Has anyone had any problems with someone stealing pictures from your LYS and posting the same picture? Would you have a problem with this? My concern is I'm selling items and I don't want people to see two of the same picture and think one is a scam. I've asked the lady to remove it and get her picture from fisher price or someone else and she said it's the internet and it's posted. She refused to take it down.
it is a federal law that once a photo exist, it is copyright to the photographer. you could get her in alot of trouble for this.
http://www.kodak.com/cluster/global/en/consumer/doingMore/copyright.shtml
Yes, that is copyright infringement. I know much about this being a photographer myself and having drawn up legal docs in the past for my freelancing. The only option it seems you have is to report it like everyone else said here.
Kristie, I never thought about the whole copyright thing. I would write that lady and tell her it's copyright and see what she says to that. Maybe she just didn't think anything about it.
I decided I'm not going to write this lady anymore. LYS can deal with her. She thinks I'm rude and I have been nothing but nice. Just thought I'd warn others. I was mad for her taking my picture but it's more that I don't want someone to see the same picture twice and think it's the same person. Thanks for your comments everyone I'll let you know what LYS tells me.
at least she's using it for a 'wanted' ad. ive seen ppl steal pics on CL before to sell things! i really hate when ppl post an item and use a pic of something and it doesn't even end up being the real item!
I think she never intended to hurt anyone and felt like she was in the right. I don't think she thought twice about it. Which is not right by any stretch of the imagination. She did seem like she would come off rude to you Kristi. As she did at first to me as well. But it would appear she does plan on taking the picture off. I hope this helps. I just dont think people know the law of photography. Its something I run into all the time ;)
I did :) This is what was said. It goes from what I most recently said to what she said in response to what I wrote her from the add. Sorry so confusing :)
Rebekah,
Its a copy right law. You take the picture you own the picture. Look at it this way. What if I found a picture of your children on say your myspace page or anywhere else and started posting them all over the web or even if you don't post pics of them online I took one off your wall in your house and put it on my wall. Those are your photos not mine and I have no rights to them and it would be stealing. Just like with Sears, JcPennys or any other studio you go to they take the picture they have the right to them, you can only buy prints unless you purchase the right to them. Weather you are an amateur photographer or professional they are still your photos and you have rights to them. I am sure him/her will be glad to hear that.
http://www.kodak.com/cluster/global/en/consumer/doingMore/copyright.shtml
Check this link out.
Sorry this what such a hassle for you. But it seems you learned your lesson and it was never intended to hurt the photographer.
Good luck with the search.
Athena
Rebekah Tappendick
to me
show details 3:22 PM (24 minutes ago)
Reply
Follow up message
Well I guess thanks for telling me it's against a law. I didn't know that, and really don't see why...but in that case I'll be taking it down. I still can't see the harm in it, but really don't feel like dealing with it.
--- On Thu, 7/16/09, russaadathena@gmail.com wrote:
From: russaadathena@gmail.com
Subject: Re: WTB kids chairs (sturdy, hard plastic)
To: rebekahtappendick@yahoo.com
Date: Thursday, July 16, 2009, 5:57 PM
===============================================
Yay! This is a message from a user on the wildly fun Lewis Yard Sales.
Note the notes at the bottom of this note. Noted? User message:
===============================================
I would if I were you take the picture you currently have posted for this add down. As in the add you clearly state that you stole the picture. This is highly illegal with out written permission from the photographer. Weather he/she is professional or not its still his/her photo and you could be facing a hefty penalty fine. Is it really worth a chair? Go online find the stock photos of this. If you cant find it then describe it in detail in the add and if some has it then they will probably know what you are talking about. Or you should of asking the photographer from the get go if it was ok to borrow the pic.
cut the crap---it is only a copyright infrigement if you have registered and paid for a COPYRIGHT. otherwise it is just someone copying a picture. In a free forum such as this you would be wasting time trying to get someone busted for copyright infringement. This is a YARD SALE site. all of you livingroom lawyers crack me up.
no I am saying that a picture posted on this site is not COPYRIGHTED. A copyright requires that you register it and place the C symbol on it with a date. I agree that stealing a picture is bad conduct, I am laughing at the ones calling it "copyright infringement" and "illegal" and act like they KNOW the law. Its silly to say it when yo dont know what you are talikng about. Show me the LOSS created by a copied picture an a YARDSALE sit? it does not exist
Sue them for what? If you are in a public place...your picture can be taken...no problems....untill they make money on the picture or post it with a caption that is Sladerous you have NOTHING
Angel - I think you are misunderstanding. If a photographer takes your photograph that image is their property. They can sell you prints or sell you either limited or unlimited rights to the image meaning you can print multiple copies, post online, etc. If you choose not to buy from the photographer that does not enable them to use it however they see fit. They may own the rights to the image, but without your written consent an image of you may not be used in almost any way. No one can charge you to not use your picture - that sounds more like blackmail. LOL
Chad - A copyright does not have to be registered in order to be valid. And it still qualifies as infringement even if it is not filed. However, if you want to file an infringement lawsuit you would have to go through the trouble of filing. Copyrights are generally meant to protect artists, writers, musicians and others dealing in creative works. I think this is not quite there but definitely annoying and possibly against the TOS?
A picture posted on yard sale site hardly qualifies you as a "photographer" by trade. Again, show the "loss" suffered...none. Therefore quit being so dramatic....It was not "illegal", nor does it meet the threshold for "Copyright Infringemnt"...bad taste, maybe.....a crime? NOT EVEN CLOSE
The only loss I can think of is if someone took your picture of an item your selling, posted it as a picture for the item their selling, and posted it for lower price then you...hmmmm....lol. But yeah, no matter what you want to call it, it was still bad conduct. But at least it was for a wanted ad...which by the way...why didn't she just BUY it from you???
I think Kristie was more concerned about people thinking it's a scam. Same person with mulitple accounts posting again and again. That would be her "LOSS" chad. If someone decided not to buy from her cause she was a scammer. And Chad... are you telling me you can take pictures of your kids and post them on the internet and then I can take those pictures and put them wherever I want to without even asking you? I know that a child is more serious then a chair, but it's the same thing... it's a picture you took and you wouldn't like someone else taking your picture without asking. So it may not be 'illegal' in your eyes... but it sure as crap is rude and disrespectful!
And I agree Misty, why didn't she just buy from Kristie? lol
I agree with Chad. I don't think there's really anything you can do about it. It's rude to steal people's pics but people can be rude and that's life.
As I always say 'Drink water, drive on' lol.
ok I was gonna stay out of this but heres the deal... posting photos on the internet places them in the public which makes them accessible for others use unless it is marked. Ever noticed how the police dont need warrants for photos on public sites? Its because its public domain. Yes this girl was in porr taste and yes it is weird to take others photos off the internet and use them but unless you expressly state do not use or make the site non private then its free game. This includes your kids pictures. That is why myspace and other sites allow you the option to be private.