It is extremely over diagnosed. And when parents hear it they think their child is doomed in life. They put them on meds to help "fix" their child and it only makes them worse. My nieces got diagnosed with it last week. My sister is pissed off that they will not put her on meds because she is only 5. My niece is a bright girl. She loves to play outside and yes has a hard time sitting still but if you saw this girls diet you would know why. I have never not seen her eat food that is wholesome and actually good for her. She lives off fruit snacks, pop, roman noodles, boxed mac n cheese and the occasional pizza. When she is in school her teachers say she only eats the dessert and never drinks her milk. My sister is 340lbs and eats non stop and is not active at all. She is teaching her girls to be the same way. I understand that its hard to loose weight but to handicap your children is just wrong. She is now taking her to another doctor to get her put on meds. I think in this situation a change in diet would go a long way!!
EEEK!!! I defiantly think foods are coming into play with your niece. My oldest son who is 9 was just informally diagnosed w/ ADD. He started medications only on school days. He doesnt have any behavior problems and he isnt overly hyper thank goodness! We tried EVERYTHING with him from diet to sleeping habits. Nothing else has worked. He is a repeat second grader this year and is still below grade level. I really wish we would have tried medication sooner for him. I am already noticing a HUGE difference with his concentration!!! We aren't ruling out a sensory problem, but there is a loooong waiting list to see the speech therapist for an evaluation. So far for his medication has been a life saver!
I think there is such a thing as SERIOUS ADD/ADHD, BUT... I think MOST of the cases these days are just kids who don't have a outlet for all of the energy they have, or are on a constant sugar overload.
i have 3 kids who are adhd and several in my family are add and I can tell the difference between those who are and those who's parents just want help controlling their child. My kids are medicated and after seeing how my cousins turned out who were not I choose to listen to my doctor.... after all he is professionaly trained. Its not easy to get a diagnosis... there is paperwork involved and testing done and then the options for treatment are discussed so many of these kids are actually properly diagnosed unlike about 10 years ago.
I agree CS. In one of my previous psych classes we were talking about this very subject. I think it's important for a full work up to be done to test for vitamin deficiencies and other issues before being diagnosed with a behavioral problem. I know a lot has gone into giving my son the diagnoses and it's still not set in stone because there are so many other possibilities to rule out!
Nancy, See i like your attitude your son is neither doomed or going to fail life. You tried everything before meds and there is a pretty good chance he will catch up. As you said there are problem other issues as well. Good luck girl, and yes with my niece it is a diet issue and I know nothing about the issue, the 3 years working with kids who had variations of it or the semester in college I took on how to teach kids will disabilities taught me nothing but my sister who has a computer degree knows more than myself. Oh well
if the doc isnt wanting to medicate then they most likely wanna see if she will outgrow it. ADD is pretty rare in females once they get a little older.
I personally get tired of everyone making statements abouth the kids with ADD and ADHD and how many act like it is not a legitimate condition. Believe me if anyone thinks that Ill leave my boys off their meds for two days and send them to their house.... their opinion will change fast.
See that makes no sense!! My son went to several appointments with a psychologist and we filled out mountains of paper work, including his teachers....Then we went to an MD. and she still wasnt 100% sure about putting Brendan on the medication. He is on the lowest dose and doing wonderful!!! Well he does have one side affect because it is a stimulant.
I'm shocked a Dr. would hand that out with no formal testing....?!
I'm doing my psych degree online and there is still so much I don't know. Even once I have the diploma; it still isn't the same as actual experience in a given field. It's so strange that your sister would push for this; you would think most parents would resist the ADD label. Not trying to be nosey! I'm just shocked I guess!
LOL Age,
My son is only taking the medication on school days, but there have been days he is home that I'm tempted! He behaves wonderfully at school, not so much at home. Sometimes I have to tell him 100 times to stop doing something before it finally sinks in. He isn't ignoring me, the thought process just isn't there. He also repeats himself over and over and over till your ears are going to bleed or it will take him an hour to get a sentence out. But on the medication it's like night and day!!!
oh no if mine are off their meds its actually dangerous. We are talking classic fascination with knives, matches and tearing things up. My oldest is just now getting to where we can take him off his meds during the summer because he is growing out of that part. I knew with him there was something wrong at 2 but the docs wouldnt listen and by the time someone did listen 5 years later when they offered meds I jumped on it, no hesitation.
Well Age it would appear that we are going to have to agree to disagree here. I am not here to argue with you about ADD/ADHD or kids or your situation or anyone elses on here but just vent a frustration. I have and will never say its not a valid condition. Because it is. There would not be classes/degrees set up just to help/deal/learn about just that ADD/ADHD if it is bogus. But it is over diagnosed. And over medicated. Your statement that doctors know best is 100% wrong. I started college with the hopes of getting my BSN. However after 2 year of working in a hospital and after having my son my eyes were opened as to how much doctors are quakes. There are good ones. But now a days in a money filled society it is no longer about helping others but helping themselves. Labs give tons of money "kick backs" to docs who give meds. Again not here to argue.
