, filtered or not. I was going to have our water delivered, but with my youngest being a complete pill, we'd have a mess of water on the floor, so we just continue to fill up the brita pitcher. I also fill my ice trays with that filtered water. I used to be a water snob, and grew up where our water was some of the best in the country straight out of the tap (naturally filtered ground water), and so if I went to the "city" I wouldn't even get ice in my pop because I could taste the chlorine. So, in all that, taste is the biggest factor for me. lol 

Lewismomma3 --- 15 years ago -

I haven't seen Tapped but it's actually on my Instant queue now. I already know that corporations make ridiculous profits charging for their tap water and often it is not any better than what comes out of the average home's tap for a tiny fraction of the price.

It's hard to convince people that they're literally giving their money away and getting nothing in return. Even when a company admits that they sell tap water with little to no filtration, people still buy it by the case and will actually sit in their own homes and drink someone else's tap water for 1000 x's the price of what is coming out of their sink.

For $30 bucks you can attach a filter to your sink and have something that is cleaner and better tasting than many of the bottles of water that have been sitting in plastic bottles on a store shelf for Lord knows how long.

And looking at it from a ecological point of view is even worse than the financial perspective. Those bottles will sit in a landfill for thousands of years and only a very small percentage are recycled.

I've done a little research on the privatization of water distribution (which is rapidly becoming more common) and it's actually pretty disturbing to see that soon having access to any water at all may be extremely costly.

I do think there is ONE good reason for bottled water in the home and that is emergency purposes. If something happens and power is down long enough, the water will stop running. Of course a more economical way around that is to fill up every sink and bathtub in the house before that point but...like most people I'd rather drink a bottle of water than water that has been sitting in a tub or sink for days. lol!

Wow..sorry for writing a novel. :p 

AshleyG --- 15 years ago -

We are pretty environmentally friendly anyway, but my biggest thing is the plastic. We use zero plastic for food because it is so toxic. I store food in canning jars, and my son uses stainless steel sippy cups (kleen kanteen) and snack containers. If you don't care about the environment, you should care about the toxicity. I also just saw a public announcement for organic food that was giving a general warning about cancer links to chemicals in non organic food especially produce. It sounded a lot like the public announcement on cigarettes. Remember when people thought they weren't harmful to their health? scary. I'm not a 'crunchy granola lady' :) but my family eats almost 100% organic (and my friends make fun of me lol) but its just because I have had way too many people die of cancer in my life to take a risk! I feel like at least I know I am taking that extra precaution to keep my family safe from any extra risks! :) 

HisGoddess --- 15 years ago -

I actually didn't eat fast food for almost two years when I first saw supersize me. Not because of the radicals views, but I just didn't feel like eating it.

Wasn't exactly a conscious decision, it's just one of those things... like I can't eat blueberry yogurt because the texture reminds me of snot with huge boogers in it... I can eat any other kind of yogurt though...lol. 

BrendaE --- 15 years ago -

It's easy to check where bottled water comes from if you just read the label it is required, so if it says "bottled at Seattle municipal water source" then um yeah why pay? However, I buy Spring water bottled in Oregon that comes directly from underground, bottled right there at the source. I buy in bulk so it is like .15 Cents a bottle, I have a large five gallon water cooler(and the whole thing costs .75 to fill up), well it is Easy to buy BPA free large cooler containers. I prefer to NOT drink fluoride, and the other crap in tap water. Seattle tap water has PROZAC and B.C pills in from people peeing it out lmao!! ( that's from EWG as well)Not a black and white issue. I drank from a well growing up, and there was probably bacteria in it and all sorts of minerals etc. Just to say there is "bacteria" in the water in such general terms is a scare tactic. There are BILLIONS of parts of bacteria in your mouth already, in your nose, your ears etc.

I won't drink tap water and I wouldn't pay for bottled tap water either. Now, if I am working out and I forgot my water bottle or on the road etc, yes I will buy one. I recycle like mad, probably more than 99.9% of people on base. When we moved from the country with a well, to the city my dog wouldn't drink the tap water..he would drink barely enough and kept getting kidney stones from dehydration...I didn't know what was up till we went back home to visit and all he did was drink the whole time, well after a couple times I figured he was right!!!


I think instead of people freaking over WATER, it's WATER the most healthy thing you can drink pretty much, wheter tap or spring etc...the focus and efforts would be way better spent getting people to cut back on Soda and sugary drinks, "Hey, no bottled water!! here son, have a Pepsi instead, they won't let you buy bottle water anymore at the quickie mart!"...yeah, it's like cutting off your nose to spite your face.

Let's be smart consumers and know where ALL our products come from. Let's choose water OVER soda/juice 99% of the time, Let's recycle ALL our containers. I don't need documentaries to tell me this. It is common sense. (but I do love me some documentaries some of the green ones are just getting so doom and gloom overboard. Like do we need 90 minutes to have someone else tell us this?) 

