Lewis Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lewis bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Fort Lewis housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Meal Deduction Rant

who's talking here?

Misty P. 2
Shelley 2
ShamWow 6
Kathryn 4
zigzag10 1
Yogis Mommy 4
NotACityGirl 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Yogis Mommy --- 15 years ago -

I love how the army took too much $ in meal deductions for march--- and STILL have yet to pay it back....now ....they're taking more meal deductions for this month - and my husband isn't even in the field...(his unit is, but they had him stay back)....figures....I'm so sick of this BS! 

zigzag10 --- 15 years ago -

They did that to my husband for months before i got dwn here and startwd askin questions. They said we would be reimburst (over $1000!), thst was a month or so ago, but they did say 30-45 days! Ugh! This is BS, but ill w8 a lil longer b4 i start bugging them... 

Kathryn --- 15 years ago -

When we first got here my husband stayed in the barracks for THREE nights before I got here and meal deductions were taken out for months and we are STILL owed $784 from over four years ago, we are never going to see that money again. Go straight to finance, that was my mistake. 

ShamWow --- 15 years ago -

The issue is that it's not finance on post that takes the money, its DFAS in Ohio that does all the pay and deductions, they get put in based on how the unit reports it. Finance people are the ones that fix the mess that the unit and DFAS makes. Play nice with finance troops because they can make it happen fast or take for ever if someone treats them like dirt. Pay mistakes suck! 

ShamWow --- 15 years ago -

So I just asked and got the info on how to get it corrected:

Your soldier needs to have a DA form 4187 stating that the "Soldier was not in the field from __ date to __ date. Request meal deduction cancelled and money returned to Soldier". The DA 4187 should be checked "HAS BEEN VERIFIED" and signed by your soldiers command.

Now if your soldier wants to take the form to finance himself he will also need to complete a DA form 2142 and verify with his PAC first before he goes to finance to make sure that he can take it there, most often it needs to be submitted by the unit PAC. 

Yogis Mommy --- 15 years ago -

Thank you Shamwow....I'm starting to get pissed that they take money from us even when its not owed to them...but when they owe us money - they take their sweet a** time 

Kathryn --- 15 years ago -

It took me FIVE trips to Rear D to get his meal deductions cancelled. He was still being charged down range. He was listed as a geo bachelor who lived in the barracks even though WE LIVED ON BASE TOGETHER!!!!! My husband's unit is assbackwards. 

ShamWow --- 15 years ago -

My husband is finance, shhhhhhh lol. He's used to work with main finance here on post for the longest time, he's not in a finance unit now which is a really nice change! When he gets back he won't be going back there either. It sure will be nice to have him here and in a normal unit for once. I am always asking him finance questions because so many of our friends run into issues. 

Misty P. --- 15 years ago -

What get me is my husband is in Korea and ours get taken becuase he eats at the chow hall...but next week there is an exercise that is going to close down the chow halls...ok...so where does he eat? They better give us our money for that week for him. 

Kathryn --- 15 years ago -

Yeah, BAS gets taken out when the soldier goes to Korea. I am thankful because last time my husband went on a long field problem we were told BAS would be taken but the 1sgt only brought one box of MRE's a day out there so there were many days my husband and other guys only ate one "meal" because there was not enough. I kinda think it is crap they take BAS and only feed them MRE's... I know the DFAC takes hot meals out sometimes, but my husband has never got one. He is on another 10 day field problem and is only getting MRE's. 

Shelley --- 15 years ago -

Misty do they take the full monthly amount or just when he scans his card? When mine was there, they only charged by the scan which was nice because my husband ate at his room a lot because he would cook or microwave something instead of going to the dfac. 

Kathryn --- 15 years ago -

so I didn't put in there, BAS wasn't taken that time, itbetter not be this time! 

Misty P. --- 15 years ago -

They take the full monthly amount 

Shelley --- 15 years ago -

They take the full monthly amount

well that sucks, we would have lost tons of money had they done that with my hubby considering me ate at MOST one meal a day in dfac :( 

Yogis Mommy --- 15 years ago -

Shamwow, my husband spent a total of 2 weeks in the field in April (that's all)...but on his LES they are charging him for a ton more...(They have now taken over $300 in meal deductions)....they charged him for 2 weeks in March/April - $154 the first check, $58 the next check (all for the same dates) and another $92 for August 11 - 31st... (and he wasn't even in the field, he was on Rear D) - the unit said they submitted the paperwork for the March/April mess up months ago, but finance said they didn't...husband is going to talk to S1 today, but I'm worried that nothing will be done by S1- YET AGAIN. I know damn well we were seriously overcharged for meal deductions...there is no way in hell 2 weeks of meal deductions is over $200....


Being that your husband is finance...Do you know if there is a way we can skip the unit and just go straight to finance and take care of this ourselves seeing as how they (his S1) don't know how to do their jobs? 

ShamWow --- 15 years ago -

It's the same as I posted up above, my husband said to have him talk to his PAC/S1 and if he feels that they aren't going to deal with it he needs to get the 4187 and a 2142 and take them to finance, but he needs to talk to his units PAC/S1 he should be able to get the 4187 from him/her. Finance won't be able to do anything without those forms.

"Your soldier needs to have a DA form 4187 stating that the "Soldier was not in the field from __ date to __ date. Request meal deduction cancelled and money returned to Soldier". The DA 4187 should be checked "HAS BEEN VERIFIED" and signed by your soldiers command.

Now if your soldier wants to take the form to finance himself he will also need to complete a DA form 2142 and verify with his PAC first before he goes to finance to make sure that he can take it there, most often it needs to be submitted by the unit PAC." 

Yogis Mommy --- 15 years ago -

Oh ok. I was just hoping we could cut the unit out completely. Thank you 

ShamWow --- 15 years ago -

yea they look down on that in the army, the whole proper chain of command bs. Just have your husband stop by and talk to him. Ask him if he can get the forms and take them hand deliver to the finance counter to have it worked since he's been waiting for some time for it to be corrected.

Even as a finance soldier pay gets totally jacked up and it takes time for them to, but the only good thing is in finance you can get your forms easier and get pay corrected because that's where your command is. We've had our share of problems. When my hubs was here in finance all of our neighbors loved us lol 

NotACityGirl --- 15 years ago -

My husband and I got married in January and just now got meal deductions to stop. We had to go to his S1 and get some paper saying that he turned in his meal card, which the dumb S1 put was in February and take that to finance. I had a power of attorney with that, yelled at them and got it straightened out finally. It was nice that they gave us back all of our money at once, but we still lost a month of meal deductions and BAH cause the S1 couldn't do their job. 

ShamWow --- 15 years ago -

Yea, like I keep saying, its usually not the finance unit the f's up the pay, its the soldiers unit or dfas, then post finance gets all the crap when they are the ones that will fix the soldiers pay. I have no doubt that's why my hubs is so glad to be out of the pay part of finance lol 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

rant

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lewis Underground