My problem with this situation is now she has the diagnosis and yes he may not medicate but with a parent and teach who are fighting for meds they will get them and that is wrong, she needs to have a dietitian help her but thats not going to happen.
Nancy, your son sounds a lot like my daughter! I worry about her so much. She doesn't act wild or anything, she just I think has a hard time concentrating. She also has a hard time keeping organized and hates to play outside or do any type of exercise. She is hurting in school as well and I am afraid she may not pass third grade this year. Last year her teacher told me that out of 100 kids 99 of them are doing better than your daughter. She also told me that she wanted to test her for special education because of her speech. I was soooo upset! I was telling myself that nothing is wrong with her speech and maybe if she got more one on one time she would be ok. They ended up testing her and said she was fine and that there was no need for special education, thanks God! I've thought about taking her to a doctor but don't really want to put her on meds. I just don't know what to do...
They put them on meds to help "fix" their child and it only makes them worse. My nieces got diagnosed with it last week. My sister is pissed off that they will not put her on meds because she is only 5.
THANKYOU!! SOMEONE WHO SEES THAT MEDS ARE BADDDD!!!
My brother was diagnosed with ADHD when he was like 4, I believe. When he was older, (*18*) he had to come down from them. His insurance went away and he could no longer afford to get them. He told me: when he came down off of Ridilin it was HORRIBLE!! He did get into harder drugs. He said coming off of Meth was EASIER than weaning off of Ridilan!
I think adhd has ONLY to do with the parents, and NOT how the child is. They are only out of hand because YOU let them!! :)
I think people should really LOOK INTO the affects of medication for add adhd, before exposing their children to drugs!
There are some medications that are good. Ridilan is a rather nasty one though. They tried to put my husband on it recently and it was an ugly time. He's not on it anymore.
i totally agree with you guys 100% and they are doing it with autism now, too. any kid that doesn't really pay attention and stares off (and whose kid doesn't at some point?) they are putting it on the spectrum.
my brother who is 20 has really bad ADHD. and he is on meds, but i have seen him off and he really needs them. my aunt as well. but that's it. out of all the ppl i know those are the only 2 i think need it.
i don't want anyone to get upset with me bc i do think they need it. there are some ppl who just need medicine (severe mental disorders and even common stuff) i do think society is just too dependent on modern medicine, but it does have a place.
i was going to say something else, but forgot:)
i was going to say something else, but forgot:)
LOL! I do that all the time... Type out my opinion, and then go to add something else, and go "um...duuuhhh....crap.."
Liz,
When the school first mentioned special education and testing Brendan for an IEP, I think my heart sank. I try so hard with my kids, I mean I spend every waking moment living for them. But after I calmed down I learned how good an IEP can be, there is so much extra help that comes with it! Help that kids without an IEP don't get b/c there just isn't enough funding. I was soooo reluctant to medicate! But now I feel bad that I didn't do it sooner because Brendan is so far behind. The sad thing is he tries so hard and you can't reward or punish him for his work because off medication he honestly could not do any better.
Age,
That sounds A LOT like my middle son. He will fly into fits and start destroying things. One day it was so bad he ripped a pair of jeans in 1/2. Its crazy b/c he is such a small sweet little boy, but make him mad and you better stay out of his way. He is now doing bad in school too, which he has always loved it before. He is also super hyper. I don't think he stops moving EVER even when he is sleeping!! But I do think a lot of what is going on with him can be changed with cognitive therapy! If we can get his anger under control or at least find out the triggers things will be so much easier!
LOL! I do that all the time... Type out my opinion, and then go to add something else, and go "um...duuuhhh....crap.."
it's just been a long day for me:P i haven't been sleeping well again, but i really didn't like the medicine i took several years ago. i sleep walked among other sleep things :/
The sad thing is he tries so hard
that would just break my heart nancy
athena I actually think we do agree on some things and in this case I have to support the dr and you in the initial diagnosis and treatment method. No that child should not be medicated if the dr says no and thinks there are better ways. My statements werent directed to you but more as a vent as well. I am lucky I have had some good Dr's with my kids and their treatment. I also didnt just go to a gen physician for diagnosis like so many do... my kids were seen by psychologists and child behaviroal specialists.
