Lewis Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lewis bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Fort Lewis housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

He wants out & I don't

who's talking here?

Bunny 6
brittney 1
ShamWow 1
Angelk9 1
Merktdawg072 2
Megan LeeAnne 2
Pepper Potts 18
MASC 3
wootage 3
Leesah 2
Waterbuggy 1
details 1
lemondrop 1
myopinion 2
CHHL 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Pepper Potts --- 14 years ago -

I talked to my hubby earlier today (he's in Afg.) He said something that has me more freaked out than the break-in attempt this weekend. He doesn't want to renew his contract which will be up shortly after he returns. The military has been the greatest thing for our marriage. It is a sense of stability that we did not have for the our first six very rocky, very growth inducing years. Also, our daughter has health needs & tricare has been a lifesaver in taking care of her. My hubby has been working on his degree, s-l-o-w-l-y, but it will not be finished before we are out. He is 11B, infantry, and his job beats him the heck up. He has had multiple foot surgeries and needs a knee surgery but will not accept modified pt because he thinks it will trash any chance of promotion. I understand his job is dangerous and wearing him down, but I think this is exactly the wrong time, wrong economy, to give up a solid thing for the unknown. Especially without a degree secured. I have one, but was hoping to use it as an extra savings generator when I do go work. I always pictured me working part-time & pursuing my masters at the same time. Anyhow, I am trying to support him but I definitely don't agree. Thoughts? 

Merktdawg072 --- 14 years ago -

I think everyone goes through this when they are gone. My hubs always does and when he is back he realizes how good he is at his job and how much he loves the army. Being away from home, your friends and family, always make them rethink their choice of continuing with the army. Tell him will you support him but will not make any decisions while he is deployed. Have conversations but make sure he knows where you stand too. The both of you have to come to a decision together. It's a big one that will effect everyone in the house. 

CHHL --- 14 years ago -

I have to agree with you in not getting out at this moment. Too many unknowns and the economy is horrible with a very slow recovery.

What you need to do it set him down and then list each benefit he gets and then figure out how much he will need to make on the outside to cover all those expenses.

So add up all of his CURRENT bennies:

Base pay

BAS

BAH

Yearly Clothing allowance

Tricare Healthcare ( dependent on family size anywhere from 500-1,000 a month)

United Concordia Dental

Cost of Life (500,000) insurance for him

Cost of life insurance for you.

Cost for your children as well.

It will end up adding up to a lot more than what one thinks.

I'm sure I missed some things...

Good luck to you both. 

ShamWow --- 14 years ago -

I agree with you. I just got laid off because my boss went out of business, luckily she gave me advance notice and I was able to network with a bunch of people I have worked with over the last 13 years and just got a new job lined up. The market is TOUGH right now.

I suggest wait until he gets back, sit him down and talk to him. Go over his LES and all his pay and entitlements, cost of insurance and such, then compare it to what kinds of jobs he might be able to find and consider all the details of what life will be like without that degree in this economy. You will be lucky to make it. My husband complains about the army all the time, but he's going to stay in to retirement because he has listened to me over the years about how good he has it with his pay and benefits and seen what little benefits I get working and what medical would cost us if through my job. I think your husband needs a reality check to help him see that for now, he's better off to stay put. 

Pepper Potts --- 14 years ago -

Merkt, you know Mr. Stubborness. He is beyond unreasonable when he gets something in his head. Already, I can see the flares of indifference when I bring up the cons. I hope he will see reason, but I don't want the fight to get ugly & I don't want to downplay what he goes through. It is rough to be an enlisted grunt. It is a sacrifice that I am thankful for every day & I just want to keep our current status quo. Don't get me wrong, getting out is definitely better for some families, but I love the army, even amidst this horrendous deployment. I think I will do what CHHL & Shamwow suggested...detailing our current benefits & what those would cost in the outside world. Still, I get his point. He had a seriously rough relationship with his dad who was deployed for six years of his childhood, & doesn't want to be that absent dad. He also pulls the "I could die & you would be raising our 4 alone" card out alot. I hate that. Royally unfair to bring up. He stepped on an ied this past week & it did not go off. I am sure that is part of this, but am afraid it may have been the last straw for him. 

details --- 14 years ago -

I wouldn't stress. If I had a dollar for every time both my ex and my hubby declared they wanted out I'd be rich. And they are both still in lol...I think they all go through it. 

