Lewis Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lewis bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Fort Lewis housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Should I have my mother come live with us?

who's talking here?

wildflower2007 2
ShamWow 1
NadaSuperstar 1
a3548417uu 4
Leesah 1
lemondrop 1
myopinion 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

a3548417uu --- 14 years ago -

Long story short, my single mother is in a bad space financially. She'll never come out and ask for money but when I talk to her, we talk about what's going on with her and I just feel horrible that she is going through that. I have a teenage brother who came to visit last summer and the discipline my husband and I placed in him was much needed. My mom is older and disabled so the way she raised me isn't the way she's raising my younger brother. I have an older brother who lives closer to them (they're in Virginia) who has thrown them by the wayside and spends most of his free time with his girlfriend's family. I know that my little brother needs a strong male presence in his life and I know my husband could be that. We have talked about it before but never really acted on it. Summer is coming up and this would be the perfect moving time, as it would be a move in the middle of the school year.

Not only would my mother benefit but we are considering having another child and my mother would love to be the care provider. We have a 2 year old that would continue to attend daycare. Also, being that my mother is disabled and is physically unable to work and we provide financial support for her, he would be able to claim her as a dependent (in doing so, she would have post access to fully carry out duties as a care provider since we do live on post). Should I just leave my current situation the way it is or help my family? I don't want to put a strain on my marriage, as my husband and I have our way of doing things now since it's just us in our home.

Thanks in advance! 

ShamWow --- 14 years ago -

That is a decision that you need to make with your husband for sure. My mom and I have a very hard time living together so I don't think we'd ever live together again but other people have better relationships with their moms. We had similar issues with my husbands dad and his brothers never helped out and since we both work everyone is like you guys have lots of money you should always be the one to help, when in reality.. we aren't rich um hello. His dad could never live here because he likes to drink and smoke wherever he feels like it. The family got him situated back east near family where he can still be independent but afford to live on his own.

If you live in housing on post make sure you get them approved before having them come live with you because you could loose your housing having them live with you without getting approval first. 

a3548417uu --- 14 years ago -

If she came, we'd have to move off post because we'd need at least a 4 bedroom house. I've talked to my husband and he says he's fine with it but I don't want to be the one to make that call and he regret that decision. I haven't lived at home since 2007 but my mother was actually supposed to move with us when we PCS'd out here to be my son's caregiver. Luckily my mother doesn't have any habits that would disrespect my home (as we have similar beliefs) but I'm more concerned that my husband is telling what he THINKS i want to hear instead of his true feelings. You're right, I need to make that decision with him but I don't want him to feel backed in a corner. 

wildflower2007 --- 14 years ago -

if you were to move them up here, housing would actually upgrade you to a larger home once your deers reflected new dependents were listed, so you might not have the expense (and trust me, it's EXPENSIVE) of moving and living off post. that is a decision you should make as a couple, over a length of time. talk about how you feel now and then in a week or two, check back in with each other on your emotions and thoughts on the subject. you'll make the right call thats best for your family :) 

a3548417uu --- 14 years ago -

Oh wow, you learn something new everyday! i figured they wouldn't allow my husband to claim my younger brother as a dependent unless he had to file the paperwork to become his legal guardian. we've talked about it before but never had to follow up on it. his dad had considered moving out here as well but changed his mind at the last minute...bummer.....i want this to make a joint decision but i sometimes feel like i force him to make decisions on my behalf. his parents is more independent than my mother so i don't feel like its fair to him. but i know when you marry someone you marry into their "mess" per se. 

NadaSuperstar --- 14 years ago -

Moving off post will cost about $3-4 k just for rent and deposits. Plus moving truck, gas, etc. Not to mention extra furniture you would need to buy for them. I would make the decision with your husband. If you decide it is best to have your family move here I would wait on having a baby right away until you know the arrangement will work. Also to know your budget with the responsibility of 2 more people to feed, clothe, insure, etc. 

a3548417uu --- 14 years ago -

Seems like the best option, if we considered such, would be to get the legalities out the way before they moved because it would be stressful. My mother has steady income so she wouldn't just be freeloading. She'd actually help ease the burden in the budget in that area, i'm just concerned about the personal feelings about it. 

Leesah --- 14 years ago -

Just tell him what you're thinking. Sounds like you're stressing yourself out over this instead of just telling him "Hey, I just want to make sure this isn't going to be a decision you will regret, can we talk about it?" 

wildflower2007 --- 14 years ago -

@A, definitely talk to housing about it. I know a family getting into a larger home, her terminally ill mother was coming to live with them and since she was considered a dependent and listed on deers, they were able to upgrade to a larger home to accomodate their now larger family. Housing could give you more information about it though, I don't know the specific requirements since i've not been in that situation ourselves. but moving off post is quite expensive and then you'd have to refigure the budget with added costs of fuel for your husband getting to work, etc. 

lemondrop --- 14 years ago -

Well, I ONLY read your post, not anyone elses ideas....
but here's what I think:
YES. My mom was in a similar situation and wanted to move to the city my sister lived in. She wanted to move in first with my sister until she was on her feet. My sister didn't want to have the added stress and said no. she should find a place first. Less then 6 months later (before she was able to move on her own) my mom had a sudden heart attack and died. My sister still has not forgiven herself. My mom wasn't ill, but she was a smoker and struggled with thyroid issues. She was 47.
My lesson learned was this-do whatever you can for family. I always ask myself, If they were hit by a bus would I have regretted not helping?
If your husband ends up having issues, then you guys can address it then. If he says it's ok now, go with it. There is always room to undo the move. But you don't get to go back into time, you know? 

myopinion --- 14 years ago -

It could be a EPIC WIN or EPIC FAILURE. Such a hard call. You know yourself best though. Can you rough it when the going gets tough. Cause Lord knows, family God love, them are difficult. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
marriage
parenting

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lewis Underground