Lewis Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lewis bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Fort Lewis housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: Is the Army, Federal Government Doing Enough To Help Soldiers With Mental Health Problems?

who's talking here?

ShamWow 1
Katena 2
Maui Girl 1
Justmeandthefamilia 1
NadaSuperstar 1
Brenda E 6
myopinion 6
Pandaroni 6
4MyFYI 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Pandaroni --- 14 years ago -

Lakewood Patch Poll  

Katena --- 14 years ago -

No I do not I have seen too many friends that were a different person when they left and a total 180 when they come back. Some people in general are too stubborn too get help and with the army mentality afraid it may hurt their career. 

Brenda E --- 14 years ago -

I just have to say at this point, I am SOO SICK and tired of the media and civilians overreacting to this and blaming PTSD, the ARMY, soldiers in General and JBLM for this AS IF this NEVER happens on THEIR side of the fence!!!!more Average joes, and school KIDS have shot up more people, and more places, then soldiers, despite having ptsd or having been in combat, so I can't help but wish the microscope would come off.

from work place shootings, to VA tech..... More of THEM have massacred innocent people-SEVERAL times. My point being that the microscope on the soldiers who, despite being put through hell STILL commit acts like these LESS then the rest of the civilians do at home-when they psychologically, would be expected to not do something so extreme vs a soldier who has been through hell-yet still it's more likely to happen at home, by a student, a child, or a co worker- but that is somehow ignored, and soldiers are made out to be "killers" brainwashed by war, when just a few weeks ago, we had a boy shoot and kill four students-but somehow, that is less shocking? I feel like the war itself, is an entirely separate issue.....I myself, can't understand why we are still fighting in that hell hole-but that aside...I would like to see American civilians look more inward, before they are ready to try and distance themselves and act like this is some shocking atrocity that is unheard of in the US or by American society and that the military culture is barbaric and sick! take a look around people! you are more likely to be blown away by some "average joe" who snapped at a mall! Then a war torn veteran!!!!!...we have this happen at HOME three or four times a year by people who have at worst-stressful every day lives..yet after a decade in two wars, with soldiers who see god knows what this has only happened a few isolated times! And from people AT WAR, with WEAPONS, fighting every day! Yet here in the STATES, people who just can't take losing their home, or their divorce, or being made fun of are KILLING in double digits way more often. I just wish the media would take a look around here as well. Look at home and be just as appalled-if not MORE....it's really starting to get on my nerves-hearing all this anti soldier b.s on FB etc. 

Brenda E --- 14 years ago -

Just sayin, their side of the fence has ten times as many sh!t piles as ours does...they just prefer to ignore it. 

myopinion --- 14 years ago -

The whole world is going to hell in a hand basket. 

Pandaroni --- 14 years ago -

Brenda, I swear you read my mind. I just think it is so much more hyped up if it involves the military. WAY more civilians do things like this. But people are quick to judge this base or our soldiers and label them all PTSD. I just think many are looking for a logical reason maybe that someone...anyone could do such acts????? 

Pandaroni --- 14 years ago -

The whole world is going to hell in a hand basket.

If things keep going at this rate all over the world, we will be there soon, or hell could seem like a vacation. 

myopinion --- 14 years ago -

SO FUNNY! !!
HELL.....the vacation spot. We will buying time shares. 

NadaSuperstar --- 14 years ago -

At least hell is always warm!!! And not rainy. 

Pandaroni --- 14 years ago -

I do however realize that there are many soldiers who do suffer from PTSD and did not , or are not recieving proper care. That does not mean we should lessen the importance of their particular situations. I am aware that over 285 cases were switched at Madigan and they are under investigation. But the percentage of soldiers who have suffered from PTSD, and those who have been suspected of possibly having PTSD and who have committed some type of hideous crime, or popped off and went postal are far different. PTSD is serious, and should be handled immediately and appropriately. The poor guy that was over the Madigan programs for this killed himself under the scrutiny and pressure once the investigations got in deep. Kind of ironic. But I am sure the Army is taking a serious look at what went wrong, who did what and handling it to the best of their ability. No one wants to allow people to just fade into the background or minimize the severity of PTSD, but also no one should think every time a soldier loses it, it was PTSD. i hope all of this can be resolved accordingly and new regulations and systems of dealing with these soldiers can be adapted and put in place to protect our soldiers and families and give them the treatment they deserve in all cases, no matter how minimal or sever it is. 

myopinion --- 14 years ago -

 

myopinion --- 14 years ago -

Pandaroni

This seems like such a hopeless discussion. Kudos for your ability to keep it in the light. Really. 