BrendaE --- 15 years ago -

Oh, Ashley G I LOVE kleen canteens, I got a bunch at Ross Last week! 3$ bucks!!! 

Lewismomma3 --- 15 years ago -

"Hey, no bottled water!! here son, have a Pepsi instead, they won't let you buy bottle water anymore at the quickie mart!"...yeah, it's like cutting off your nose to spite your face."

That's a new one. I've never heard anyone argue that people should buy bottled soft drinks in place of bottled water? I wonder how anyone would rationalize that. They're equally wasteful IMO (and of course soda has no health benefits) but the convenience outweighs the cost for some people. Which brings me back to my point that it's extremely difficult to convince people that bottled water/drinks are at a cost that often (if not always) far exceeds it's value.

CLEAN water is healthy no matter what, that anyone would agree on. But monetary and planetary cost do matter to many people. 

Tange --- 15 years ago -

I see that your profile photo is of a child. Do you/ did you use bottled water (gallons or otherwise) for her bottles/formula? Or tap water?


Honestly, yes I did use bottled water for her formula for the first three months of her life. I had a 24 pack of arrowhead right in her room.

That was before I learned about the toxicology that were present in the plastic bottles. I never thought to question it before because like most ladies on here were saying it just seemed to taste better to me.

After becoming more informed about the whole water factor I went out and bought a brita filter for my facet instead and just boiled the water to sterilize it furthermore when I prepared my daughters formula. I know to some people that might seem a bit of an extreme measure but it was something I felt more comfortable doing.

I realize that almost everything now a days gives you cancer, having health problems is just the natural process of living in general. But why perpetuate in something you know could furthermore jeopardize your health and your children.

I resent the fact that companies like crystal springs and mountain mist go out there with their sells reps and lie through their teeth or maybe not knowingly do to people about the water content. Saying "oh tap water isn't safe" and try to convince you to pay for an alternative under false pretenses. 

Tange --- 15 years ago -

I'm not in anyway saying you should stop drinking bottled water but I feel that an awareness factor should be put out there. 

BrendaE --- 15 years ago -

Meaning, that when cities outlaw bottled water from being sold in stores consumers are left with poorer, less healthy options, like a Dad, and his kid on a road trip, sorry water no longer allowed. There aren't many other good alternatives at say, a Quick Stop.

I was always told from the get go to boil tap water for formula from wic...Did you know that most formula cans are lined with BPA?

Recently it was suggested to NOT use tap water at all for formula because the high levels of fluoride is starting to give children tooth damage and that purified nursery water is best. It is one of those things, unless it comes from nature or your own boob, there is most definitely going to be some environmental/health draw back. I am not sure what the stance is now on mixing formula...it is one of those back and forth type things. There are lots of bpa free alternatives now and they are much cheaper then when they first came out. I feel that it is 100% my own responsibility to vet and and research the products that I buy and come into my own home...I was in sales for years...so I don't take the word of anyone peddling ANYTHING without doing my own homework. 

whitwhit --- 15 years ago -

Hey it's great to be informed :) so i'm all for this topic. But I will say that I have seen the report on the water that is coming through my tap on post, and the bottled water I pay for every month and trust me I will take my chances with the bottled water lol. Not to mention the water on post where I live taste like complete crap. It's got so much chlorine in it to kill all the junk in it that all you taste in chlorine. I can't even stand brushing my teeth with it. 

BrendaE --- 15 years ago -

Smells like I am at the swimming pool when I fill the bathtub, yuck. I miss well water, I am used to minerally tasting water. 

Tange --- 15 years ago -

BrendaE you were smart enough to make informed decisions based on your own incentive to go out there and know exactly what you're getting. However, me and maybe most people don't have an idea to question things. I didn't expect there to ever be a health issue with bottled water. I grew up in a house that had five gallon jugs on top of a cooler stationed in the corner of our kitchen. I should have definitely been smarter about what I was mixing my daughters formula with but that was my own fault for not informing myself.
I didn't have wic tell me to boil anything, I think maybe because I originally wanted to breast feed but had complications and only settled for formula because it was the only option. I hated it, I really did. Because I knew and felt it wasn't the best for my baby. But that's a whole different story.

If you don't have an easy access to a drinkable water source, like during a drought or who knows even a worse situation, that is an excellent reason to keep bottled water around but other than that it serves no other purpose. 

Tange --- 15 years ago -

Brita does make a huge difference in the taste factor! LOL 

Tange --- 15 years ago -

I gotta stop saying factor ... 

BrendaE --- 15 years ago -

It does help, if it would remove fluoride too I would be good with it, in Spanaway we just had a brita, because they don't fluoridate the water there. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lewis Underground