I was walkin out of the PX a few min ago, and some guy carring a baby no more than a month old, was yellin at this baby to "SHUT UP"
For 1: its a baby, dude. If you can't handle it. Wrap ur sh*t and you won't have that problem. I was actually considering taking the baby and walkin away and callin the MPs..
And YES I was walkin over to tell him what I was thinking. But my husband tightly grasped me arm and told me to mind my own buisness.
The guys wife was there also she walked up as I passed by and she took the kid and told him if he every yelled at her son like that again he can leave.
BOY I was HEATED..... He's freakin lucky... I don't take sh*t from people especially when it comes to kids. Mine or not. And when it comes to babies.. They can't defend themselves or protect themselves. You have no right yellin at a baby like that...
"I was actually considering taking the baby and walkin away and callin the MPs.."
I'm glad you didn't because if you had the MPs would be walking away with you, possibly in handcuffs.
"And YES I was walkin over to tell him what I was thinking. But my husband tightly grasped me arm and told me to mind my own buisness."
Your husband has good sense, listen to him.
"The guys wife was there also she walked up as I passed by and she took the kid and told him if he every yelled at her son like that again he can leave."
I'm glad to hear that the MOTHER handled HER business.
i think that she would have had every right in the name of safety for the child. what if the solider had shaken the baby and had died? she would have felt horrible for the rest of her life!
i know it would be good and bad both ways if theings were done different. and if he would have done anything else yea i would have yanked waway from my husband and took the baby away...
i dont deal with people verbally,mentally or physically abusing children
and a 1 month old baby when u yell in its face to shut up.. u have major issues
I agree that he was wrong, but if you had snatched his baby from him and walked away the situation would be bad for YOU not him.
Chances are good that if you approached the guy both the guy and his wife would have responded in a less than positive way turning a bad situation WAY worse.
But I'm glad that the mother did something. At least one parent appears to have some sense.
"what if the solider had shaken the baby and had died? "
In THAT case quickly snatching a baby out of a stranger's arms wouldn't turn into kidnapping charges. Until then I would advise never to snatch a child away from it's parent or guardian no matter if you intended to be a good Samaritan.
If someone snatched my child from my arms, there would be a beat down. The only situation that it would be ok to take a baby from its parents is if there is physical abuse.
Not to play devils advocate here, but being a mother myself, sometimes you are just so tired that you don't even realize what you say sometimes. NOT that he was right by any means, I'm just saying that when you've been up for 3 days straight you can't remember your name or the last time you took a shower, sometimes unkind words come out. I've looked at my son before and said a couple not nice words and apologized later for it...
kind of reminds me of something i saw in an article on parenting.com the other day. a flight attendant took a baby (i think 13 mos old?) away from her mother on the plane because she slapped her across the face for crying
unfortunatly some people have no sense anymore, i had a friend who had (past tense) a little girl i loved her to death but then she decided she was going to cheat on her hubby and leave him in massive debt that he has to re-pay because its all in his name, long story short, she ran off with some dude she barely knew for less than a week and goes back home to KY, now its been awhile, she had another baby by this dude and unfortunately lost it, and then RUNS OFF with the next newest dude to FL leaving her little girl in the appartment all alone!! Thankfully her parents went and got the girl and claimed her fully and needless to say my so called friend can no longer have her baby girl back because she was considered i guess not worthy or whatever that fancy word is lol
i think that she would have had every right in the name of safety for the child. what if the solider had shaken the baby and had died? she would have felt horrible for the rest of her life! i
Issues like this are best left to law enforcment..
Issues like this are best left to law enforcment..
eff that! no way in heck could i just stand by and do nothing if a child is getting abused. I mean yelling or spanking (within reason) not that it is always justified but that should be left alone. It's not the place of anyone other than the child's parents.
BUT some parents take it over board and then that is when the proper authorities should be contacted if the child is being mistreated.
kind like saying its 100 degrees outside and theres a baby in a car with the windows up and the car off hmmmm let me call the cops and watch this kid die... NO HELL NO
id break that window and get that kid out of that car...
What is it exactly that you think your going to do? Snatch a kid out of it's parents arms and "TADA" all is well? You gonna keep the kid? You call the police. They take a report... Family Advocacy is called and the parents can get the help they need or if the situation warrants it the children can then be removed. It is not your responsibility to do more than report. But hey.. if you feel facing criminal charges and potentially being taken away from your own family is worth it then who am I to judge... My comments are directed to the original post of a man yelling at an infant not a child gettin the tar beat out of them. Even then you address the parent and contact police.
