Lewis Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lewis bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Fort Lewis housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Advice.. how would you handle this?

who's talking here?

goddessanne 1
Athena 2
Elise 1
chicquila 2
Susan 4
lotsokids 1
JustcallmeSuz 2
whitwhit 2
Liverpool 1
HisGoddess 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Susan --- 17 years ago -

I take a speech class, there are 45 students in my class. Let's just say only 6 of us really speak up in class when asked questions.( IT IS NOT a public speaking class). Well there is one girl in class who has something to say after EVERY comment the teacher makes and insists on using profanity in class. Several of us have gone to instructor about this. We were told we "dominate" the class by speaking up, due to classmates know if they do not speak up, we will ( we get graded on participation in class). So we decided to be silent today in class. Well said female decided to make rude comment in class against another one and let us just say the whole thing could of been avoided if he talked to the student about her vulgarity yesterday or before class. WE had a pretty heated argument that winded up outside class and she tried to get her husband ( ex marine) involved. Several of us are upset that the instructor did not handle this differently. What would you do at this point. Basically he is telling us not to speak up in class, and then got upset that we wouldnt speak up today. Is that not giving us mixed signals? 

Athena --- 17 years ago -

I would go to the principle with this issue. It is the teachers job to make sure that all the students are able to learn. If comments she was saying caused a fight then thats not ok. 

Susan --- 17 years ago -

there is no principal in college.. only a dean. 

Susan --- 17 years ago -

there is no principal in college.. only a dean. 

Athena --- 17 years ago -

there is no principal in college.. only a dean. 1.)Well then the dean. I forgot what they were called. My brain is fried today. So sorry. Go to them. Explain what happened. That due to this persons actions it caused disruption in the class and the teacher at this time has not done anything to solve said problem. 2.) Go into either the guidance councilor or some other like person and tell them the situation maybe they can give better advice. 3.) Write a letter in detail to the teacher, explain how his actions have been out of line and he needs to fix it. 

JustcallmeSuz --- 17 years ago -

Sorry, but your in freaking college....not in middle school....just ignore this person. 

lotsokids --- 17 years ago -

I would ask the teacher how your going to get any credit for participation if your not supposed to speak up... 

chicquila --- 17 years ago -

Well first of all surely do NOT ignore it. I don't care what grade or school you are in, inappropriate behavior and language is unacceptable and needs to be dealt with accordingly. Especially when it is making everyone else feel uncomfortable and hindering the learning process of others. I agree with going to the dean if need be. Surely you can relate most civilian things like jobs and school to the military. Everywhere you go there is a system in place for a reason...a "chain of command" if you will. If you sit back and do nothing, then nothing will ever be accomplished. Point blank. 

Elise --- 17 years ago -

I would be upset too. I hate overly vulgar people because to me that is immature and ignorant. There are more effective ways to communicate as far as I am concerned; especially a grown woman in college. I would make sure that you talk to a counselor and note what the teacher told you about not speaking and your concern on what that will do with your grade concerning participation. That way if your grade goes down you have a 3rd party there to vouch on your behalf and you can fight it. Sounds like the teacher might be a bit timid and not want to confront the student.... just my opinion. 

JustcallmeSuz --- 17 years ago -

Well, that was my opinion on the matter....she can take it or not. I just think if its ONE person causing the issue, to ignore her will take away any power she thinks she has....sometimes thats all it takes. 

Liverpool --- 17 years ago -

I would begin by ignoring this person. If, however, that doesn't work and she is a true distraction to your "educational environment" then definitely talk to the professor's department head. And if participation is so important to your final grades, what will happen to the other 39 people who don't speak up? Will their grades suffer, or are the 6 participants going to carry the class? 

chicquila --- 17 years ago -

I feel you there missing, not downplaying your advice at all. From what I was gathering, they tried to ignore her, but she kept on. That is why I said what I did. 

whitwhit --- 17 years ago -

Susan I totally understand what you are saying. I have a girl in my cal class that seems to think she is the teacher and the teacher won't grow a pair and tell her to back off. Just remember no one can bother you unless you let them so just ignore the girl. I waited for the girl to smart off in class again and then politely said "Excuse me i don't mean to be rude but i'm paying tuition for Mr "smith" to teach this class. So i would appreciate it if you would kindly keep your comments to yourself unless you have something to add to the subject that you can convey in a more respectful manner." Let's just say it put her in her place and she only comments if she has a legitimate question now. You might try something like that if it really bothers you that bad. But remember you need to be respectful even if she isn't. Besides the quarter is close to over so you could probly just grin and bear if for a few more weeks. 

goddessanne --- 17 years ago -

From my experience, deans won't usually get involved in situations like this. They see it too often. Honestly, they don't care for the nitty gritty of the classroom environment. Deans mainly prioritize making sure their college department is up and running. I would just try again to speak with the professor to address the situation. He is the one who wrote the specifics of his syllabus so he has to deal with its flaws. (If he is an adjunct professor then maybe talk to the head professor of the department if you absolutely must.) While every student has the right of speech, she should keep in mind that college students should be professional and respectful. More importantly, she crossed the line by bringing in her husband into the situation. Her husband is not a student in the class so he had no right. If it is what it is, then you will just have to wait until the end of the course for the evaluation. Be honest about the professor evaluation. Those are what the dean looks at. Issues within the evaluation will be shown to the professor anonymously. Whitwhit comments are really good as well. 

Susan --- 17 years ago -

several of us have gone to the instructor as well as tried to talk to the individual about our "issue" with her. She just does not care. As far as how the instructor handled it, it will reflect in his end of school survey. He knows there are many that are upset how class ended on Friday. I just do not think he knew what to do in the situation, as he has only taught at our college for I believe this is going on his 2nd year. I appreciate everyone's advice. And WhitWhit. Remember you and I go to same campus LOL 

whitwhit --- 17 years ago -

lol! I know! Maybe it's just the way the teachers at our campus decide to run their class. I personally wouldn't put up with the girls' antics if it were my class room! You aren't having much luck with this speech class are you?!?! Hopefully next semester will be easier for you. I always use ratemyprofessor.com to pick my professors and I've always found the information to be acurate for the most part. Maybe when you are making your schedule for next semester you could try it. Thanks for the mention goddesanne! 

HisGoddess --- 17 years ago -

Well, I would do all of the above personally... and hiding behind her "ex-marine" husband is just pathetic... She backed herself into a corner and tried to hide... Obviously extremely insecure about her position in life 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

help

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lewis Underground