Lewis Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lewis bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Fort Lewis housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Costco Vs. Sam's Club Vs. regular stores (Walmart, Target, etc)

who's talking here?

Heather T 1
Misty P. 2
Amy L 5
Leslie 2
Shelley 1
mcdirty 1
JenJ 1
C&J's Mommy 2
sensesfailrockergirlyahoocom 1
Eliz 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

C&J's Mommy --- 16 years ago -

I'm debating whether or not to renew any of my memberships at the warehouses, but was wondering.. in your own experience, which was better for you? And why? 

Amy L --- 16 years ago -

We have a costco membership, use it for meat and diapers. Not a bad deal compared to what we save. We shop at the comm. for everything else. Albertsons usually has a buy 1 get one free or really cheap hamburger, chicken at the butcher block, so we watch the ads and shop there as well. 

Misty P. --- 16 years ago -

We have Costco...Its great for toilet paper, paper towels, laundry soap, kitty litter and misc stuff you wont find at the commissary. I just got 4 pairs of those comfy Adidas track pants/capris for 10-20 dollars a pair, and they are cute with different color stripes. They only time we get toilet paper, paper towels or laundry soap at the commissary is at the caselot sales. Also, when you buy computers/laptops from Costco...you automatically get the extended two year full warrenty. 

Amy L --- 16 years ago -

good point about the electronics. 

JenJ --- 16 years ago -

I read an article on yahoo once that said if you don't buy everything in bulk (Think Jon & Kate plus 8 haha), that's it's really a waste of money. They broke it down financially, I can't remember everything, but from what I remember, it made sense. But I guess I really don't know since I've never been a member of Sam's or Costco. I'm a Target girl at heart 

Leslie --- 16 years ago -

it all depends on what you have (as far as couponing) as to whether or not it's good to buy in bulk. I went to a couponing class and she said she'll go sometimes and buy $50 worth of stuff and only spend a couple of dollars (i've seen the receipt. It's all about paying attention to the adds and what not. I have costco and I like it, I've never had a sam's card though. We drink soda and it's cheaper there, unless there's a sale going on, also paper products. I did find that Target or PX diapers are cheaper then costco though. But their water's the cheapest. All of this is not based on sales. Anyway, if you really want to get into couponing (too much work for me lol) here's the website and she gives you all the great deals going on in our area. http://queenbeecoupons.com/ 

Amy L --- 16 years ago -

We cant buy generic diapers for our daughter so Costco has the best deal for the amount in the box, that I have found anyway. Coupons are great, but like Leslie, I dont have the time..lol Right now, Alberstons has bacon buy 1 get 1 free, and thats a great deal!! lol 

Leslie --- 16 years ago -

yeah, their huggies and pampers deals are awesome! :) I wish with my first son we could have had a card! lol I tried the whole coupon thing for a month amy... and well yeah, I just gave up and threw them all away! i do like bacon! lol Stupid question... where's the closest Albertsons? 

Amy L --- 16 years ago -

Lakewood, on steilacoom blvd. Pick up one of their ads, theres other buy 1 get 1 deals too. 

C&J's Mommy --- 16 years ago -

Okay. Thanks for all of your input on that. I am thinking whether or not it's worth paying the $50 to renew. I mean.. if you think about it in savings.. things are cheaper in bulk hands down, but... that $50 that I paid towards membership... is that going to save me at all in the long run? I should probably try it for another year and keep track of the amount of money I save every time I purchase items at Costco and check the prices at Walmart/Target to see if they're worth it. I know I can save a bunch if I shop wisely but I do love buying in bulk to save me numerous trips to other stores.. and I was once a coupon person, but I don't have the time or patience to clip them and pick out the ones that I need. I only keep diapers, wipes, and formula coupons with me at all times.. 

Amy L --- 16 years ago -

I absolutely think its worth the 50.00. You save more then that usually on one trip. But keeping track is a great way to see your savings. 

Shelley --- 16 years ago -

The only time I had a membership anywhere was at Sams and it was only because my mom owned a store and just put my sister and I both in for memberships since we worked for her off and on. Now coupons, I LOVE coupons and always save a bunch of money when grocery shopping with them. I cut ones out of the sunday paper but I mostly go online and print coupons for things I use to take with me. I most usually save more than double my surcharge anytime I go and to me that is more than worth the time it takes me (which is actually very little) to get the coupons. 

sensesfailrockergirlyahoocom --- 16 years ago -

costco is worth it for all the samples!! lol we just renewed ours, but we half it with my parents in ca so they have one card and me and my hubby have the other one! it really depends on what you buy, i get dog food there..i used to pay 40 bucks a bag, now i pay 25 for the same quality just kirkland brand. but i did buy tide for 24 i think and saw it at target for 19 on sale, so just depends on what it is 

mcdirty --- 16 years ago -

our family is costco all the way. my hubby's mom is a marketing manager for a costco on the east coast. one of the things that got us to commit to costco was when she told us how most of the kirkland brand stuff is produce by the same company as the mainstream brand. (for example, huggies makes kirkland diapers) I have found over and over that costco items are higher quality than sams/walmart. But i will say one thing about costcos in this area, the customer service just isnt what Im used to in the south! 

Eliz --- 16 years ago -

we have costco and i am really good at remembering prices from where we used to shop (walmart). i do know that the razors there are not cheaper. the fusion and mach ones. we get dishwasher det., toilet paper, carrots (we and our dogs eat alot), and snacky foods. we have spend close to the same, but we have more quantity. bulk isn't good if you actually aren't going to use it. and so some things aren't realistic for us to get... 100,000 lbs of flour we don't need :) 

Eliz --- 16 years ago -

we have costco and i am really good at remembering prices from where we used to shop (walmart). i do know that the razors there are not cheaper. the fusion and mach ones. we get dishwasher det., toilet paper, carrots (we and our dogs eat alot), and snacky foods. we have spend close to the same, but we have more quantity. bulk isn't good if you actually aren't going to use it. and so some things aren't realistic for us to get... 100,000 lbs of flour we don't need :) 

Eliz --- 16 years ago -

we have costco and i am really good at remembering prices from where we used to shop (walmart). i do know that the razors there are not cheaper. the fusion and mach ones. we get dishwasher det., toilet paper, carrots (we and our dogs eat alot), and snacky foods. we have spend close to the same, but we have more quantity. bulk isn't good if you actually aren't going to use it. and so some things aren't realistic for us to get... 100,000 lbs of flour we don't need :) 

Misty P. --- 16 years ago -

Dont forget the 90 return policy at Costco...nobody beats that. 

Heather T --- 16 years ago -

I really like Costco. They have great fruit/veggies. :) I love buying the big bag of romaine lettuce for under $2 when at the commissarry one bunch iss like $1.79. In the summer their watermelons are a great price as well. I also love thier desserts. :) 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lewis Underground