Pepper Potts --- 14 years ago -

I hope so, details. He has always ranted about ditching the bs of the army following bad days at the unit, but he's never plotted on it & I'm hoping this passes. This is the 1st time I've taken it seriously. 

wootage --- 14 years ago -

If he's really thinking of getting out, do this calculator first to see how much he needs to make a year to get close to equaling what he makes now, plus benefits.
http://calculator.gijobs.com/ 

Pepper Potts --- 14 years ago -

Oooh, thanks wootage! 

wootage --- 14 years ago -

No problem. I know when we did it, I was like "uhhhhh....wow!" We'd need to make A LOT to equal what we make now LOL 

Pepper Potts --- 14 years ago -

Dang. $78,329.04. Yeah, not happening without his degree. 

Pepper Potts --- 14 years ago -

Not counting special pays such as hostile fire, etc. for deployments. Those extra benefits are worth alot. 

myopinion --- 14 years ago -

Look,
I love my hubby but I don't love being around him 24/7.
No sir. The military is wonderful at allowing us the space and time apart we need.
OMG I couldn't imagine living with someone daily weekly monthly yearly ....like most civilian jobs. I'm a true believer after 10 years of marriage that it can stay fresh if your not cornered by each other. So that's my argument to him the 2 times he considered not signing on again. I said .. ..where else are you going to find employment that offers you built in space? Trust me....hotels add up...And I NEED MY SPACE. 

MASC --- 14 years ago -

you know, im going to go against the grain and say you need to support his decision to get out. not to be harsh but if you want the army benefits you could enlist and let his tired body have a rest. infantry is definitely not an office job!

this guy is out there nearly dying every day. and yeah, he got lucky that the ied didnt go off. my husband was only in for a year when he got sent off and could have died in an ied blast... that is why we are here. he is alive but it messed him up mentally.

there are other jobs that allow you time apart and benefits and pay better than the military. these jobs do not own you as a person, no contract to sign.

i support my husband no matter what as long as he is trying, and he is good enough to let me be a SAHM. we have rough times and have been through the unemployment & poverty bs most of our time together. so what? we dont need THINGS to be happy. my husbands life and daughter being able to grow up with daddy are priceless. 

Pepper Potts --- 14 years ago -

LOL MO! Well said. I am stealing that phrase "employment that offers you built in space" :) 

MASC --- 14 years ago -

myopinion...

i understand every relationship is different, but i also disagree with you. one of my stipulations for hubby's job that he stays with forever (hopefully the next one) is that he is home every night to kiss our daughter before she goes to bed. not many of his jobs have allowed that yet, but i am still crossing my fingers.

my parents worked for the same company for many years and theyve been married more than 40 years.

my sister and her husband both work at home with their own business, their relationship is stronger than ever.

time apart doesnt have to be job related. girls weekends, fishing trips with the guys... i think those make for a happier spouse when youre actually having fun while having alone time. 

Pepper Potts --- 14 years ago -

I like a little space. The two most solid relationships that I witnessed growing up were that of my grandparents and my aunt & uncle, and both were military until retirement and survived many separations. My parents drive eachother batty when they are in the same space too long. I def do not want their relationship, as sad as it is to say. I love the small breaks we get in the military. Hate the long deployments!!! The short stints away are just enough time to re-center and turn some attention inward. When he is here, he is my focus. It is nice to think independently for a bit, though you are right...the best time apart is the fun breaks. 

myopinion --- 14 years ago -

MACS.
You are wise. Every relationship is different.
Such an amazing statement.
10 years of faithful marriage. 10 years of growth. We are content and secure. We are also convinced NO ONE else in this HUGE world holds another soul that could love or tolerate us the way we do for each other.
The way we work is complex ..but we love it.
We are complex.
Our children understand.... love and example will always be available to them.
Maybe not bed time kisses all the time.
Our children know this world is broken and it is our duty as humanity to help fix it up using our special gift we were all given.
My hubby uses his. Humility and sacrificial service. As a chaplain Assistant he honors the brave men and women of the Army by honoring the buffet of different religious beliefs. That every soldier be budist, Christian, Muslim or Jewish knows his religious rights and is offered a place of worship.
With that ,one of the BIGGEST bonuses we love about this career ...
THE SPACE!! 

Merktdawg072 --- 14 years ago -

Mo...you literally took the words from my lips. Well said and neither my hubs or myself couldn't agree more!! 

Megan LeeAnne --- 14 years ago -

I understand where you are coming from and thoughts on it but I also understand his point. I would never talk my husband out of getting out if he truely wanted to. He is the one putting his life in danger to stay in. I guess I'm the one who worries. There's always a what if...in theback of my head. Like, what if I talked my husband into staying in and his next deployment he got seriously injured. In mmy opinion I would leave that up to the one doing the job. There's always lots of jobs he could get once out and they would help find one. There are plenty of people who would love to hire someone with previous military experience. I know its not what you would really want to hear but please don't take this the wrong way. This is after all my thought on it. Just wait it out and see if he still thinks the same way once back. My husband was thinking the same thing but ended up extending his contract just to be able to deploy again. 

