Lewis Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lewis bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Fort Lewis housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

First grade level?

who's talking here?

goddessanne 1
Kristin 1
MASC 2
lemondrop 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

MASC --- 13 years ago -

I did kindergarten at home with my daughter last year in hopes she could skip it this year. You don't get help with kindergarten or a transcript though, so when I went to register her they went by her age. She turns 6 shortly after school starts, but they didn't care or do any kind of testing like I asked to see where she should be placed.

Well, now she is more advanced than classmates. First grade level work is being sent home and she is pulled out to do advanced reading group. This kinda makes me mad because if they had listened she would be able to be in first grade and working at her level at school. (I told them she needed to be in public school because she wont work for me, they also didn't listen about that.) It kinda makes me mad because I want her to keep moving forward, not being stagnant waiting for others to catch up.

So, to get to the point...
I'm wondering where she would need to be at the end of first grade? We are moving and I want to get her into a magnet school next year. Since I am working with her at home anyway, maybe I can get her back on track to where she was headed and have her test into second grade. 

goddessanne --- 13 years ago -

I don't have an answer for you, but I just wanted to comment on your post. I'm Asian and the early years of my schooling was in Asia and we based our grade level by our intellectual level. We really do "flunk" if we ,ake poor grades. Being a non experienced teacher in the U.S. I was surprised when I learned during my internship that in the U.S. they have what you call "social" promotion. Basically, if you're in a public school, your grade level is based off of your age... ready or not, advanced or not, etc. your age pretty much determines your grade level. Private schools may be different... 

lemondrop --- 13 years ago -

Last year in my son's kindergarten class there was an advanced child who also got pulled for 1st grade reading. But after Christmas break they moved him into a 1st grade class.
SO moving her mid-year is possible. Make a stink about it, that is the ONLY way anything happens.
I know that is not what you asked, but it is what I would do. Why wait?
Also it might be nice to see how she is maturity wise? It might not be a good fit and it would suck to have to hold her back at her new school if it didn't work.
My son is one of the smartest in his class, but one of the most immature-so I'd never push him up a level! In his defense, he is also the youngest, he barely made the cut-off date. 

Kristin --- 13 years ago -

That's really interesting goddessanne-I kind think that's how schools should be run, basing it on age really means nothing. Schooling should be about learning the basics really well, progressing based on that, and going back and relearning when needed.

I would ask MASC-its probably more disruptive for her to be pulled out to do the 1st grade work than it would be to just move her into the grade.

I am totally not impressed with the public schools near/on base which is why I homeschool. But homeschooling is hard too! I think I will be trekking back out the Yelm next fall to take the kiddos back to Eagle View Christian-great school:) 

MASC --- 13 years ago -

thanks for the info! i wish they didnt go by age here.
it would be nice if she could do first grade now, but i dont want to pull her out in the middle of the year. i think it would be more disruptive than anything, and they would be working on totally different things than she is. she has established her friendships, gotten into the routine and we love her teacher. plus, she is only in half-day kindergarten right now so that would be another big change for her all at once.

we dont live near ft lewis anymore, but i wouldnt have her in public school there if we did. our original plan was to do homeschooling but she needs to get out and be with kids her own age and doesnt like to sit down at home to work for me.
either way there will be negatives but hopefully i can get her into a school that will work at her level next year. i am trying to do fun things at home to keep her learning. right now we are working on spanish with muzzy and bill nye videos for science related things as well as informational books from the library.

maturity wise, she adapts. she grew up around adults and older kids so she can be more mature. she has always spoken very clearly and has a great vocabulary. but, she loves people and will be friends with anyone so she will adjust and play with kids her age or younger just fine too. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lewis Underground