Yeah... break a window, place the child in danger of shattering glass, and traumatize them more than they probably already are by being left alone in the vehicle. A simple call to 911 maybe a 3 minute wait and it can be solved by the police...
Yea but how will you know how long that child has already been in there. If you break the front windshield and a child is in the back it won't hurt them. Ask a cop and they will tell you to get that child out of there if you're able to...at least that's what the cops in my family would say. I think anyone who isn't willing to help another life should be ashamed of themselves. People risk their lives for strangers every day doing the right thing and they are heros in my eyes.
Sara that isn't meant to be rude towards you...so hopefully you won't take it that way, it'sjust my opinion from what I've seen with people and how they treat others.
He may have been yelling at the baby, in a way you would never do to your kid. But that definitely doesnt give you the right to PHYSICALLY put your hands on someone elses child and TAKE him from his parents. If I were that parent you would have another thing coming from this girl. There may have been a time where I have been over stressed, over tired, and the kids are taking advantage of this and raising all kinds of heck on me, I may react in a way I might not normally do and others may think im a crazy bad parent. But that does not mean my kids have ever or will ever be in any type of danger. So for a stranger to walk up and snatch my child. You can bet your arse they are asking for a beat down and/or possibly some nice little charges of attempting to kidnap my child.
Now, if the child was beat or left in the car unattended, thats a total different story... however that was not what this original post is about. Oh heck naw ding dong. That would not fly.. you dont put your hands on someone elses child unless you are asking for trouble.
how would u handle it sara... if you see some guy holding a screaming baby and yelling at it to shut up would u walk away? yea u can call the cops and the guy can just leave... the cops can take over 20 min to respond depends on whats happening at the moment..
make a report file charges and le the family adv people get involved sure then all this will get back to his COC he'll get in trouble go through parenting classes and anger management and maybe be a better parent and actully learn how to handle a kid...
Or you can just walk by like nothign ever happend.... its not ur kid, dont worry about it right!!
and in a week when Breaking News comes on this Army guys arrested for shaking baby syndrome or drowing his kid because he wouldnt stop crying...
hmmm what might have been... yea i know theres alot of ways to handle things but if im there and no one else will do anything ill step up and take care of it.... ill put myself at risk to make sure that baby doesnt get mistreated or hurt... i can defend myself that baby cant
sounds like the mother of the baby handled it just fine. She took HER baby from her husband and set him straight. You have no need to get involved because it was alraedy handled. Had you touched that child im pretty sure both mom and dad of the baby would have not reacted so well to that.
if im there and no one else will do anything ill step up and take care of it.... ill put myself at risk to make sure that baby doesnt get mistreated or hurt... i can defend myself that baby cant
While this is admirable and all, Im just wondering how your 5 kids would feel without their mom because shes behind bars from assault (which is what you could potentially be accused of) because there is no real good way to take a child from their parents, lol. And if the cops did show, what would you say? He yelled at his kid! I think they would laugh honestly and it I don't think it would fly in court...I think they would ask who you were, do you have any proof of abuse and why do you care.
I still don't get how anyone would conclude that snatching a baby from a parent's arm because they are yelling at him/her and walking away with the baby would have a good outcome. Assault charges, kidnapping charges, a good old-fashioned beat down in front of the baby and every other child in the area..that I can imagine. But in what reality would a cop not arrest a person after they took a child because the parent was yelling at the child.
Good intentions don't excuse wrong actions. I guess some people have to learn the hard way.
If I yelled at one of my kids, for ANYTHING, and someone tried to verbally "set me straight", and it wasn't someone in my family, You can bet you would get a big old "F*ck off it's not your child".
Now if you tried to TAKE my child, you would probably end up in the hospital with something broken, and have kidnapping charges against you. Trust me. I've done it. And because YOU took MY child, and that child was not in any immediate physical harm, I would get away scott free. Now if the child was found to have an unusual amount of bruising, or broken bones... I would not get away scott free... but you would still have kidnapping charges on you.
Do you want to risk losing your children over some kidnapping charges that will happen weather your right or not?
Look ladies; she was venting. You don't have to jump on her about it, BUT I can tell that if something goes haywire, it would be here that I would want working on it becuase the lot of you that keep harping on her wouldn't give a flying flip. Lets just leave it be already? This is getting just about as bad as the whole attitude filled teen babysitting post... let just STOP ok?
That "attitude filled" teen had every right to defend herself IMO, shes a friend of mine...and ssg was the first to jump on her about over-posting, the"rules", lol...in fact ssg jumps on just about everyone, what goes around comes around I guess...