Pepper Potts --- 14 years ago -

Megan, I get you. And I wouldn't get mad even if you were offensive, lol. I guess that is my dilemma. I understand him wanting out. And I will feel guilty if he stays in a job he dislikes, that beats his body up, potentially life-threatening, if he really wants out & only does it to support us. Then again, I think his going in the military has been a huge growing experience for him personally & he's just so cut out to be a soldier. He is great at his job & has advanced regularly in his 6 years in. I fear the change. The military represents a separation from painful aspects of our fight to be together. I don't want to be on the outside just yet & while I have practical reasons, some are incredibly personal knee-jerk reactions against going back to what we came out of. 

Pepper Potts --- 14 years ago -

I just re-read & to be clear, you weren't at all offensive, but even if you said something totally crazy to me, I would take things with a grain of salt :) 

wootage --- 14 years ago -

Can he use his reenlistment to change his MOS to something that isn't so hard on his body?
DH got out of the Marine Corps Infantry back in 2005 because it was so hard on his body and he just couldn't take it. We did a year in the civilian world and he decided to join the Army in a different MOS. That year as a civilian was really hard financially. I don't need stuff, I need my husband, but I actually see my husband more now, even with deployments, than I did in that year because he was working such horrible hours to pay the bills and I had to work when he was home. I'm so thankful for the opportunity that the military has given us and am really glad my husband decided to get back in. 

MASC --- 14 years ago -

have you guys looked into active guard? i dont know much about it but my husbands brother went straight from army to that after deciding not to extend his contract. 

Pepper Potts --- 14 years ago -

I hope, wootage. I want to avoid those rough times. The dude is an all-star at anything physical & definitely not so much in academia. He is dyslexic and has severe test anxiety. He freezes even when he knows stuff. It is a wonder he made it past the board, lol. I think he will definitely need to retest and raise his gt scores to open up more options. And it's not that he can't do it, but he is so hard on himself and rarely puts himself out there in his historically weak areas. I am his editor for his college assignments, etc. I hope he'll show some initiative and study hard. He has shown interest in some warrant opportunities in the past & I hope he'll just go for it. It is super frustrating to watch his personal capabilities be stifled by testing hang-ups.

And MASC, that's a thought, but I am still hoping we will not be in a position to have to check that out! 

lemondrop --- 14 years ago -

I was thinking the same as Wootage, can he re-enlist for a different MOS?
My husband did when we found out we were going to have a baby. It has saved him from deploying and he really loves his new job.
Just be really open to hearing his reasons. Encourage him to talk to you and to keep exploring his options.
I am a very stubborn person, and sometimes having someone tell me no just makes me want it more. If you give me a reason why I have a bad idea I'll just fight to find a way to fix it. If he is like me-he will come to reason on his own. Maybe he just needs to daydream a bit? 

Bunny --- 14 years ago -

[i]So add up all of his CURRENT bennies:

Base pay

BAS

BAH

Yearly Clothing allowance

Tricare Healthcare ( dependent on family size anywhere from 500-1,000 a month)

United Concordia Dental

Cost of Life (500,000) insurance for him

Cost of life insurance for you.

Cost for your children as well.

It will end up adding up to a lot more than what one thinks.

I'm sure I missed some things...


I always tell people the same thing! 

Leesah --- 14 years ago -

I would definitely tell him to wait until he's back home to talk about it. But I would support him in any decision that he makes. He is your husband and he is entitled to do what makes him happy. You never know, it could very well work out. You could also find a career and that will give you guys the space you need. My husband is getting out next year and I'm okay with that. It may be rough for a little while, but I'm perfectly capable of working and plan to so that our family will be on the right track. If he decides to stay in, then awesome, if not, it isn't the end of the world. Just remember, there are millions of non military married couples doing just fine. And you should have a little more faith in your man. Almost dying probably opened his eyes, and the Army life might just not be worth it for him anymore. 

Bunny --- 14 years ago -

nd you should have a little more faith in your man. Almost dying probably opened his eyes, and the Army life might just not be worth it for him anymore. 

agree 

Pepper Potts --- 14 years ago -

Trust me girl, I am his staunchest supporter & have stuck with him through far worse. I was the pregnant chick waking up in a car next to him behind bed bath & beyond where I was invent. control manager, sneaking in as soon as the doors were open to brush my teeth & hair before work. It took awhile for my family to come around to my marrying him & we have had many rock bottom hard times. For reasons listed above, the army has been a great fit & huge blessing for us. I will support him come what may, but my family has specific needs that are best met by the security of the military right now. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

men

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lewis Underground