Pandaroni --- 14 years ago -

No I do not I have seen too many friends that were a different person when they left and a total 180 when they come back. Some people in general are too stubborn too get help and with the army mentality afraid it may hurt their career.

Katena, I can agree that people are different when they come back, and that they are stubborn in to seeking treatment. That needs to change as well. When you have sorry COC's or fellow soldiers that harass you or call them sissies, this makes one not want to go forth with treatment. It happens a lot. I used to date a great guy who serve a total of 30 years in the military. Once in Afghanistan a building was blown up while he and his soldiers were in it. Concrete beams fell right on his head, giving him a severe brain injury. He recovered from that, 2 deployments later, his Hum-V hit an IED, he suffered yet another head injury and shrapnel into his eye, and side of his head, along with burns to his left side of his body and face. He recovered. but he really didn't back then when I knew him very well, he would wake in sweats, jump, restlessness while he was sleeping, and even have to walk away sometimes to calm down from whatever it was that was bothering him. A very quiet, funny, very intelligent man, but he never sought treatment for PTSD, even though many knew he had it. He was afraid of what others would say, as well as afraid of losing his career he had built his whole life.

No one that sees combat first hand will ever be the same, even though we may feel they are the same man or woman when they come home. it takes it's tool and they will carry it with them for the rest of their lives. I can't express my gratitude for anyone who serves in the military and has to endure this type of action and keep this in their minds, only to go back home to their families and friends and be "normal". 

Katena --- 14 years ago -

@ all you ladies great points. The world has issues and refused to look at their troubles. @Pandaroni I agree guys are being called names and COs are no help. I am tried of hearing about it. I am glad that I live on Mcchord and really don't have to deal with it. 

ShamWow --- 14 years ago -

No they never have and never will, i know vets of many generations that are so messed up thanks to the army and the army hasnt done much to help them, past or present. 

Brenda E --- 14 years ago -

Did anyone read the TNT article this Sunday??? they actually crunched the numbers for JBLM being "the most troubled base".....as it turns out, we have less crime, then most other bases, our crime went up a little BUT we added a over a thousand soldiers, we had 12 suicides, more than last years NINE, but fort hood had 22 last year...

So are we troubled? -----NO----this is one of the safest bases, we just have the latest "high profile" crimes....


And as for deployment stress causing these, it wasn't a factor in many of them...the guy that killed the Forest cop-never saw combat and did one tour--basically he was kicked out because he was a bad guy-so this most likely was just the path he was on. Many of the domestic violence ones had been attributed to marital and deployment stress/PTSD(which is a lethal combo in some cases if you ask me)

Some of the "kill team" where on their first deployment, they were most likely sort of brainwashed by the leader of the ring who is a total sociopath and also very troubled,--it's was like the Manson's of the Army


This guy, was tested for PTSD--before many times...didn't have it...Got tested this week, STILL doesn't have it! He says he doesn't have it...Sounds like he caved under alcohol and pressure from being on the brink of loosing it all financially..and being just -done-with it all. I wish they would quit acting like three (yes I say THREE cause dude just got there in DEC, so he is what, three months in?) is "HIGH" deployment..for someone who has been in 11 years??? I know many people on a fifth deployment..Mines, been to Iraq four times, (and Korea twice) out of 11 years, luckily two were under a year...but really, when you enlist, then re-enlist in the middle of two wars..you are consenting to this rotation..oy vey, anyways...I was thankful for TNT writing a SENSIBLE article that included BOTH sides of the story...it did note that JBLM has thee MOST mental health staff members too but was still having an issue with diagnosis, and the scandal of some being over turned. Many were over turned because the stories of combat, could not be corroborate, or were found to be flat out.lies.....I really think we are paying the price for lowering the enlistment standards...


I also think there is a chance this mans TBI may have impeded his judgment, but that would be for a Dr. to decide I guess...for his sake, I hope that was the cause.


PTSD is very really and people who use it as a false defense hurt all the others who really need the help... 