Shoot when my 13 yr old was in 2nd or 3rd grade her principal told me that I should get her tested for add/adhd and even tried to get me to put her in LD classes. "I" did not listen because even though she had some issues on the "common sense" aspect of things and a bit of quirky behavoir, she did excellent when it came to her grades. Well she is 13 now and still getting good grades and doing just fine. I agree that diet can have a lot to do with it. That's why junk food is a rarity in my house, but the fridge is stocked with apples, oranges, kiwi, grapes, and bananas on the counter. Plus yogurt and string cheese. I am in pain just about everyday and even I still don't take pills lol. So I am really funny about medications for my kids.
I think adhd has ONLY to do with the parents, and NOT how the child is. They are only out of hand because YOU let them!! :)
I repeat I will take my boys off their meds for 2 days and send them to you. IF your house is not burnt down I will be surprised. MY husband and I are darn good parents and we dont let them get out of hand but when there is a chemical imbalance resulting in a loss of impulse control a parent cant always watch what they are doing. DO you want to know how many nights my husband and I didnt sleep because we had to watch their EVERY move? You have no clue what it is like and how dare you make that generalized statement! I pray your children are never touched by this condition but seriously get educated. BTW it is genetic and comes through the mothers side.
She actually is in extra math and reading classes already but doesn't help. I will sit down with her to try helping with her homework but I get so frustrated that I just want to pull my hair out! I have been looking into maybe getting a tutor but gosh they are so expensive and I can't afford anything close to what they charge. I spoke with my mom (who I haven't really spoke to in 3 years) and I was telling her about my concerns with Hailie. She told me that she was the same way growing up and how hard it was for her to keep up in school, her desk was always a mess and she just couldn't keep up. She is a manic depressive and takes tons of meds. I think that is why I am so hesitant to put her on anything but as she was explaining how she grew up it sounded like she was talking about Hailie! What were your first steps? Did you just bring it up to his pediatrician and go from there?
Liz, you can mention it to your dr but ask them to refer you to a child behavioral specialist. They are better educated on those types of things. Also, make sure you get statements from her teacher and any other caregiver so they get an accurate idea of what is going on. I myself didnt notice some of my sons symptoms but the teacher did. This also helps to prevent a misdiagnosis for any condition. Even IF she is diagnosed she may not need meds. We tried the therapy and other methods also and for some it really works. I know of some parents with ADHD children who simply use caffeine to control their milder cases.
Wow age I didn't even see that statement. That's wrong to blame the parents. I mean yea there are some parents that need to step up their game when it comes to being a god parent, this issue has NOTHING to do with that.
BTW I have a good friend whose son is autistic and when they diagnosed him he was severe/moderate I think it's called but now he is about 10 or 11 and pretty much fully functional and she NEVER medicated him, she used herbal, aroma as well as some other therpaies along with good old patience, but that does not necessarily work for everyone. I think you have to really evaluate the child and situation as a whole and do what works best for them overall.
chic I agree, every child is different and their treatment is supposed to be customized. I am really lucky that our dr's have been really good and I also educated myself on it as well so we havent had any problems. My middle son was the last to be diagnosed because I was in complete denial. You would think with two already medicated and knowing it is genetic I would be more open but I wasnt. Once he was suspended from school I couldnt argue anymore. Now he is 100% better... an honor student and truly loved by his teachers so I know we are doing this right. I just get soooooooo ticked when people blame our parenting skills... I have enough guilt knowing I passed this on to them in their genes I dont need that crap too.
Yea well don't sweat it age "I" know you are a good mom just from the few times I have been around you and your fam, and above all else YOU know you are so screw the peanut gallery lmao! Put em in the grinder and make peanut butter lol. :))
Parents are not to blame. I thought that at first but my hubby finally helped me realize that this was not my fault. I am just mostly worried about school. I want her to do well and become successful. She tries so hard and nothing gets through to her, bless her heart...
Liz,
Age knows way more on this subject than I do since we just started this journey, but my advice would be similar. It was actually my sons reading teacher that had talked to me about getting him tested. She is so wonderful with them and can see how hard Brendan is struggling. Since she specializes in children with difficulty reading and spends more one on one time with him, I think she has a better idea of what he is going through. Once she had told me I should consider getting him tested to check all our bases, I called tricare and got a referral to a child psychologist. We go to Dr. Callies in Oly. LOVE HIM! From there all the testing started. Brendan, his teachers, and myself had to fill out tons of questionnaires. I meant w/ the Dr. alone, and then Brendan got a chance to go in. After all that he wrote a report for our Dr. and we went to see her.
I agree with Age, there are other options besides medication. I think it would be best just to touch all bases. Brendan has times where he completely goes into his own world and just gives a blank stare. This has been going on since he was very young, but like I said I didn't want to medicate. Heck I would have never thought ADD until recently when I actually started researching it. I'm just so happy with his progress so far!! Instead of it taking over an hour to do 10 homework problems it only took 20 minutes! That is huge for us!