Lewis Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lewis bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Fort Lewis housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

What is that dern cookie recipe

who's talking here?

JessiKa yells roll tide 12
Christine A. 1
sweetjudy 1
Amy L 2
Nancy 1
Trinity 10
sidney 1
Katena 1
ella 3
Kathryn 1
lakej 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

JessiKa yells roll tide --- 16 years ago -

I got some new neighbors today. I want to make them something, but im not really up to making them a pie. I was thinkin back to the good ole days of family and their special recipes. Well my mammaw would make these cookies with special homemade frosting. I remember I really liked these cookies. Now that she has passed away, and I did get most of her recipes, I can not find her special recipe for these cookies. Bad part is, im not sure what they were. I dont think they were sugar cookies since I hate hate hate sugar cookies, but they were a simple cookie. No chocolate, nuts, or any of that stuff added. Do any of yall have an idea of what kinda cookie this may be? 

Kathryn --- 16 years ago -

snickerdoodles? 

JessiKa yells roll tide --- 16 years ago -

I dont think they were snickerdoodles. Those are kinda cinnamoney (great word, right lol) arent they? 

Trinity --- 16 years ago -

I want to say i know what kinda cookie you are talking about but don't know what they are called.lol My Grandma makes these cookies around the holidays. They are very simple like you said and have a very simple, but very sweet off white kinda color frosting. Of course she would add color to some batches for Christmas and such. 

JessiKa yells roll tide --- 16 years ago -

Yup, its those Trinity! :O) Now if we can just get that name we will be good! 

Amy L --- 16 years ago -

i know what your talking about but I cant think of the name either!! lol 

Trinity --- 16 years ago -

I think the frosting is made with evaporated milk or condensed, I always gets those confused. lol

I can call my Grandma tomorrow and ask for her recipe if you don't find it by then. 

Amy L --- 16 years ago -

wait, is it royal icing? Is that the name of it? That keeps popping in my head 

JessiKa yells roll tide --- 16 years ago -

Royal Icing looks good... 

Trinity --- 16 years ago -

I think it is royal icing. or confectioners icing. they seem to be very similar. And I guess I was way off with the condensed/evaporated milk thing. Must have seem thinking of a different recipe. haha

But all the recipes I keep seeing on the internet keep showing sugar cookies. I didn't think they were sugar cookies either. 

Christine A. --- 16 years ago -

Is it like a refridgerator or shortbread cookie? 

sweetjudy --- 16 years ago -

I want you as my neighbor Jess!!! My mom makes those also! 

sidney --- 16 years ago -

Butter cookies? My grandma used to make them with a cookie press. Loved them at christmas time. 

JessiKa yells roll tide --- 16 years ago -

I have no clue if they were Fridge or not. Butter and the short bread sound good. Trinity you gonna call grandma today? 

Trinity --- 16 years ago -

ok, i got it. I will warn you though. My Grandma is very old fashioned and is the type that doesn't really use measuring cups/spoons. She did break it down in measurements but if you end up with a kitchen full of cookies...I'm sorry. LOL

For the cookies:
preheat over to 350

1 cup shortening
4 cups flour
1 cup milk
2 eggs
1 1/2 cups sugar
2 tsp. baking soda
1/2 tsp salt
1/2 tsp. vanilla extract

cut shortening in flour until well mixed.
Then add all other ingredients (dry first, then wet ingredients)

Roll dough out to a thin layer, like 1/8 inch ( i think this is all personal preference on how thin or thick you want you cookies)
Use desired cookies cutters
bake on ungreased cookie sheet for ABOUT 10 minutes..may take shorter or longer depending on thickness.

for frosting:
2 cups powdered sugar
3 tbsp. milk
1/2 tsp. vanilla (optional)


I really hope that works for you. I am just worried it is too big a recipe, you know. That's the only way she know how to cook, is for a lot of people. So worse case, you'll have leftovers!! 

Trinity --- 16 years ago -

She said that will made about 2 dozen cookies, "or so." So, if you google sugar cookie recipes there are tons all over the internet and some have smaller batches to help with cutting back the other ingredients. 

JessiKa yells roll tide --- 16 years ago -

I will just send the extra's to you :O) The new neighbor is a stick, so she needs some calories, lol. Thanks Trinity. I will let ya know how it all comes out! 

Trinity --- 16 years ago -

Not a problem. I wanted to get this recipe for the holidays this year anyways. 

JessiKa yells roll tide --- 16 years ago -

so far the dough is super duper good! But its sticky, so im gonna let it chill in the fridge for maybe a hour or two and then roll it out. 

Trinity --- 16 years ago -

Good! I was reading on a few of the online recipes that say to chill it and flour everything you use so it won't stick, like the rolling pin, cookie cutters etc. 

JessiKa yells roll tide --- 16 years ago -

Yea, I dont have any dern cookie cutters. I wish I was feeling normal I could head on out to Michaels. They have a full box of cookie cutters. 

ella --- 16 years ago -

I miss being your neighbor 

JessiKa yells roll tide --- 16 years ago -

Sure, thats why you left. She liked them :) 

Katena --- 16 years ago -

What an awesome neignbor you are. I wish all neighbors were like this. I sometimes miss the old days. Like the Little House on the Pararie Days. 

Trinity --- 16 years ago -

Oh so they came out okay??

And yes, what an awesome neighbor. When we moved in 3 years ago, my neighbors then made us brownies. It was very nice. 

Trinity --- 16 years ago -

how did the cookies come out jessika? 

JessiKa yells roll tide --- 16 years ago -

They came out good. I just ate. Two actually. I went to get cookie cutters yesterday and on the box it had a super similar recipe on it for smaller quantity. 

ella --- 16 years ago -

Bite me jess =) 

ella --- 16 years ago -

Bite me jess =) 

lakej --- 16 years ago -

I made my neighbor some cookies when they moved in and every time I went to drop them off they weren't home! LOL! So we ended up eating them! I feel bad I have never remade them. but they have been here a month now and I feel kinda silly if I were to send them some now! 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lewis Underground