Maui Girl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

"No they never have and never will, i know vets of many generations that are so messed up thanks to the army and the army hasnt done much to help them, past or present. "

Idk...my dad was from the Vietnam era, and the Army took GREAT care of him throughout his life. He was diagnosed with PTSD and labeled 100% mentally disabled in the 90's, and I have no doubt in my mind that that was a proper diagnosis. I just think unfortunately, too many soldiers fall through the cracks or dont bother to seek treatment. The Army offers veterans SOOOOO many benefits, but not all of them are aware of whats available. My dad was a retired, stay-at-home dad. He ha nothing better to do than to hound VA office and find out about all the new benefits coming out. Once, he got $25,000 to use towards a "hobby", because the Army was handing out money to PTSD diagnosed retirees to keep them from committing suicide. Dad got a ridiculous amount of musical instruments in the house, on top of a new Mac desktop. It was insane. I have no idea if this benefit's still around, but what I'm saying is that research will serve you richly! My dad was well out of the Army by the 90s, though, so he had nothing to lose by being diagnosed, whereas being active and diagnosed with PTSD many times leaves soldiers being viewed as weak or unreliable as a soldier which is a real shame. Instead of being treated when they think they have a problem, they're told to "suck it up" or to bury the feelings. Human beings are only able to suppress feelings for so long before they'll crack. 

Justmeandthefamilia --- 14 years ago -

I do not believe they are doing enough for our soldiers, they do not have enough down time, not just that, sometimes and I am not saying all the time, but the units make it to where if you ask for help that makes you weak. I think should more training on how to look for all the signs. That's just my opinion. 

Brenda E --- 14 years ago -

Latest update about this guy....he stole hundreds of thousands of dollars in investment fraud...He enlisted to HIDE from prosecution, he took the entire life savings from an Elderly couple, swindled them...He is shady as he77...


So again to the people who mentioned the low standards for enlistment while the Army grew...again I say you hit the nail on the head, if you want to blame the Army, blame them for not being picky enough about who's hands they put weapons in and who's already bad minds they trained, this guy, woman beater, hit and run, thief...he is a shame to all the good people in the service and a shame to those who truly suffered mental and emotional damage. 

myopinion --- 14 years ago -

Why are some reporting his record was perfect as a soldier? Just curious where the info is coming from. 

Brenda E --- 14 years ago -

I kinda think that is his lawyer try to paint a different picture..this guy, he seems like a really scary person now! Those that only had to deal with him when he was happy or getting what he wanted seem to think he was nice, however those who had to deal with him when he wasn't happy and didn't get his way saw a very dark and scary person.


You know if you get a DUI, you can't own a firearm till you get off probation? that's years!(true for any felony)


Yet the Army hand this guy and trains him on military weapons..He should have never been allowed to enlist, as well as been kicked out shortly after....they have often discharged people for less...

The victims of his crimes in the STATES, were against women and elderly- so killing children, and women -is not so out of character for him after all. He was definitely NOT fit to serve IMO in the first place! 

myopinion --- 14 years ago -

Ya I figured it was media wind that whispered he had a spotless army record. They were still trying to figure out how they wanted to spin this ya know? 

Brenda E --- 14 years ago -

Pretty much...it's not as good of a story if it all comes down to this guys just being a bad person...it's a lot more tragic if it's a Hero gone bad story-so that's the spin they put on it.. 

4MyFYI --- 14 years ago -

I feel that with all the PTSD talk in this case that it will become the new "in" thing with soldiers trying to get out and looking to make an extra buck. With proper care there is no reason for a soldier to be able to carry out his military career. But in light of all this I am worried that if this soldier chooses this defense that they will start putting sodliers out left and right that have PTSD. PTSD is very easy to "fake" and prior to this it had a bad stigma attached to it, making it so that soldiers did not want to be labled with it at all because they where seen as damaged goods in fellow soldiers eyes. I feel the medical system in whole is not broke, my husband gets vry good care for his inuries, and his PTSD and always has. I feel that maybe the medical system is just having a hard time weeding out the fakers (no matter what the medical condition) and the soldiers who truly needs help. 

Pandaroni --- 14 years ago -

I seriously hope he fries. People like this do not deserve to be
"honored" as a military member. I honestly think they should have given him to the Afghans to do with whatever, as he did those innocent victims and for whom ever he has hurt and robbed previously. Skeletons will always find a way out of the closet. He is a disgrace to the military, his fellow soldiers and to the human race period. God be with his family and all of the victims and their families. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lewis Underground